DA: Officers who shocked teenager committed crime — but can't be charged


Highlights

After a Statesman story, the Dallas DA opened a review into the death of Graham Dyer.

Prosecutors said Mesquite police should be charged with criminally negligent homicide in his death.

Yet because Graham Dyer died more than 3 years ago, it is too late to bring charges.

The office of Dallas County District Attorney Faith Johnson said Thursday it had concluded some Mesquite police officers, who in August 2013 shocked 18-year-old Graham Dyer with a Taser on his testicles while he was handcuffed and allowed him to fatally injure himself in the back of their cruiser, had committed a crime.

But due to the expiration of the statute of limitations, the officers involved couldn’t be charged.

“If I could go back in time and have this case, it would be indicted,” said Michael Snipes, the first assistant district attorney. “We would have pursued criminally negligent homicide charges.”

According to state law, however, such charges cannot be brought more than three years after the incident, which came to the district attorney’s attention as the result of an American-Statesman investigation two months ago. And while there is no such limitation on the higher charge of manslaughter, Snipes said the officers’ behavior that contributed to Graham’s death didn’t reach the level of a knowing disregard for his life.

READ: Texas police withheld records of their son’s death. Now they know why.

Graham, a skinny skateboarding enthusiast, died after Mesquite police took him into custody on a summer night while he was having a bad LSD trip. The medical examiner called his death an accident, concluding he’d died of self-inflicted injuries sustained by hurling himself around the backseat of the police car on the way to the jail.

Yet police videos later obtained by his parents — with great difficulty and despite the city’s refusal to turn them over — appeared to show that Mesquite police had failed to properly restrain Graham in the back of the car. They also revealed the officers had pulled over and shocked the teenager with a Taser, including several times in his groin. One officer threatened to kill Graham.

The videos also seemed to contradict official police reports of the incident, which stated that Graham had needed to be placed in a special restraint chair at the jail because he was so out of control. Yet the videos of him being unloaded from the police car before being taken to a cell show Graham lying limp on the sally-port floor. It was more than two hours later, when officers found him unresponsive, that medics were summoned to treat him.

The case was never presented to a grand jury, and a city spokesman has said none of the police officers involved was disciplined.

Graham’s parents, Kathy and Robert Dyer, said they met with prosecutors for three hours Thursday. Snipes said his office’s investigation included reviewing videos of Graham’s arrest, police reports and affidavits, and it resulted in a 12-page internal report that was presented to the district attorney.

Kathy said she was disappointed the Mesquite officers wouldn’t be held to account for her youngest son’s death. “We’re pretty emotional, but it’s what we expected,” she said. “We feel like (prosecutors) did a pretty thorough investigation.”

Wayne Larson, a spokesman for the city of Mesquite, didn’t immediately respond to a phone call or email.

The Statesman described in April the Dyer family’s long and frustrating battle to obtain the damning police records. Mesquite was able to withhold them because of a Texas law that says law enforcement agencies don’t have to turn over their records if a defendant isn’t convicted of a crime. Graham was charged with assault for allegedly biting an officer in the finger while being arrested, but, he was never convicted because he died before his case could be heard.

STATESMAN INVESTIGATES: A Question of Restraint: How 290 people died in police custody

After being repeatedly rebuffed in their request for the Mesquite Police Department’s records from the night Graham died, Kathy and Robert Dyer asked the FBI to investigate. Although the federal agency said it was unable to bring a civil rights case, the Dyers realized they could circumvent Mesquite officials by asking the bureau for the records it had reviewed.

The family used the videos the FBI eventually turned over to them as the basis for a federal civil lawsuit against Mesquite. That case is pending and still in the early stages of litigation.

The Dyers’ story spurred a flurry of responses. In addition to the district attorney’s promise to review Mesquite’s treatment of Graham on the night of his death, Kathy and Robert testified in front of legislators in support of a bill that could help other families in their position.

Sponsored by Rep. Joe Moody, D-El Paso, House Bill 3234 would have compelled law enforcement agencies to release their investigative records if, like Graham, the suspect had died, or, if not, gave his consent to their release. The couple’s emotional testimony appeared to move several of the lawmakers on the state House Committee on Government Transparency and Operation.

While the proposed law made it out of the committee — a small victory in a committee that scuttled most of its open government bills — it later died.

In its multistory investigation into people who died in the custody of law enforcement officers, the Statesman noted a patchwork of local policies regarding how such incidents are reported to prosecutors, who in turn had a variety of policies about presenting cases to grand juries.

The Travis County medical examiner determined the death of Willie Ray Banks, who in December 2011 was shocked with a Taser for more than 3 minutes continuously and restrained for a lengthy time by Granite Shoals and Burnet County officers, was a homicide. Yet the case wasn’t presented to a grand jury until the Statesman inquired about it five years later — also too late for criminal charges to be brought against the officers.

After 23-year-old Thomas Klessig, a former high school wrestling champion with mental health issues, died of “mechanical compression” while being restrained by University Park police, that department changed its policy. Prior to that the agency determined on a case-by-case basis which incidents needed district attorney involvement. After Klessig’s death, also found to be a homicide, the suburban Dallas department notifies local prosecutors whenever a person dies in officers’ custody after a use of force.

The completion of the Dallas district attorney’s review means the Dyers’ lawsuit is their sole remaining hope to hold police accountable in Graham’s death. Their Fort Worth attorney, Susan Hutchison, predicted a long legal road, but vowed to see it through.

“We are going to fight to the end for civil liability,” she said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

JUST IN: Local comedian stabbed 5 times in Southeast Austin attack
JUST IN: Local comedian stabbed 5 times in Southeast Austin attack

An Austin comedian is recovering after being stabbed five times during an attack in Southeast Austin last week. The stabbing happened around 11:46 a.m. on April 20 in the 4400 block of East Ben White Boulevard near Burleson Road. Seth Murray, 32, also known as Seth Goodtime, was walking from his girlfriend’s house on Matador Street to grab a...
Texas 130 set to expand as tollway freeze thaws
Texas 130 set to expand as tollway freeze thaws

The Texas Department of Transportation freeze on toll projects thawed somewhat Thursday, when the board governing the agency approved a $36.7 million contract to add lanes to Texas 130 east of Austin. The project to add a third lane to each side of the tollway between Texas 45 North and U.S. 290 was approved by the Texas Transportation Commission as...
Austin firefighters praise puppy that took on coral snake near children
Austin firefighters praise puppy that took on coral snake near children

Austin firefighters on Thursday praised a puppy that took on a coral snake that was just inches from a patio where two young children were playing. The puppy, a shih-poo named Panda, spotted the brightly colored serpent as a 1-year-old and a 3-year-old were playing on an apartment patio on the ground level of a building. “My awesome hero pet...
Vehicle crashes into Oracle campus wall, EMS says
Vehicle crashes into Oracle campus wall, EMS says

SOUTHEAST AUSTIN EMS: Vehicle crashes into Oracle campus wall A vehicle crashed into a wall at the Oracle campus in Southeast Austin on Thursday afternoon, Austin-Travis County EMS said. Medics responded at 1:41 p.m. to a vehicle-building crash in the 2300 block of South Lakeshore Boulevard near East Riverside Drive. Medics evaluated a person after...
Longer live music hours on Red River will remain in place
Longer live music hours on Red River will remain in place

Longer live music hours on Red River Street will stay for good, after a yearlong test that drew widespread praise and support. Austin City Council members agreed unanimously Thursday to permanently allow venues in the Red River Cultural District, between Sixth and 12th streets, to play amplified music until midnight on Thursdays and 1 a.m. on weekends...
More Stories