Prized Austin magnet schools are more diverse, but didn’t hit targets


After admission changes last year, AISD’s top magnets made modest gains in enrolling black and Latino students.

More notable changes were the increases of low-income students in the magnet programs.

Principal Kenisha Coburn’s push to increase the diversity of students at the mostly white Kealing Middle School magnet program goes beyond adding black and Latino students to the attendance rolls.

Coburn said she could go to the area’s high-tech companies to recruit employees’ children to increase the numbers. Instead, she wants to bring in the kids who are low-income or whose parents didn’t attend college. She wants the kids who live in attendance zones from which the magnet hasn’t drawn students in the past, children who didn’t think it was an option for them.

She wants gifted students who’ve never been in a program like Kealing’s to be able to walk into the room and know they are competitive with those from middle class and well-to-do families with more resources and support at home.

“I am not interested in the appearance of equity on the back of students,” she said. “I want real equity.”

After changing admissions last year, Kealing has made modest gains in attracting more underserved black and Hispanic students into its magnet program. Similar changes also have been made to admissions at the nationally ranked LASA High School.

More notable were the increases of low-income students. Kealing’s magnet more than doubled its low-income student population from 9 percent to 19 percent in 2017-18. LASA’s low-income population grew to nearly 100 students, from 7 percent to 8.3 percent.

While the gains show promise that the admission changes will help diversify the magnet programs, the Austin school district missed its targets in bringing up the numbers.

Diversity expected to edge up again next year

The disparities go back years. While the students in the Austin school district are mostly Hispanic and poor, the students in the district’s most sought-after magnet schools are largely white or Asian, and are from more affluent homes.

While Latinos make up 57 percent of the district’s student population, less than a quarter are in the sought-after magnets. Fewer low-income students are admitted into the programs, and for years, less than 2 percent of black students were enrolled in them. Critics said the competitive admissions process favored white students from affluent families with highly educated parents who could help them pull together an application packet that included test scores, essays and teacher recommendations. A student’s economic status or ethnicity were not factored on magnet applications.

RELATED: Lack of diversity looms over South Austin magnet school plans

But both Kealing and LASA changed their admissions processes going into the current school year, and for the first time considered factors such as race, socioeconomic status or the neighborhood where a student lives. Preliminary admissions numbers for 2018-19 show the schools will maintain the gains, or slightly increase, but again, fall short of diversity goals.

“They’ve showed some improvement, but not nearly sufficient enough improvement given the demographics of the district,” said school board member Ted Gordon, who represents the areas of East and Northeast Austin where both schools are located.

Gordon said there needs to be a more sophisticated process for recruitment than just tweaks to admissions, and said district leaders should look to diversity efforts on the collegiate level for strategies to use.

Beefed-up recruiting

Though some pushed back against the admissions changes, fearing the rigor of the programs would be watered down, Coburn said there was no need to lower the standards. There already were students who met academic standards, but needed the opportunity, and now the support, to persist in the programs.

READ MORE: Preliminary data shows diversity gains to come at Austin’s top magnet schools

While supportive of the changes to bring in more diversity, school board President Kendall Pace said the district must do more, starting in the early grades to better prepare low-income students and children of color.

“It highlights we have work to be done,” Pace said. “You have to fix the academics and eliminate those equity gaps in the earlier years. Unless you bring academic excellence to our students of poverty and students of color, you’re not going to create a strong pipeline for students interested in our magnets.”

Among the admission changes, the schools beefed up their recruiting and now do more to assist students with their applications.

“I’m first proud these are things we’re digging into,” Coburn said. “I’m happy to see ready students from every attendance zone have a real ability to come to this program, which wasn’t the case in the past.”

Tweaking admissions isn’t a cure-all, Coburn said. Equity must be pursued not only in the campuses, but also at the district and city levels because “underserving whole communities of people” is a symptom of a larger problem, she said. “We continue to put systems in place here to recognize, attract, admit and serve a broader base of students because we should.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Shooting reported in Panama City, Florida
Shooting reported in Panama City, Florida

Police responded Tuesday afternoon to reports of a shooting in Panama City, Florida, according to multiple reports. Multiple agencies were responding to the situation in the 2300 block of Beck Avenue, including the Walton County Sheriff's Office, WJHG reported. Update 2:40 p.m. EDT: Walton County sheriff’s deputies confirmed that a shooting...
Bar owner from Austin accused of raping customer in Fort Worth, police say
Bar owner from Austin accused of raping customer in Fort Worth, police say

An Austin man is accused of sexually assaulting a patron last December at a bar he owns in Fort Worth, according to an arrest affidavit filed in Tarrant County. Israel Espiricueta, 41, the owner of the Library Bar in downtown Fort Worth, was arrested in Travis County on Feb. 5 for sexual assault and released from jail after posting $10,000 bond, according...
Travis County tax assessor Elfant responds to fraud investigation
Travis County tax assessor Elfant responds to fraud investigation

Responding to a multiagency investigation of fraud that authorities said was carried out in part by four Travis County tax office employees, assessor-collector Bruce Elfant said Tuesday he is committed to renewing his unit’s integrity. “I fully expect that I will be judged by my response to this abhorrent situation, and I promise to do...
Houston Texans star J.J. Watt visits Santa Fe High School shooting victims 
Houston Texans star J.J. Watt visits Santa Fe High School shooting victims 

Houston Texans defensive end J.J. Watt continues to make an impact in the wake of the mass shooting at a southeastern Texas high school, KTRK reported. Watt visited some of the victims injured in the deadly shooting at Santa Fe High School on Monday and took photographs with them and their nurses at the hospital. He also visited several victims...
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott cancels shotgun giveaway after Santa Fe shooting
Texas Gov. Greg Abbott cancels shotgun giveaway after Santa Fe shooting

After eight students and two teachers were killed Friday in a shooting at Santa Fe High School, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott appears to have canceled a shotgun giveaway on his website. According to the Texas Tribune, Abbott’s re-election campaign dropped the giveaway from its website, instead opting for a $250 gift card as the prize.  “The...
More Stories