Federal judge tosses out Texas abortion law


Highlights

The Legislature passed regulations in May to restrict the most common form of second-trimester abortion.

A federal judge struck down the law Wednesday, saying it improperly interfered with the right to an abortion.

It’s the third time this year that a federal judge has tossed out a Texas abortion-related regulation.

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton filed a notice of appeal within an hour of Wednesday’s ruling.

For the third time this year, a federal judge has tossed out an abortion-related regulation in Texas — this time a law that bans a common type of second-trimester abortion unless doctors first employ an added procedure to ensure fetal demise.

In a ruling issued Wednesday afternoon, U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel of Austin said the law requires doctors to use risky, unproven and medically unnecessary methods to cause fetal demise before beginning a dilation and evacuation abortion, the safest and most common such procedure after the 15th week of pregnancy.

The added procedure, typically conducted by injecting toxins into the fetus via a 4-inch needle inserted through the abdomen or vagina, carries increased risks of infection and other health complications, Yeakel wrote.

“The court is unaware of any other medical context that requires a doctor — in contravention of the doctor’s medical judgment and the best interest of the patient — to conduct a medical procedure that delivers no benefit to the woman,” he wrote.

READ: Pay raises, hiring initiatives usher in Texas CPS improvements

Within an hour of the ruling, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton filed a notice of appeal with the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, saying he intended to reinstate the provision of Senate Bill 8 — approved by the Legislature in May — that was meant to protect “unborn human life from ghastly dismemberment abortions.”

“No just society should tolerate the tearing of living human beings to pieces,” Paxton said, adding that the law “treats the unborn with dignity and respect and protects the integrity of the medical profession.”

“We will defend Senate Bill 8 all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, if necessary,” Paxton said.

In his ruling, Yeakel acknowledged that the state has an interest in preserving the life of a fetus, as determined by the Supreme Court. But the state’s interest does not supersede a woman’s right to an abortion, he said.

“That a woman may make the decision to have an abortion before a fetus may survive outside her womb is solely and exclusively the woman’s decision. The power to make this decision is her right,” Yeakel wrote.

“The state’s position is that the right and the interest are entitled to equal weight. But this is incorrect,” the judge added. “The state’s legitimate interest in fetal life does not allow the imposition of an additional medical procedure … not driven by medical necessity. Here, the state’s interest must give way to the woman’s right.”

At the urging of abortion providers, Yeakel temporarily blocked the Texas law on Aug. 31, the day before it was to take effect. That 14-day temporary restraining order was extended until Wednesday to allow time for Yeakel to issue a written opinion after a five-day trial on the law’s constitutionality that took place earlier this month.

Abortion rights advocates praised Wednesday’s decision.

“Politics should never tie the hands of doctors or bar women from safe medical care,” said Cecile Richards, president of Planned Parenthood Federation of America and daughter of former Gov. Ann Richards. “Lawmakers in Texas have been trying for years to ban abortion by any means necessary. This law is the same underhanded agenda in a different package, and it’s women who get hurt in the process.”

READ: New Capitol monument will depict “The Price of Liberty”

Abortion opponents said Wednesday that they hoped the Texas law would get a fairer hearing before 5th Circuit Court, which has upheld several Texas abortion regulations that had been overturned by a lower court, including the requirement for a pre-abortion sonogram.

“We’ve been down this road before,” John Seago, legislative director for Texas Right to Life, said on Twitter. “Hopefully the state’s interest in protecting innocent human life will be acknowledged.”

Seven other states have passed similar laws targeting “dismemberment abortions,” but courts have blocked five states from enforcing the ban — including rulings from federal judges in Alabama and Arkansas that also have been appealed to separate U.S. circuit courts. The laws in the other two states were not challenged.

Wednesday’s ruling followed decisions striking down two Texas abortion-related regulations earlier this year.

• In January, U.S. District Judge Sam Sparks of Austin voided a state rule requiring health facilities to bury or cremate fetal tissue, whether from an abortion or miscarriage.

• In February, Sparks also blocked Texas from ousting Planned Parenthood as a Medicaid provider for contraceptives and related care.

Both rulings also have been appealed to the 5th Circuit Court.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Prosecutors drop charge against man who police accused of pointing gun at officer
Prosecutors drop charge against man who police accused of pointing gun at officer

Travis County prosecutors on Wednesday dropped a charge against a man who Austin police had said pointed a gun at an officer last year, jail records show.  Lawrence Parrish, 32, has been in the Travis County Jail on the charge of aggravated assault against a public servant, among other charges, since April 2017.  Austin officers shot Parrish...
‘I don’t like my odds’: In trial, Criner says he did not kill Weiser
‘I don’t like my odds’: In trial, Criner says he did not kill Weiser

Meechaiel Criner took the witness stand Wednesday at his own capital murder trial and told a packed courtroom he did not kill University of Texas student Haruka Weiser — but understands why the jury might think he did after he was found with many of her belongings. “So far I don’t like my odds,” Criner said. “It doesn&rsquo...
Nearly all parking lots full at Austin airport, officials say
Nearly all parking lots full at Austin airport, officials say

All but one parking lot was full at the Austin-Bergstrom International Airport Wednesday evening, and the lots had all been completely filled earlier Wednesday, Austin airport officials said. The short-term parking lot is full, the cellphone lot is open, and only Lot D is open for long-term parking, Austin airport officials said. There are no guarantees...
Police searching for driver who struck child in East Austin 
Police searching for driver who struck child in East Austin 

Austin police are asking for the public’s help in finding a driver who they say struck a child in an East Austin neighborhood Tuesday and left. Police responded around 11:15 p.m. to the 3500 block of Webberville Road and found a boy with serious injuries. The victim was taken to a hospital, officials said.  Authorities described the vehicle...
‘I don’t like my odds’: In trial, Criner says he did not kill Weiser
‘I don’t like my odds’: In trial, Criner says he did not kill Weiser

Meechaiel Criner took the witness stand Wednesday at his own capital murder trial and told a packed courtroom he did not kill University of Texas student Haruka Weiser — but he understands why the jury might think he did after he was found with many of her belongings. “So far, I don’t like my odds,” Criner said. “It doesn&rsquo...
More Stories