Court upholds ruling requiring Texas to reveal execution drug source


Rejecting an appeal from state officials, the Texas Supreme Court on Friday let stand a lower-court ruling requiring Texas to identify the pharmacy that supplied its execution drugs as part of a 2014 legal challenge.

The state’s highest civil court declined to accept the case without comment, other than to note that Justice Jimmy Blacklock — formerly a legal adviser to Gov. Greg Abbott — did not participate in discussions of the case.

Prison officials have worked for years to avoid identifying the source of the state’s lethal injection drugs, arguing that the publicity would deter suppliers from selling to the state over fears of protests and threats from death penalty opponents.

The Austin-based 3rd Court of Appeals, however, ruled in May 2017 that exceptions in the Texas Public Information Act did not apply to the information, sought in 2014 by three lawyers who represented death row inmates, because state lawyers could point only to vague threats of violence against suppliers.

Maurie Levin, one of the lawyers who sought the information, praised the court’s action as a victory for transparency but said its impact will likely be limited by a 2015 law that allows state prison officials to keep secret the name of the pharmacy or company that sells execution drugs to Texas.

“We are hopeful that in light of the Supreme Court’s decision today, the state will finally honor the district court’s 2014 order commanding the state to disclose the source of its lethal injection drugs. Today’s decision is a win for the fundamental principles of transparency and open government,” Levin said.

Prison officials will ask the Supreme Court to reconsider its ruling, said Jeremy Desel, spokesman for the prison agency.

Motions for a rehearing, however, are rarely granted by the court.

The dispute began when the lawyers for death row inmates, seeking to verify that the state’s execution protocols would not produce an unconstitutional level of pain and suffering, asked the Texas Department of Public Safety to reveal the drugs used in executions, the source of the drugs and any testing performed to verify their effectiveness.

Prison officials declined to name the source, saying only that execution drugs were purchased from a licensed compounding pharmacy in Texas. An opinion from state Attorney General Ken Paxton agreed that the source of execution drugs must be kept secret because of the threat of harm to the company and its employees.

But writing for the 3rd Court of Appeals three-judge panel, Justice Bob Pemberton said prison officials pointed only to isolated, vague threats against suppliers of execution drugs. That was not enough to show a “substantial threat of physical harm,” a standard established by the Texas Supreme Court in 2011, to withhold the information under state law, Pemberton wrote.

Allowing governments to withhold information based on a threat of violence, Pemberton warned, could vastly expand the amount of information that could be kept from the public.

“Virtually all who participate in our government and its functions face not only the potential comment and criticism that are fair game in our free society, but will at some point bear some degree of risk of … physical violence,” he wrote.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Austin police officer who killed Morgan Rankins won’t face criminal charges, DA says
Austin police officer who killed Morgan Rankins won’t face criminal charges, DA says

An Austin police officer who shot and killed 30-year-old Morgan London Rankins in 2017 will not face criminal charges, according to Travis County District Attorney Margaret Moore. The officer, Benjamin Rogers, shot Rankins on Feb. 22 after, according to police, she charged him with a knife. The events that led to the shooting began when police received...
TODAY: Austin police discussing school safety as students head back to class
TODAY: Austin police discussing school safety as students head back to class

Austin police on Thursday will discuss school safety as students head back to class this week. The Police Department has scheduled a news conference at 1 p.m. to offer tips to students and parents. Austin school district students return to campuses on Monday, but other districts throughout the region opened their doors this week. School safety has...
Floodgates at Tom Miller Dam will be replaced starting next week, LCRA says
Floodgates at Tom Miller Dam will be replaced starting next week, LCRA says

The Lower Colorado River Authority is investing nearly $10 million to replace the time-worn floodgates at Tom Miller Dam. The project is set to begin next week, and isn’t expected to cause any problems for boaters on Lake Austin. The dam has nine floodgates that are used to send floodwaters downstream to help control the water supply in the Austin...
Community news: Housing voucher wait list reopens

TRAVIS COUNTY AUSTIN Housing voucher list reopens The Housing Authority of the city of Austin will accept online pre-applications for the Housing Choice Voucher program, formerly known as Section 8, from Sept. 17 through 24, for the first time in four years. Applicants may apply for free at hacaapply.org, and applications typically take five to 10...
Man charged with stalking girlfriend for months before choking her, police say 
Man charged with stalking girlfriend for months before choking her, police say 

A man suspected of sending threatening messages to his girlfriend for two months before choking her was arrested on Thursday, court documents say. James Tate, 39, has been charged with stalking and felony assault strangulation, court documents show. Police said Tate began sending text messages and leaving voicemails threatening to kill his girlfriend...
More Stories