Judge: Woman in fatal arson case should be declared innocent


A West Texas woman should be found innocent of murder because her conviction and 99-year sentence were based on discredited scientific evidence, a state judge recommended Monday.

Sonia Cacy was convicted of setting a fire in her Fort Stockton home that killed her uncle, Bill Richardson, while he slept in 1991.

Her case became a rallying cry for reformers who argued that conclusions reached by poorly trained arson investigators produced convictions that could no longer be supported, including Cacy’s.

Experts, including now-deceased chemist Gerald Hurst of Austin, presented evidence to the Texas Board of Pardons and Parole indicating that Richardson, a 76-year-old who smoked up to three packs of cigarettes a day, died of a heart attack while smoking in bed. Evidence of multiple cigarette burns on sheets and around the bed were ignored by arson investigators, they said.

In an unusual move for the notoriously strict board, it granted Cacy parole after she served only six years in prison.

Volunteer lawyers later moved to have her declared innocent, leading to Monday’s findings by visiting Judge Bert Richardson, who noted that new evidence casts doubt on lab tests that found gasoline on the clothes worn by Cacy’s uncle.

That evidence showed that a tester falsified the evidence receipt form for the man’s clothing and tests performed by another employee of the Bexar County Forensic Science Center detected no accelerants, Bert Richardson said.

The judge’s order will go the the Court of Criminal Appeals, which as the state’s highest criminal court has the authority to issue declarations of innocence. Bert Richardson was elected to the court while he had the Cacy case under consideration and will not participate in its review of her case.

Cacy’s innocence also was supported by a State Fire Marshal’s Office review that discredited evidence used to convict Cacy.

Monday’s order criticized District Attorney Rod Ponton for attempting to halt the office’s review of Cacy’s case by seeking an attorney general’s opinion finding that the agency lacked the authority to review old arson cases. Then-Attorney General Greg Abbott disagreed, and the reviews continued.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

‘Whole lotta women’ changing the face of the Texas Democratic Party
‘Whole lotta women’ changing the face of the Texas Democratic Party

Kim Olson strode to the stage of the Democratic State Convention on Friday to Kelly Clarkson’s “Whole Lotta Woman.” “Let me just repeat those lyrics, a bad-ass woman with class and self-confidence,” Olson said. “I run for office because I’m confident I’m going to win.” “Whole lotta women&rdquo...
UPDATE: Texas 130 near U.S. 79 reopened after firefighters battle grass fire
UPDATE: Texas 130 near U.S. 79 reopened after firefighters battle grass fire

5:00 p.m. update: Williamson County officials say all lanes of Texas 130 near U.S. 79 have reopened after being closed previously for a grass fire. Authorities say there is still smoke over the road and have asked drivers to remain careful and to drive 20 mph under the speed limit as firefighters work in the area. Earlier: A fast-moving...
In Rio Grande Valley, a life-altering limbo as asylum process shifts
In Rio Grande Valley, a life-altering limbo as asylum process shifts

In shelters in Mexico, in detention facilities in the United States and in consultations with attorneys, they wait in uncertainty. Lorena, 31, left Honduras with her husband and four children in mid-April, when gangs started killing children attending local schools and skimming the money she earned as a laundress. “Every day you hear that they...
Vinnie Paul was co-founder, drummer of Texas metal band Pantera
Vinnie Paul was co-founder, drummer of Texas metal band Pantera

Vinnie Paul, co-founder and drummer of the Arlington-based metal band Pantera, has died at 54. Pantera’s official Facebook page posted a statement early Saturday announcing his death. The label of Hellyeah, his most recent group, confirmed the death but neither statement mentioned Paul’s cause of death. His real name was Vincent Paul Abbott...
BAD BREAD: H-E-B pulls some bread after finding ‘unfavorable aroma’
BAD BREAD: H-E-B pulls some bread after finding ‘unfavorable aroma’

H-E-B is voluntarily pulling some of its bread products off its shelves after discovering an unfavorable aroma, the company said in a statement. The store has pulled all H-E-B and Hill Country Fare bread products, including hamburger and hot dog buns, that have a best buy date between June 26 and July 2. The company said it was concerned about the...
More Stories