Gun vs. scissors fight leads to acquittal in Austin murder trial


Highlights

Defense lawyer asked for testing of bloody scissors found in area of shooting.

Stephens, 49, had no criminal history when he fatally shot Dedrick Earl in November 2016.

A man who fatally shot a man armed with scissors was acquitted of murder and got to go home Friday after a year and a half behind bars.

After deliberating for three hours Thursday, the Travis County jury weighing Melvin Stephens’ self-defense claim needed just 15 minutes Friday morning to return the not-guilty verdict.

“Really happy for Melvin,” his lawyer Robb Shepherd said. “He gets to go home to his family.”

The defense overcame a police interview shown on video to the jury in which Stephens, 49, told investigators he regretted shooting Dedrick Earl and that he “didn’t have to” do it. The two had been feuding at a North Austin apartment complex after Earl and another man vandalized Stephens’ Ford Taurus with ashes from a burned magazine.

But from the witness stand, Stephens testified that he had reconsidered the November 2016 incident and realized his life was in danger when Earl, 22, sprinted up a flight of steps as Stephens was retreating to his home.

Although Stephens never saw the scissors that detectives later discovered on the steps near the area of the shooting, he told the jury that he assumed Earl had grabbed a weapon when he went into a downstairs apartment moments before the fatal confrontation. Stephens fired his .357-caliber revolver, striking Earl in the neck.

A friend who was with Earl at the time of the shooting and saw the scissors told police “it looked like he was going to use it to attack the dude.”

BE THE FIRST TO KNOW: When big news breaks, we send Breaking News emails. Click to sign up

Police never referenced the scissors in a four-page arrest affidavit. There also was no mention of them in a January 2017 grand jury proceeding that led to an indictment and allowed the case to proceed, Shepherd said.

Shepherd said investigators did not order that the scissors be tested for DNA. He later had them tested with the approval of prosecutors, and blood found on them was Earl’s.

Shepherd said he was “irritated” that police made a rush to judgment.

“A poor black man like Melvin Stephens defends himself, justifiably so, and the case has to go to a grand jury,” he said.

There were no pretrial plea negotiations, Shepherd said, and there was no question that he and Stephens wanted a trial.

At the time of the shooting, Stephens was working as a security guard for a company that was under contract to National Instruments. Stephens had no criminal history and had never been arrested.

For a month in 2015, Stephens was homeless and lived in his car. He showered at a gym and saved up money to rent a place.

“He pulled himself up,” Shepherd said.

Stephens is divorced with one child, who is attending college in Sacramento.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Florida man shoots girlfriend once, returns and shoots her fatally, deputies say
Florida man shoots girlfriend once, returns and shoots her fatally, deputies say

A Florida man faces a first-degree murder charge after allegedly firing a shot at his girlfriend, fleeing the scene, then returning and shooting her a number of times, The Tampa Bay Times reported. >> Read more trending news  Nathaniel J. Yates, 32, of Largo, is accused in the shooting death of Christine Giles, 28, of Seminole, according...
How did low-income Texas schools fare under state’s A-F rating system?
How did low-income Texas schools fare under state’s A-F rating system?

Although they tended to perform better under the state’s new school rating system than under the previous one, Texas schools with the highest rates of low-income children still performed worse than schools with wealthier student bodies. Among Texas schools with the highest percentages of low-income students, 6 percent of them failed to meet state...
PolitiFact: Increasing share of state money goes to charter schools
PolitiFact: Increasing share of state money goes to charter schools

A Democratic legislator declared that state aid fully fuels Texas charter schools while schools serving the vast bulk of students field less money. State Rep. Donna Howard of Austin said in a tweet: “Here’s the thing. In Tx, charters get 100% state $/pupil funding while district schools (95% students) get about 1/3 funding from state w/...
Traffic report for Aug. 20, 2018

Interstate 35 (Hays County): Various closures in both directions between Yarrington Road and Robert S. Light Boulevard from 9 p.m. to 5 a.m. Monday through Thursday nights. Interstate 35 (Travis County): The left lane on the southbound access road will be closed between Three Points Road and Cheddar Loop Road from 9 p.m. to 5 a.m. Monday through Thursday...
As first bell rings Monday, Mendez Middle School gets second chance
As first bell rings Monday, Mendez Middle School gets second chance

Mendez Middle School’s Principal Joanna Carrillo-Rowley knocked on the door to the mobile home. Wearing jeans, a school shirt and a pair of Converse shoes, Carrillo-Rowley was pounding the pavement on a recent summer night in search of students who were zoned to attend her middle school but had not registered. It was a tactic she previously used...
More Stories