The bright (and not-so-bright) side of making Jell-O cookies


Jell-O and cookies are two super kid-friendly desserts, but what happens when you combine them?

A few weeks ago, a reader emailed about Jell-O cookies she’d seen in an Arizona newspaper that she thought me and my boys might like to try for a summer project. I picked up some Jell-O on a slow weekend day and we set out to try this somewhat weird combination.

The recipe is a simple sugar cookie recipe, but some of the sugar is replaced with the Jell-O. The original recipe said you could halve the recipe to make different colors, so that’s what I did, but I made the mistake of using the whole package of Jell-O in each. I was just trying not to waste half a pack of Jell-O, but looking back, I should have just tossed that extra 1 1/2 ounces because the resulting cookies — though cute — were too tart and sour to really enjoy. The cookies do need that extra 1/2 cup of granulated sugar and even the decorative sugar (or, in our case, Skittles) to sweeten the treats.

Otherwise, this was a fun cookie to make! The dough has a nice texture to it that’s easy to roll and cut with the cookie cutters. The bright red color of the cherry Jell-O was more eye-popping than the grape flavor, and even though we didn’t like that first batch (because of my error), I’m going to try again with the lime Jell-O, just to see how the green turns out. You can just use food coloring to brighten up your sugar cookie dough.

Jell-O Cookies

3/4 cup butter, slightly softened

1/2 cup granulated sugar

1 (3-ounce) package Jell-O or flavored gelatin powder (not sugar-free)

2 large eggs, room temperature

1 teaspoon salt

1 1/2 teaspoons baking powder

2 1/2 cups flour, or slightly more if batter is too sticky

Food coloring, if desired for more color

In a mixing bowl, cream together butter, sugar and Jell-O until well blended. Add eggs, and cream well. Add salt, baking powder and flour, mixing well. Add food coloring if desired.

Scoop dough into a bowl, cover and refrigerate for 1 to 2 hours to harden. When ready to bake, heat oven to 350 degrees. On a lightly floured surface, roll out dough 1/4- to 1/2-inch thick. Use cookie cutters to cut out patterns. Sprinkle with decorative sugar.

Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Place cookies on baking sheet about 1 inch apart. Bake for 12 to 15 minutes or until done. Let cool on baking rack and then store in airtight container.

— Adapted from a recipe by Jan D’Atri



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Austin360 Eats

In debate over butter vs. brown butter, brown butter wins in this lemon bar recipe
In debate over butter vs. brown butter, brown butter wins in this lemon bar recipe

Deep thinkers debate good versus evil, while baked goods, which have goodness baked right in, debate good versus better, which is to say butter versus brown butter. Butter set over steady heat separates; left to sizzle, the milk solids toast in the milk fat, turning sweet, creamy butter into rich, nutty brown butter. If brown butter is better than...
Can I drink alcohol while taking antibiotics?
Can I drink alcohol while taking antibiotics?

A: With some antibiotics, the answer is a definite no. With most, however, the answer may be a cautious yes. Concerns about alcohol and antibiotics may have their roots in the rubber industry of the 1880s. Around this time, manufacturers began using a chemical known as disulfiram to accelerate the vulcanization of rubber. Soon, rubber workers began...
Real Simple launches Real Simple Cooking School
Real Simple launches Real Simple Cooking School

Meredith Corporation's REAL  SIMPLE today announced that it has launched REAL SIMPLE Cooking  School, a new multiplatform cooking series that teaches viewers the  basics of cooking and shares smart kitchen tips and inspiration for  meals. REAL SIMPLE Cooking School is now available on  REALSIMPLE.com/CookingSchool.  The...
A Mo. family made a special connection with Anthony Bourdain
A Mo. family made a special connection with Anthony Bourdain

Anthony Bourdain wanted the Piña-White family of Eureka, Mo., to enjoy the best food they could as they cruised through Europe on a Make-A-Wish Foundation trip. The celebrity chef and author knew the foundation didn’t provide for the food the family would eat off the ship, so he quietly wrote them a check with recommendations of restaurants...
I tried one of IHOP's new Steakburgers, and something's missing
I tried one of IHOP's new Steakburgers, and something's missing

The problem arose as soon as I asked the IHOP server if I could order my burger medium-rare. He shifted in place for a second before telling me that he has repeatedly asked the kitchen to do exactly that and the cooks always reject the request. Then he looked up at the ceiling, as if he couldn't even meet my eyes as he delivered the bad news. I sort...
More Stories