UT resolves sexual assault lawsuit, sparing Fenves from testifying


Highlights

Per the agreement, UT cannot punish the man again for the same incident.

UT President Gregory L. Fenves avoided the witness stand due to the settlement.

A University of Texas student suspended for sexual assault has been reinstated through a negotiated settlement in which the school also agreed to dismiss his case and not pursue further punishment.

The agreement, reached Monday behind closed doors at a hearing in U.S. District Court, spared university President Gregory L. Fenves from having to testify about his decision to overrule a hearing examiner who had reviewed an assault complaint from spring 2016 and determined the male student had done nothing wrong.

John Doe — the name assigned to the male student in court documents — sat out the fall semester while serving his suspension. He is clear to resume coursework after winter break and cannot be punished again for the same incident, according to his attorney, Brian Roark. He is not entitled to money for damages or legal fees.

UT officials did not respond when asked why they reinstated the student while simultaneously arguing in court papers last week that their process for handling such disputes is fair and that Fenves based his decision to suspend the student “solely on the merits of this case.”

Fenves, who exited the courthouse with a UT communications official, declined to comment other than to say, “There’s been a settlement.”

According to court filings, the man and woman both told university investigators that she consented to his request for sex after the two left a sorority party and went to his apartment. But the woman came forward days later and made a complaint against the man, saying she was so drunk as to be incapacitated and unable to give consent.

A UT hearing examiner disagreed, siding with the man and determining that the woman had made rational decisions throughout the course of the evening.

READ: UT report finds 15 percent of undergraduate women have been raped

But Fenves reversed the hearing examiner’s ruling, citing witnesses who described the woman as stumbling and slurring words. He suspended the male student for five continuous semesters, finding him in violation of the school’s sexual misconduct policy.

The man filed a federal lawsuit in August against UT and its president, claiming that Fenves had denied his right to due process and requesting a temporary injunction that would have let him enroll in classes in the fall. The suit also alleged that Fenves had a possible conflict of interest because the woman’s father is a university donor who gave a significant sum within a month of her complaint.

District Judge Sam Sparks declined to act on the man’s request but expressed bewilderment over Fenves overruling the hearing examiner, who was a chemistry lecturer at UT.

“Tell me that’s due process,” Sparks remarked to UT’s attorneys.

UT attempted to avoid Monday’s hearing altogether, offering a compromise last week by lifting the suspension and signaling intent to hand the case to an unnamed third party to review Fenves’ decision.

READ: Federal judge questions Fenves’ ruling in UT sex assault case

Roark, the student’s attorney, called the third-party review a “sham gesture” and a “desperate attempt to avoid having Fenves answer questions under oath.” He asked instead that Sparks make the ruling.

The settlement was announced Monday after the attorneys met for 45 minutes in the judge’s chambers.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

NEW INFO: Police ID man killed in East Austin shooting Thursday
NEW INFO: Police ID man killed in East Austin shooting Thursday

Austin police have identified the man who died Thursday evening after an East Austin shooting that also left another man critically injured.  Police responded at about 6:28 p.m. to a call from the 1100 block of Poquito Street and found two injured men lying on the ground. The victims were taken to Dell Seton Medical Center, where one of the men...
Mexicans in U.S. to play big role in July election, but hurdles remain
Mexicans in U.S. to play big role in July election, but hurdles remain

The Texas midterms aren’t the only elections going on this year in the Lone Star State. Four months before Texans elect their governor, senators and representatives, Mexicans living in the U.S. will help decide their next president. Although Mexicans living outside of Mexico have been able to participate in that country’s past two presidential...
Mexicans in U.S. to play big role in July election, but hurdles remain
Mexicans in U.S. to play big role in July election, but hurdles remain

The Texas midterms aren’t the only elections going on this year in the Lone Star State. Four months before Texans elect their governor, senators and representatives, Mexicans living in the U.S. will help decide their next president. Although Mexicans living outside of Mexico have been able to participate in that country’s past two presidential...
Boerne man accused of punch attack at San Marcos bar in March surrenders
Boerne man accused of punch attack at San Marcos bar in March surrenders

A Boerne man accused of punching a man unconscious outside a San Marcos bar last month has surrendered to authorities, officials announced Friday. Bryan Albert Garcia, who is charged with assault-bodily injury and serious bodily injury, turned himself in to the Hays County Jail early Thursday. Garcia, 34, was identified as a suspect in the bar...
Man in his 30s stabbed in Southeast Austin, taken to hospital, EMS medics say
Man in his 30s stabbed in Southeast Austin, taken to hospital, EMS medics say

A man in his 30s was taken to the hospital Friday after being stabbed in Southeast Austin. Austin-Travis County EMS medics said they responded at 11:46 a.m. to the 4400 block of East Ben White Boulevard near Burleson Road, where they took the man to St. David’s South Austin Medical Center. His injuries were serious but not expected to be life-threatening...
More Stories