In murder trial, defense says police ignored other possible suspects


Trelin Reed’s death was sparked by a feud over lewd Facebook posts, prosecutors say.

Text messages show Reed had boasted about robbing someone of marijuana on the day he was killed.

A defendant who is on trial for a fatal shooting that police believe was over inflammatory social media posts told investigators he did not kill the victim, even though he said he had every reason to do so.

Jabari Mitchell, 26, had arranged in November 2016 to meet up and fight his ex-girlfriend’s brother, Trelin Reed. When there were too many people hanging around at the North Austin Luby’s where they had agreed to meet, they pivoted to a Wendy’s. And then to a Shell gas station.

At yet another location — a Mobil gas station at the intersection of Interstate 35 and East St. Johns Avenue — Reed was ambushed with gunfire while sitting in a Ford Explorer. The killer was positioned behind a privacy fence and fired 25 times through a missing plank, police say. Reed was hit 13 times and was taken to a hospital where he was pronounced dead.

In closing arguments Tuesday, Mitchell’s lawyer said police became too focused on the feud between the men and dismissed the possibility that Reed might have been killed by someone else. The list of possible suspects who were never vetted includes a person in Wells Branch who, text messages show, Reed had boasted about robbing earlier in the day, defense attorney Amber Vazquez said.

“There were a lot of people who had motive and opportunity,” she told the jury.

The men and women weighing a murder charge against Mitchell deliberated for more than four hours Tuesday. If they return a guilty verdict, they can impose a sentence of five to 99 years in prison. Mitchell also faces two related counts of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon for gunshot injuries sustained by two others who were with Reed in the Explorer.

Attorneys for the defense and the prosecution agreed Mitchell and Reed were both involved in drug dealing and other criminal activity. The area is a magnet for police calls, according to testimony from an officer who said he is called to the convenience store where the shooting took place more than once every shift.

The underlying feud that detectives say led to the shooting was related to a nasty break-up between Mitchell and Reed’s sister. Retaliating to allegations that Reed’s sister slashed his tires, Mitchell posted a video on Facebook showing her performing a sexual act on him. She responded with a lewd video of her own that showed Mitchell performing a sexual act on her. At some point, their mothers got involved and quarreled.

On the day of the shooting, Mitchell had accused Reed’s sister of damaging his car once more, prompting the move to arrange a fight. However, prosecutor Michelle Hallee said Mitchell was never prepared to fight and decided to “lie and wait until the car got there and shoot it up.”

A second prosecutor, Jeremy Sylestine, called Mitchell’s intentions “highly calculated.”

Sylestine agreed with the defense that the investigation that led to Mitchell’s arrest was quick, but he attributed it to the many signs that pointed to him as the shooter. Records from cellphone towers show he was in the area of the convenience store at the time of the shooting, contradicting a statement he made to police about being elsewhere with a friend. Mitchell also told police he did not have a gun, but prosecutors think that was a lie based on a video that showed Mitchell holding a firearm that is consistent with the AR-15 rifle police say was used to kill Reed.

Within moments of the attack, surveillance video captured Mitchell and a friend getting a drink nearby at Texas Land & Cattle. Sylestine said Mitchell purposefully stared into the camera to create a false alibi.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Florida man shoots girlfriend once, returns and shoots her fatally, deputies say
Florida man shoots girlfriend once, returns and shoots her fatally, deputies say

A Florida man faces a first-degree murder charge after allegedly firing a shot at his girlfriend, fleeing the scene, then returning and shooting her a number of times, The Tampa Bay Times reported. >> Read more trending news  Nathaniel J. Yates, 32, of Largo, is accused in the shooting death of Christine Giles, 28, of Seminole, according...
How did low-income Texas schools fare under state’s A-F rating system?
How did low-income Texas schools fare under state’s A-F rating system?

Although they tended to perform better under the state’s new school rating system than under the previous one, Texas schools with the highest rates of low-income children still performed worse than schools with wealthier student bodies. Among Texas schools with the highest percentages of low-income students, 6 percent of them failed to meet state...
PolitiFact: Increasing share of state money goes to charter schools
PolitiFact: Increasing share of state money goes to charter schools

A Democratic legislator declared that state aid fully fuels Texas charter schools while schools serving the vast bulk of students field less money. State Rep. Donna Howard of Austin said in a tweet: “Here’s the thing. In Tx, charters get 100% state $/pupil funding while district schools (95% students) get about 1/3 funding from state w/...
Traffic report for Aug. 20, 2018

Interstate 35 (Hays County): Various closures in both directions between Yarrington Road and Robert S. Light Boulevard from 9 p.m. to 5 a.m. Monday through Thursday nights. Interstate 35 (Travis County): The left lane on the southbound access road will be closed between Three Points Road and Cheddar Loop Road from 9 p.m. to 5 a.m. Monday through Thursday...
As first bell rings Monday, Mendez Middle School gets second chance
As first bell rings Monday, Mendez Middle School gets second chance

Mendez Middle School’s Principal Joanna Carrillo-Rowley knocked on the door to the mobile home. Wearing jeans, a school shirt and a pair of Converse shoes, Carrillo-Rowley was pounding the pavement on a recent summer night in search of students who were zoned to attend her middle school but had not registered. It was a tactic she previously used...
More Stories