Man charged with shooting Judge Kocurek seeks to suppress phone data


Highlights

Judge’s ruling will determine whether key evidence will be excluded from Onyeri’s trial.

Police took the phone after a traffic stop of a car that Chimene Onyeri was riding in.

An impending ruling on the lawfulness of a traffic stop will determine if federal prosecutors can present some of their strongest evidence in the trial of a man charged with shooting Travis County state District Judge Julie Kocurek.

Lawyers for Chimene Onyeri argued Thursday in federal court that law enforcement officials in Houston had no legal grounds to pull over a car in November 2015 in which Onyeri was suspected of being a passenger.

The traffic stop enabled investigators, who had an unrelated warrant for his arrest, to seize Onyeri’s phone. The investigators also had a search warrant for the phone and were able to unlock evidence they used to place him in Austin around the time that authorities say he and two other men ambushed Kocurek outside of her Tarrytown home, critically injuring her.

The Samsung phone associated with Onyeri was found broken into pieces in the car’s back seat, retired Austin police Detective Derek Israel testified.

Israel classified the information taken from the phone, which includes text message conversations with alleged accomplices, as “highly incriminating.”

Co-defendants Marcellus Burgin and Rasul Scott have pleaded guilty, leaving only Onyeri, 30, to stand trial on March 26. The charges for which Burgin and Scott pleaded are under a court-ordered seal. Neither has been sentenced.

Onyeri is charged with intent to commit capital murder. A 17-count indictment also accuses Onyeri of racketeering, mail fraud, identity theft and wire fraud.

The decision on the defense’s motion to suppress the cellphone records will be made by U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel, who said he’ll call lawyers on both sides once he reaches a conclusion. He hinted that the traffic stop appeared to be lawful based on testimony from a Houston police officer who said the driver of the Dodge Charger that Onyeri was traveling in had made an illegal turn. Authorities believe the driver was heading to Onyeri’s home, but turned off when he spotted agents in marked vehicles parked outside of the home.

Yeakel said he’d review his notes and make a decision soon.

As he was leaving court, Onyeri’s lawyer, Leonard Martinez, said that, regardless of Yeakel’s decision, “it’s going to be a difficult case.” The trial could take up to six weeks, Yeakel said.

Martinez said he’s not surprised Burgin and Scott pleaded guilty, adding, “We expected we’d be the only ones put to trial.”

Testimony from Israel, the retired police detective, revealed why investigators mistakenly dismissed a tip as false that could have prevented the attack.

Weeks before the shooting, an anonymous tipster informed the Travis County district attorney’s office that Onyeri had planned to kill the judge. The tipster was later revealed to be Onyeri’s girlfriend.

The tip was investigated but determined to be false, Israel testified.

“In retrospect, it was very credible,” he said.

READ: Confidential records detail decision not to warn Kocurek of threat

Israel said the mistake was made because investigators believed Onyeri had not been in in Kocurek’s court since 2012. The theory behind the shooting was that Onyeri was concerned Kocurek would send him back to prison. It turned out the investigators with the district attorney’s office were incorrect, and that Onyeri had actually been in her court the month before.

In his testimony, Israel did not name the person who made the mistake.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Grand jury indicts son of slain jeweler on capital murder charge

A grand jury on Wednesday indicted a 19-year-old who Travis County investigators have accused of planning to kill his father on a charge of capital murder, court records show. A two-page indictment says Nicolas Shaughnessy “knowingly caused the death of an individual” by hiring 21-year-old Johnny Roman Leon III of College Station to kill...
Austin police officer who killed Morgan Rankins won’t face criminal charges, DA says
Austin police officer who killed Morgan Rankins won’t face criminal charges, DA says

An Austin police officer who shot and killed 30-year-old Morgan London Rankins in 2017 will not face criminal charges, according to Travis County District Attorney Margaret Moore. The officer, Benjamin Rogers, shot Rankins on Feb. 22 after, according to police, she charged him with a knife. The events that led to the shooting began when police received...
TODAY: Austin police discussing school safety as students head back to class
TODAY: Austin police discussing school safety as students head back to class

Austin police on Thursday will discuss school safety as students head back to class this week. The Police Department has scheduled a news conference at 1 p.m. to offer tips to students and parents. Austin school district students return to campuses on Monday, but other districts throughout the region opened their doors this week. School safety has...
Floodgates at Tom Miller Dam will be replaced starting next week, LCRA says
Floodgates at Tom Miller Dam will be replaced starting next week, LCRA says

The Lower Colorado River Authority is investing nearly $10 million to replace the time-worn floodgates at Tom Miller Dam. The project is set to begin next week, and isn’t expected to cause any problems for boaters on Lake Austin. The dam has nine floodgates that are used to send floodwaters downstream to help control the water supply in the Austin...
Community news: Housing voucher wait list reopens

TRAVIS COUNTY AUSTIN Housing voucher list reopens The Housing Authority of the city of Austin will accept online pre-applications for the Housing Choice Voucher program, formerly known as Section 8, from Sept. 17 through 24, for the first time in four years. Applicants may apply for free at hacaapply.org, and applications typically take five to 10...
More Stories