Meechaiel Criner trial: Race at issue in day 2 of jury selection


Highlights

A prospective juror who is a naturalized U.S. citizen said the legal system discriminates against minorities.

With a jury expected to be finalized late Tuesday, the presentation of evidence is set to begin Wednesday.

Discussion about the intersection of race and criminal justice was at the center of the jury selection process Tuesday in the capital murder trial of defendant Meechaiel Criner, an African-American runaway who is accused of strangling and sexually assaulting University of Texas student Haruka Weiser two years ago.

A Travis County resident who was being vetted by attorneys for a seat on the jury asked to be removed from consideration because of strong views he says he harbors about the way the legal system mistreats people of color. In response to a question from the prosecution about the mandatory life sentence Criner faces if he’s found guilty, the man said he recently became a naturalized U.S. citizen and his time living in the country has led him to believe that minorities who are accused of a crime do not get fair trials.

The man suggested he might favor Criner and asked to be disqualified — a request that was initially denied but later approved by state District Judge David Wahlberg, who had stressed the importance of getting a diverse jury.

“It’s only through the participation of a wide variety of people that we can achieve justice,” he said. “I want you to consider having your voice heard.”

The man’s commentary came one day after Criner’s lawyer made an oral objection in court because none of the three black candidates who were on Monday’s jury panel were chosen for the jury. Defense attorney Ariel Payan had wanted to pick a black man around Criner’s age, 20, but was stopped when prosecutors used one of their 10 allotted strikes to send him home.

In defending the decision, prosecutor Victoria Winkeler said a questionnaire submitted by the man contained many confusing responses that called into question his fitness to serve on the jury. Earlier in the process, two other black candidates were dropped from consideration for undisclosed reasons.

On Monday, six women and three men with a wide range of ages were selected to the jury from a panel of roughly 75 candidates. The remaining selections on Tuesday were two men and a woman, bringing the jury breakdown to seven women and five men. The two alternates are a woman and a man. None of them are black.

The presentation of evidence is scheduled to begin Wednesday, a day ahead of the schedule Wahlberg demanded.

Of Tuesday’s panel, 26 candidates were excused and did not come back after lunch, most of them because they said they had already formed an opinion on the case through their exposure to media stories.

Later, a black woman requested to be excused because she is pregnant. Wahlberg tried to talk her out of it, saying “we need someone with your background and outlook.”

The woman ended up being sent home after she said she believed she couldn’t judge Criner because she had reviewed news reports in which Criner’s lawyers said their client suffers from mental health issues.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Trial begins for man accused of attacking 7 women in North Austin
Trial begins for man accused of attacking 7 women in North Austin

An aggravated assault trial begins Tuesday for an Austin man accused of committing a string of attacks against women, including incidents in which authorities say one woman was doused in gasoline and another was sexually assaulted while threatened with a knife. Police allege that Nicodemo Coria-Gonzalez, 27, attacked seven women between December 2015...
FORECAST: Sunshine, high temperature near 92, heat index of 100
FORECAST: Sunshine, high temperature near 92, heat index of 100

Tuesday forecast for Austin: A hot day with mostly sunny skies is in store for Central Texas, according to the National Weather Service.  Temperatures could reach 92 degrees with humidity driving up the heat index value, or the “feels like” temperature, to as high as 100, forecasters said.  Although the astronomical start...
Hurricane Florence: Trucker driving school bus rescues 64 dogs, cats from South Carolina
Hurricane Florence: Trucker driving school bus rescues 64 dogs, cats from South Carolina

A Tennessee truck driver is being hailed as a hero after he rescued 64 shelter dogs and cats ahead of Hurricane Florence. According to the Greenvale News, Tony Alsup, 51, from Greenback, Tennessee, drove a school bus to South Carolina last week as the deadly storm strengthened in the Atlantic. Once there, he stopped in Orangeburg, Georgetown, Dillon...
TRAFFIC ALERT: Bee Cave Road closed until noon between Loop 360, Barton Creek Blvd.
TRAFFIC ALERT: Bee Cave Road closed until noon between Loop 360, Barton Creek Blvd.

8:50 a.m. Tuesday update: Bee Cave Road will be closed from Barton Creek Boulevard to Loop 360 until noon Tuesday after an 18-wheeler crashed into utility poles and damaged them, causing some to be left without power, Monday night, Austin Energy officials confirmed. Since Monday night, power has been restored to most customers, but...
Is Ted Cruz’s ‘summons’ letter deceptive, illegal or fair play?
Is Ted Cruz’s ‘summons’ letter deceptive, illegal or fair play?

A “summons” letter from U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz’s re-election campaign that has landed in Central Texas mailboxes in recent days has reignited the debate about what qualifies as a deceptive and illegal fundraising practice. Austin resident Sean Owen shared on Twitter Saturday such a letter from the Cruz campaign addressed to his grandmother...
More Stories