Judge Kocurek’s accused shooter gets second chance to dispute evidence


Highlights

The defense is trying to suppress evidence that shows Onyeri was in Austin at the time of the shooting.

Defendant Chimene Onyeri’s trial is scheduled to begin March 26.

The man charged with the attempted murder of Travis County state District Judge Julie Kocurek will get a second chance to suppress key evidence after his defense team located a previously unavailable witness.

Attorneys for Chimene Onyeri argued last week in federal court that a cellphone showing Onyeri was in Austin around the time of Kocurek’s November 2015 shooting was seized during an unlawful traffic stop. According to testimony from a former Austin police detective, evidence scraped from the phone is “highly incriminating” and contains text messages between Onyeri and two co-defendants who have already pleaded guilty.

U.S. Judge Lee Yeakel said last week that he plans to rule on the defense motion to suppress the evidence soon so that the losing side will have time to regroup ahead of a March 26 trial.

READ: Investigator’s error led to dismissal of threat on Judge Kocurek’s life

But before Yeakel issued his ruling, Onyeri’s attorneys asked to present an additional witness — the driver of the vehicle, Reginald Matthews, who was previously unavailable to testify, according to an email they sent to the judge Thursday evening.

“Turns out that hood folks don’t return calls or cards from ‘investigators,’” defense lawyer Victor Arana wrote.

Yeakel wants to hear from Matthews, and he ordered that the hearing reconvene on Wednesday.

Authorities say Matthews was driving a Dodge Charger carrying Onyeri and two other men on the night of Onyeri’s arrest. The car made an abrupt left turn after spotting authorities camped outside of Onyeri’s home in Houston, according to testimony from agents who worked on the investigation.

A Houston police officer said he initiated the traffic stop after Matthews made an illegal turn into a far lane. Onyeri’s lawyers suggested the officer had lied about the illegal turn to justify the stop.

READ: Three men indicted in plot to kill Judge Kocurek

Onyeri was arrested on an outstanding warrant from Louisiana. His phone, which investigators say was smashed into pieces, was taken into evidence through a search warrant.

Investigators say Onyeri was motivated to kill Kocurek through a belief that the judge would revoke his probation on a 2012 larceny charge and send him back to jail, thus thwarting a criminal fraud operation he had headed.

A 17-count indictment accuses Onyeri, 30, of attempted murder, racketeering, mail fraud, identity theft and wire fraud. His trial could take up to six weeks, Yeakel said.

Co-defendants Marcellus Burgin and Rasul Scott pleaded guilty. The specifics of the deals they agreed to are being kept under court-ordered seal.

Kocurek has returned to the bench in the 390th District Court, but not before losing her left index finger as a result of the attack outside of her Tarrytown home.

Onyeri twice has been charged in Houston with murder, but in both cases the charges were dropped.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Abbott to launch 3 days of private gun discussions
Abbott to launch 3 days of private gun discussions

Inviting advocates on opposing sides of the gun debate, Gov. Greg Abbott will kick off three days of roundtable discussions on school safety with a Tuesday event featuring districts that arm teachers or have partnerships with local police. The hastily organized Capitol meetings, however, will be closed to the public and open to the media only at the...
Witnesses contradict what Crispin Harmel told police in 2009 slaying
Witnesses contradict what Crispin Harmel told police in 2009 slaying

Prosecutors wrapped up their capital murder case against Crispin Harmel on Monday by presenting three witnesses who contradicted what Harmel told police during the investigation of the 2009 strangulation death of Jessika Kalaher. Harmel told police then that he could not give them the shirt he had worn when he was with Kalaher because it was at a friend&rsquo...
Pond keeps unwanted pet fish out of San Marcos River
Pond keeps unwanted pet fish out of San Marcos River

Conservationists are hoping that a small pond in San Marcos will help protect endangered species in the San Marcos River. The pond, about 4 feet long and 3 feet wide, was built about a year and a half ago by the San Marcos Discovery Center for people who want to drop off unwanted pet fish. Otherwise such non-native fish, if dumped into the river or...
Texas given 45 days to fix motor-voter violation; Paxton appeals
Texas given 45 days to fix motor-voter violation; Paxton appeals

A federal judge has given Texas officials 45 days to correct an online voter registration system that was found to violate federal law, rejecting state arguments that the ordered changes cannot be accomplished before Dec. 1. U.S. District Judge Orlando Garcia of San Antonio said the tight deadline was justified because the November election is looming...
Officers report smelling burnt marijuana at day care where baby died
Officers report smelling burnt marijuana at day care where baby died

Officials who responded last week to the death of a 5-month-old at an in-home daycare in Northwest Austin found what they believe was marijuana in the home as well as the odor of “burnt marijuana,” according to a search warrant affidavit obtained Monday. No charges have been filed in the baby’s death at the home on Truman Cove, and...
More Stories