Federal investigation finds faults in VA’s wait times probe


Federal investigators have rebuked the Department of Veterans Affairs for inadequately investigating allegations that several Central Texas clinics tried to make veterans’ wait times for health care appear shorter than they were.

In a news release Wednesday, the U.S. Office of Special Counsel stated that, in three whistleblower investigations, the VA’s “disclosures of scheduling data manipulation at several Texas VA hospitals and clinics are deficient and unreasonable.” The Office of Special Counsel, which wrote a letter to Congress and the White House, found the VA’s Office of Inspector General had failed to appropriately address the whistleblowers’ allegations.

“These employees raised important concerns about access to care issues within their hospitals and I applaud their efforts to improve care for veterans,” Special Counsel Carolyn Lerner said. She added that the VA was taking steps to correct the issues.

The office’s announcement comes a little more than a month after the VA’s Office of Inspector General, the department’s self-investigating arm, released a long-awaited report into the allegations of data manipulation. It found that scheduling clerks in Austin, San Antonio and Kerrville regularly engaged in the practice of “zeroing out” patient appointment requests, which resulted in undercounts of true wait times for care.

But that report placed blame on individual clerks and concluded there was no “malicious intent” to cook the VA’s books. Supervisors and administrators denied they instructed clerks to manipulate data, blaming the practice on widespread misunderstanding of VA scheduling rules. One administrator said “the concept of scheduling errors seemed to confuse schedulers.”

The inspector general’s findings had drawn a sharp rebuke from U.S. Rep. Jeff Miller, R-Fla., chairman of the House Committee on Veterans’ Affairs.

It also incensed Brian Turner, a medical assistant who retired from the VA and had brought allegations that employees in Austin and San Antonio were directed to manipulate patient wait times. He told the American-Statesman on Wednesday the system itself is flawed and that administrators have a financial incentive to cheat.

“They can make $50,000 or $60,000 by changing the data. It’s motive for a crime,” said Turner, a retired Army sergeant. He agrees with the findings of the U.S. Special Counsel Office, but said he doesn’t believe, as the office states in its release, that the VA will make meaningful changes to the way it investigates such allegations.

“The VA can’t be trusted to govern and investigate themselves,” he said. “They’ve already wasted enough time and money investigating themselves. What’s come from it? Nothing.”

The VA’s Office of Inspector General found no evidence of employees receiving bonuses or awards specifically related to patient wait times.

The VA issued a statement responding to the Office of Special Counsel’s findings.

“The department appreciates the work of the independent OIG to provide necessary feedback to help us improve. OIG’s investigations give us the opportunity to make necessary changes and better serve veterans,” the statement said. “In the overwhelming majority of instances, the OIG found no intentional wrongdoing; nonetheless these reports demonstrated the need for standardized training on scheduling across VHA.”

The overarching scandal came to light two years ago, when the VA came under fire nationally for hiding lengthy wait times in an effort to meet goals of seeing patients within 14 days. It began after allegations that numerous VA patients in Phoenix died while languishing on secret wait lists meant to hide the existence of delays for care. It eventually cost former VA Secretary Eric Shinseki his job.

In May 2014, Turner, then a San Antonio VA scheduling clerk who previously worked at the Austin Outpatient Clinic, publicly accused VA officials of submitting false appointment data in Texas.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

JUST IN: Local comedian stabbed 5 times in Southeast Austin attack
JUST IN: Local comedian stabbed 5 times in Southeast Austin attack

An Austin comedian is recovering after being stabbed five times during an attack in Southeast Austin last week. The stabbing happened around 11:46 a.m. on April 20 in the 4400 block of East Ben White Boulevard near Burleson Road. Seth Murray, 32, also known as Seth Goodtime, was walking from his girlfriend’s house on Matador Street to grab a...
Texas 130 set to expand as tollway freeze thaws
Texas 130 set to expand as tollway freeze thaws

The Texas Department of Transportation freeze on toll projects thawed somewhat Thursday, when the board governing the agency approved a $36.7 million contract to add lanes to Texas 130 east of Austin. The project to add a third lane to each side of the tollway between Texas 45 North and U.S. 290 was approved by the Texas Transportation Commission as...
Austin firefighters praise puppy that took on coral snake near children
Austin firefighters praise puppy that took on coral snake near children

Austin firefighters on Thursday praised a puppy that took on a coral snake that was just inches from a patio where two young children were playing. The puppy, a shih-poo named Panda, spotted the brightly colored serpent as a 1-year-old and a 3-year-old were playing on an apartment patio on the ground level of a building. “My awesome hero pet...
Vehicle crashes into Oracle campus wall, EMS says
Vehicle crashes into Oracle campus wall, EMS says

SOUTHEAST AUSTIN EMS: Vehicle crashes into Oracle campus wall A vehicle crashed into a wall at the Oracle campus in Southeast Austin on Thursday afternoon, Austin-Travis County EMS said. Medics responded at 1:41 p.m. to a vehicle-building crash in the 2300 block of South Lakeshore Boulevard near East Riverside Drive. Medics evaluated a person after...
Longer live music hours on Red River will remain in place
Longer live music hours on Red River will remain in place

Longer live music hours on Red River Street will stay for good, after a yearlong test that drew widespread praise and support. Austin City Council members agreed unanimously Thursday to permanently allow venues in the Red River Cultural District, between Sixth and 12th streets, to play amplified music until midnight on Thursdays and 1 a.m. on weekends...
More Stories