Federal judge upholds activist Antonio Buehler’s right to film officers


A federal lawsuit filed by local activist Antonio Buehler against the Austin Police Department has cleared a hurdle as a U.S. magistrate judge this week upheld his constitutional right to photograph and film police officers.

In an order filed Thursday, Judge Mark Lane denied motions to dismiss the case, finding that private citizens have the right to record officers in public places as they perform their official duties and that such a right had clearly been established in Buehler’s case.

The judge dismissed his claims of excessive force and malicious prosecution, but Lane said the officers were not immune from allegations that they had arrested and searched him without probable cause, according to the documents filed in the U.S. Western District of Texas.

Lane also declined to dismiss claims that the police department had failed to establish a policy and provide training addressing how officers should proceed when being videotaped or photographed by citizens.

The city can now appeal the judge’s decision to the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. If the appeal is denied, the case moves forward until a settlement is reached or the parties go to trial.

Requests for comment to the city attorney representing the department were not immediately returned Friday.

Daphne Silverman, Buehler’s lawyer, said she and her client were pleased with Lane’s detailed analysis in support of his First Amendment and constitutional rights.

“This ruling is a clear signal to law enforcement that the public can now photograph and videotape police officers so long as they don’t interfere with the officer’s duties,” she said.

Buehler, a 37-year-old Army veteran and founder of the Peaceful Streets Project, has been in dispute with the department since officers arrested him New Year’s Day 2012 as he videotaped a woman getting arrested on Lamar and 10th Street. Buehler has alleged he was trying to capture the officers abusing the driver and her passenger, and he later founded Peaceful Streets, in which members record police encounters and post them online.

The National Press Photographers Association in May filed an amicus brief in support of his case, which the organization says is not an isolated incident but “part of a nationwide phenomenon where police have interfered with citizens’ rights to photograph and video-record officers engaged in official business in public spaces.”

“NPPA follows these cases closely, and strives to ensure that the crucial role that journalists and citizens play in promoting discussions of public concern is not diminished,” the brief states.

To read more about his case, read here.

Follow Jazmine Ulloa on Twitter: @jazmineulloa


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Phoenix police officer, gunman critical after shootout
Phoenix police officer, gunman critical after shootout

A Phoenix police officer and the driver of a car he was attempting to stop were in critical condition early Friday after exchanging gunfire, KNXV reported. >> Read more trending news  Authorities said the officer was attempting a traffic stop but the driver initially refused to stop, the television station reported. The driver finally...
Man asks Manhattan clerk, 'Are you Arabic?' before punching him
Man asks Manhattan clerk, 'Are you Arabic?' before punching him

A man asked a bodega clerk in Manhattan “Are you Arabic?” before punching the surprised man in the face, The New York Daily News reported.  >> Read more trending news  The man asked the question on Aug. 9 at the Green Olive Deli around 10 a.m., police said. Surveillance videos do not show the punch being thrown, but...
UPDATE: 21-year-old man dead after police shooting in downtown Austin
UPDATE: 21-year-old man dead after police shooting in downtown Austin

6:15 a.m. update: A 21-year-old man died early Friday after eight Austin police officers shot at in an alley of Sixth Street in downtown Austin. Assistant Chief Troy Gay said police opened fire on the man behind the Terminal 6 bar at around 1 a.m. Several disturbances were reported at the club, including one in the alley where shots were fired...
FDA cautions some people using pets to obtain opioids
FDA cautions some people using pets to obtain opioids

Pet owners could be stealing opioids that were meant for their pets, according to a statement Wednesday from Dr. Scott Gottlieb, commissioner of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration. >> Read more trending news  “We recognize that opioids and other pain medications have a legitimate and important role in treating pain in animals...
Multiple students arrested after brawl at Indianapolis high school
Multiple students arrested after brawl at Indianapolis high school

Thirteen students were arrested after a brawl Thursday at an Indianapolis high school, the Indianapolis Star reported. >> Read more trending news  The fight, witnessed by more than 100 students, occurred at Arsenal Tech High School, WXIN reported. Authorities said no weapons were involved during the fight, which began inside the...
More Stories