After reconsidering, Travis County decides women’s jail still necessary


Highlights

Critics had wanted the county to expand jail diversion programs rather than build a new facility.

Sheriff says new facility is needed because current one is in poor shape and awkward for female inmates.

Five months after activists held up a Travis County Commissioners Court vote on initial funding of a new women’s jail facility as they pushed instead for more diversion programs, identical funding reappeared in a preliminary budget that staffers presented at a budget hearing Thursday.

Travis County Sheriff Sally Hernandez has said the facility within the Del Valle jail is needed because the county’s current facilities are in poor physical shape. The setup splits the female population into four facilities, she said, which is inefficient and at times uncomfortable for the women who have to walk through men’s facilities.

But community criminal justice reform advocates said there was more the county could do to keep people out of jail before resorting to an expansion, such as increasing mental health, substance abuse and other support services.

In March, at the activists’ urging, the Commissioners Court postponed a decision whether to spend $6.6 million to design the facility, giving staffers time to evaluate diversion programs and study ways to reduce the jail population.

READ ALSO: Travis County commissioners to hold off on women’s jail expansion

The funding for the design, which would be paid for with nonvoter-approved bonds, is part of a larger $616 million master plan recommended by consultants in 2015.

The facility would include classrooms for “gender-specific programming” and a satellite clinic for addressing women’s health issues, reducing the need for correctional officers to escort women to other buildings and off-campus, according to a 2018 update to the plan.

Last month, the county’s Justice Planning Department and community advocates presented to commissioners an asset map they created that lays out existing diversion programs and available data on outcomes.

Staffers highlighted programs such as the batterer’s intervention and prevention program, an intervention for defendants with domestic violence charges. About 8 percent of participants between 2014 and 2016 were rearrested within a year of the program compared with 22 percent of those who didn’t participate.

They also pointed to some of the county’s new programs, including the driving without a valid license program, which reduces a misdemeanor charge if a person gets his license, and a possession of marijuana class for people arrested for less than 2 ounces of marijuana in exchange for no charge being filed.

The city of Austin, the report also noted, in June passed “Freedom City” resolutions that call for police to work to end most discretionary arrests for nonviolent misdemeanors, which happen when an officer chooses to arrest someone for an offense that could have been resolved with a ticket, in an effort to reduce racial disparities.

READ ALSO: Austin City Council approves ‘Freedom City’ resolutions

AND City action would target racial disparity in Austin police arrests

“The need for a new women’s facility has not gone away,” said Allison Fink, planning project manager, in an interview. “The asset map showed that not for every single program do we have measures that tell us how well it’s working, so that could be a next step coming out of this.”

Since Thursday’s hearing was not a voting session, County Judge Sarah Eckhardt did not allow commissioners to ask questions or respond directly to testimony. But the item likely will come up again in upcoming voting sessions.

Diana Claitor, a member of the sheriff’s office’s advisory committee on the women’s facility, said Thursday that while she agrees that it’s important that the county work to improve its diversion effort, the new building is needed to better serve female inmates.

“This new women’s jail will be designed with women specifically in mind, it will be trauma-informed, safe, healthy, rehabilitative and respectful,” said Claitor, who is also director of the Texas Jail Project, a group that works to improve the condition of Texas’ county jails. “We fully expect that a re-envisioned jail … will result in much better outcomes for the women and for the whole community.”

Cate Graziani, criminal justice campaigns coordinator at nonprofit Grassroots Leadership, said in an interview that she was disappointed that the facility was back on the table but was encouraged by the progress made in the past five months.

RELATED: Grumet: Why Travis County wants to build a kinder, gentler jail

“One reason why we sounded the alarm bells last year was because we didn’t feel like the county had done a good enough job of having community input on that master plan on the women’s facility before moving ahead with it, and … to their credit, (they) are doing a better job of speaking with advocates,” Graziani said.

A six-page proposal sent to commissioners Thursday morning by Grassroots Leadership — as well as the Texas Criminal Justice Coalition, the Texas Overdose Naloxone Initiative and the Austin Harm Reduction Coalition — proposed a pre-arrest diversion program for people with substance abuse disorders.

Such a program would give substance users suspected of drug offenses the option to participate in a supportive services and case management program rather than face jail and prosecution.

The proposal cited the example of a pre-arrest diversion program in Seattle, which gives controlled substance users suspected of drug and prostitution offenses the option to participate in a supportive services and case management program rather than facing jail and prosecution.

A 2017 study of that program found that participants were 58 percent less likely to be arrested after enrollment compared with those who went through the typical criminal justice process.

The proposal also urged commissioners to help fund a 24-hour walk-in clinic for opioid users that the Texas Overdose Naloxone Initiative and the Austin Harm Reduction Coalition is opening this fall. The project is being paid for with federal money from the Texas Targeted Opioid Response initiative.

OP-ED: Commissioner Daugherty explains why he supports new women’s jail facility

The groups’ members encouraged commissioners to contribute funding so that the facility might be able to extend services for other types of substance abuse.

Graziani said the number of drug possession cases filed in Travis County has increased 90 percent since 2012. Such arrests are costly, inefficient and can lead to higher rates of recidivism, Graziani said.

“If we could reduce those jail bed days and those bookings even by a fraction, we could really reinvest dollars into the pre-arrest diversion program,” she said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Politics

Austin gentrification study touted as tool to fix affordability crisis
Austin gentrification study touted as tool to fix affordability crisis

When Delwin Goss moved to the Montopolis neighborhood in Southeast Austin in 1992, it wasn’t safe to walk down the street at night because it had so much crime, he said. Over time, the fabric of the neighborhood has started to change: People jog at night at dusk, and many of the drug houses have closed. But home prices are rapidly increasing...
Echoes of Anita Hill in charge against Brett Kavanaugh
Echoes of Anita Hill in charge against Brett Kavanaugh

In a prologue to their 1994 book, “Strange Justice: The Selling of Clarence Thomas,” journalists Jane Mayer and Jill Abramson wrote of how “unresolved the conflict” remained between Thomas, the conservative justice, and Anita Hill, the law professor who testified that he had sexually harassed her a decade earlier...
Did backers of city audit proposition skirt ‘dark money’ restrictions?
Did backers of city audit proposition skirt ‘dark money’ restrictions?

The political action committee behind a ballot proposition that calls for an independent efficiency audit of Austin City Hall might have broken local campaign finance laws by shielding the identities of its donors, according to city officials. In the sole campaign finance report it filed with the city, Citizens for an Accountable Austin showed only...
Judge refuses to dismiss official oppression charge against Dan Gattis
Judge refuses to dismiss official oppression charge against Dan Gattis

A judge ruled Friday that the Williamson County attorney’s office must amend its complaint about an official oppression charge against County Judge Dan Gattis to include more information about the charge against him. Visiting Judge Sid Harle, however, refused to dismiss the charge. The complaint said the county judge...
Average Hutto homeowner could see $81 increase in property taxes
Average Hutto homeowner could see $81 increase in property taxes

The average homeowner in the city of Hutto could pay about $81 more in property taxes this year. The increase reflects rising property values across Williamson County. The Hutto City Council is proposing to adopt the same tax rate as last year — 51.5 cents per $100 valuation — and would need to adopt a lower rate to keep taxes from increasing...
More Stories