breaking news

Austin man accused of several attacks found guilty of sexual assault

Appeals court rules Crispin Harmel can be retried for capital murder


The Texas 3rd Court of Appeals ruled Wednesday that a man can be retried in a 2009 capital murder case that led to Williamson County’s district attorney spending a few days in jail.

The court ruled that Crispin Harmel, whose first trial in 2014 ended in a mistrial when the judge ruled that prosecutors didn’t share evidence with the defense, won’t face double jeopardy — being prosecuted twice for the same offense — if he is tried again.

One of Harmel’s attorneys, Ryan Deck, said Wednesday he couldn’t comment on the ruling because of a gag order in the case. Williamson County District Attorney Jana Duty and state District Judge Rick Kennon didn’t return requests for comment.

Duty spent a few days in jail during August 2015 for violating Kennon’s gag order by speaking to an American-Statesman reporter.

Defense attorneys have the option of appealing the ruling to the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.

One of Harmel’s defense lawyers, Kristen Jernigan, had appealed the case in September, saying Duty had intentionally caused the mistrial by withholding evidence.

Double jeopardy bars a retrial when the prosecutor’s conduct was intentional in provoking the request for a mistrial.

Harmel is accused of strangling Jessika Kalaher in 2009 after following her out of a Wal-Mart in Cedar Park. He was released from jail May 9, 2014, after the mistrial was declared.

Bob Phillips, a Georgetown criminal defense attorney for more than 30 years, said Wednesday that it is “rare for an appellate court to determine double jeopardy has attached just because a mistrial has been declared.”

The court’s ruling Wednesday said Duty intentionally withheld evidence connected to a Wal-Mart video during Harmel’s first trial. But the ruling also said there was “nothing in the record, however, to indicate that the State acted with the intent to provoke Harmel to request a mistrial in order to avoid an acquittal or for any other reason.”

Defense attorneys had asked during Harmel’s first trial for a copy of a surveillance video with time stamps, the ruling said. The video was crucial to the trial because there was no DNA evidence and no weapon was found.

The prosecutors figured out during the trial how to display the time stamps on the video but didn’t share that information with defense attorneys until playing the video during the trial, the 3rd Court of Appeals ruling said.

The time stamps were at odds with the defense’s timeline of events.

Duty later admitted in a district court hearing that “she withheld this information from defense counsel for a variety of reasons, including her perceived mistreatment by defense counsel,” according to Wednesday’s ruling.

The ruling also said that when an appeals court reviews a double jeopardy claim, it “will view the evidence in the light most favorable to the trial court’s ruling, understanding that the trial court is in the best position to make the evaluations necessary to this type of decision, particularly where a prosecutor’s state of mind is concerned.”

Kennon, who presided over Harmel’s first trial, had ruled in September that, even though Duty had withheld evidence in the case, Harmel could be retried.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

JUST IN: Man shot during burglary, aggravated robbery in San Marcos, police say
JUST IN: Man shot during burglary, aggravated robbery in San Marcos, police say

A man is in stable condition after he was shot during a robbery and burglary in San Marcos early Thursday, San Marcos police said. Police responded to the Lodge Apartments at 1975 Aquarena Springs Drive in Northeast San Marcos around 12:22 a.m., they said. When police arrived, they found a man inside an apartment trying to give first aid to another...
Texas bride paralyzed in boogie board accident in Hawaii
Texas bride paralyzed in boogie board accident in Hawaii

A Texas woman’s dream honeymoon in Hawaii earlier this month turned nightmarish when she was paralyzed in a freak boogie boarding accident, KXAS reported. >> Read more trending news  Nikki Lewis and Will Lewis were married Sept. 8 in a destination wedding on Maui. Days later, the couple and some friends were at the beach. While...
Affidavit: Austin activist Chas Moore punched bar owner after Sixth Street scuffle
Affidavit: Austin activist Chas Moore punched bar owner after Sixth Street scuffle

Austin Justice Coalition director Chas Moore punched the manager of Recess Arcade Bar in May after he refused to leave the establishment, court documents filed Thursday say. Moore was charged with misdemeanor assault after the scuffle, according to the documents. He was no longer in Travis County Jail on Thursday afternoon. On May 27, Moore entered...
Former DPS director Thomas Davis to be remembered in Austin on Friday
Former DPS director Thomas Davis to be remembered in Austin on Friday

Texas Department of Public Safety Col. Thomas Davis Jr., whose 43-year career with the agency included eight challenging years as its director, died last week from lung cancer. He was 77. Davis, who died Sept. 14, will be remembered by family, friends and colleagues at a funeral Friday at Shoreline Church, 15201 Burnet Road in Austin. The service is...
James Brown's daughter, Venisha Brown, dead at 53
James Brown's daughter, Venisha Brown, dead at 53

Venisha Brown, one of the daughters of the late Godfather of Soul James Brown and the late Yvonne Fair, formerly of the Chantels, died Wednesday. She was 53. >> Read more trending news  Venisha Brown died at Augusta University Health Medical Center in Augusta due to complications from pneumonia, according to a release from the ...
More Stories