Grading glitch incorrectly ranks Reagan High valedictorian No. 2


Naomi Lands earned the top class rank, but she was honored as No. 2 due to a programming error.

A month after graduation, school officials notified Lands that the error caused her GPA to appear lower.

A nonprofit that supports schools will give the other student a grant to pay for one year at a Texas college.

Six years of studying every night until the early hours of the morning, working daily through lunch on homework and projects in a teacher’s classroom and abandoning high school extracurricular activities paid off for Naomi Lands.

Lands graduated at the top of her 2018 Reagan High School class, the Austin district’s only black valedictorian this year.

But the 17-year-old didn’t receive the accompanying fanfare or give the keynote speech at her graduation. She didn’t even know she finished first in her class until a month after graduation.

“I was sad I didn’t get valedictorian, but I was happy to be in the top three and be up on stage,” Lands said.

Due to a programming error, one of Lands’ advanced courses was weighted improperly, giving her a lower GPA, and mistakenly ranking her as No. 2 among her classmates. Reagan officials a couple of weeks ago notified Lands of her new rank, and they explained how it occurred on Monday night.

READ: Austin school district delays renaming schools with Confederate ties

“I was really shocked and surprised. It took me by surprise,” Lands said. “I’m still a bit shocked about it. It hasn’t hit me fully yet.”

But Lands’ relatives said they wish she had been honored properly by the school.

“Without any fanfare or acknowledgement … they said, ‘after finalizing the grades, we have determined your daughter was the valedictorian,’ ” said her father, Richard Sterling Lands. “It’s an uncomfortable situation. We already had gone through the graduation. We’re not sure who knows, other than who we tell.”

District officials decided not to strip the student initially named valedictorian of the honor and instead to call both students valedictorians. Both will enjoy two semesters of free tuition at a Texas public college, a perk under Texas law for the highest-ranking graduate at each high school.

Because the district now is providing the first-year’s college tuition waiver to Lands, district officials tapped nonprofit Austin Ed Fund to provide the other student a grant to pay for her first year of college. Lands had planned to attend college out of state to pursue architectural engineering but now is considering Texas Tech University.

READ: Report: Texas student arrests have soared since Parkland, Santa Fe

“We have apologized to the families affected and have recognized both students as co-valedictorian, as well as identified a scholarship solution that holds each student harmless,” Reyne Telles, executive director of communications at the district, said in a statement. “An extensive review of student records found that this was a unique and isolated case and no other students or schools were affected.”

School has often been easy for Lands, the granddaughter of longtime community activist the Rev. Sterling Lands. She skipped seventh grade because she was advanced in her studies and needed more rigor. Two weeks before her high school graduation, while still 16, she also graduated with an associate degree from Austin Community College, an early college program offered at some Austin high schools aimed at getting more low-income and minority students to attend college.

On Monday, she walked around her alma mater, carrying her graduation gown for a photo. Among her multiple decorative vestments and tassels boasting various accolades, her gold academic stole worn over her baby blue robe still bears the word “salutatorian.”

Lands stopped to look at it, wondering aloud if the school can reprint her another.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Health premium increase for retired teachers unlikely in 2019
Health premium increase for retired teachers unlikely in 2019

The Teacher Retirement System of Texas appears unlikely to raise health insurance premiums for retired teachers under the age of 65 next year amid pressure from state officials. A board committee of the pension and health care system on Thursday followed a staff recommendation to keep premiums and deductibles the same. The full board likely will agree...
5,000 Medicare patients shut out from Austin Regional Clinic
5,000 Medicare patients shut out from Austin Regional Clinic

A contract dispute between Austin Regional Clinic and UnitedHealthcare has left an estimated 5,000 Medicare patients without access to their physicians, according to clinic officials. Patients who are enrolled in UnitedHealthcare’s Medicare Advantage plan were notified through mail by the insurance company last week that Austin Regional Clinic...
Suspect in series of sexual assaults convicted in North Austin attack
Suspect in series of sexual assaults convicted in North Austin attack

A Travis County jury on Thursday found a man guilty of sexually assaulting a 56-year-old woman in North Austin two years ago. Nicodemo Coria-Gonzalez, 27, was convicted of aggravated sexual assault after a forensic analyst linked him to the attack through DNA evidence found on the victim. The eight women and four men on the jury deliberated for four...
Bakari Henderson’s accused assailants to go on trial in Greece
Bakari Henderson’s accused assailants to go on trial in Greece

Nine men accused of fatally beating an Austin native while vacationing in Greece are expected to stand trial in that country starting Friday — a proceeding his family hopes will result in life sentences for the assailants. The parents of Bakari Henderson have traveled to the Greek city of Patras for the trial and say they are eager for justice...
Man shot pregnant woman in the face at North Austin hotel, affidavit says
Man shot pregnant woman in the face at North Austin hotel, affidavit says

Austin police have arrested a man accused of shooting a pregnant woman in the face at a North Austin hotel earlier this month, court documents say. Jeremy Petty, 41, has been charged with aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and is being held at the Travis County Jail on $100,000 bail, records show. Police say Petty shot a woman who is five months...
More Stories