A new study on gender and racial figures in pop music proves the old James Brown refrain is still true: It’s a man’s man’s man’s world.
The study, in part, looked at the gender breakdown of Grammy Award nominees, and found a wide imbalance. A total of 90.7 percent of nominees between 2013 and 2018 were male, meaning just 9.3 percent were women.
Stacy L. Smith, Marc Choueiti and Kate Pieper, of the USC Annenberg Inclusion Initiative, tracked the gender and racial breakdown of performers, writers and producers across the top echelons of the pop charts and the Grammy Awards.
The full results of the work, titled “Inclusion in the Recording Studio? Gender and Race/Ethnicity of Artists, Songwriters & Producers Across 600 Popular Songs from 2012-2017,” was released Jan. 25, a few days before the 60th Grammy Awards.
While one might suspect that an era seemingly dominated by major female stars such as Taylor Swift, Adele and Beyoncé would have a more even split, the workaday figures for representation in pop music today remain startling in their male dominance. And in 2017, the figures seemed to be getting worse.
“That’s a goal, to find out the impediments in the hiring and recruiting process and where there might be bias that excludes women,” Smith said.
Women nominated for Grammy Awards, for instance, were most likely to be recognized for best new artist or song of the year and least likely to be up for producer of the year. In the time period surveyed, not a single woman got a nod in that category.
“One thing that’s important is to not let high-profile women be the sole source of recognition” at the Grammys, Pieper said.
The general figures of the gender breakdown in pop music show similar imbalances. In 2017, 83.2 percent of artists across the top pop songs were male and just 16.8 percent were women. That’s a sharp drop-off from 2016, when women were the featured artist on 28.1 percent of the same charts, or even from 2012 with 22.7 percent.
The numbers get even more skewed when looking specifically at musical groups rather than popular solo acts. For bands, the gender makeup was 91.3 percent male (70.5 percent of bands were all men), and for duos, 94.9 percent of members were male.
“At the top of your mind, you can name prominent female solo artists and think things are good,” Smith said. “This data challenges that, especially with how few women are songwriters and producers.”
One slight upside to the findings: In 2017, slightly more than half of the top acts surveyed were from minority racial or ethnic groups. Specifically, 51.9 percent of acts surveyed were minorities, a figure 13.5 points higher than five years ago.
In songwriting, the numbers are even more imbalanced. Credited songwriters from 2017 were 87.7 percent male and 12.3 percent female, a figure that has barely budged since 2012. Of those female songwriters, 40.2 percent were from minority groups, including a notable bump in 2017 to 54.4 percent.
A mere nine male songwriters were responsible for nearly 20 percent of all songs surveyed in the time period.
Interestingly, the vast majority (nay, all but one) of the top-credited female songwriters were also credited in the survey as artists, while only one male in the same group was a credited artist as well. Female artists were also notably more likely to use female songwriters than their male peers were.
“Those results are encouraging, that female artists are advocating for female peers,” Smith said.
As for production credits, the disparity is so vast as to be almost totally dominated by men. An astonishing 98 percent of credited producers across the top surveyed songs were men. Only two women of color had production credits among the songs surveyed, and a full 95.7 percent of songs had no female production credits whatsoever.
“For women of color, that’s an epidemic of invisibility,” Smith said.
In the wake of the #MeToo and #TimesUp movements that have swept through the film and television industries, these figures could be part of a turning point in addressing similar gender disparities in music.
“One thing that’s been interesting to watch in film is the development of a critical mass of people who care about these issues,” Pieper said. “These are all linked issues and they have to be addressed together.”
CENTRAL TEXAS AT THE GRAMMYS
Country trio Midland and former American-Statesman journalist Michael Corcoran are among Austin-area nominees for the 60th Grammy Awards, which will air on CBS at 6:30 p.m. Sunday.
Midland’s hit single “Drinkin’ Problem” is up for Best Country/Duo Group Performance and got a nod in the Best Country Song category. Band members Jess Carson, Cameron Duddy and Mark Wystrach share that nomination with their co-writers Shane McAnally and Josh Osborne.
Corcoran’s two nominations are for “Washington Phillips and His Manzarene Dreams,” a compilation of works by the early-20th-century Texas gospel musician. He shares the nomination in the Historical Album category with his co-producers April G. Ledbetter and Steven Lance Ledbetter as well as mastering engineer Michael Graves. He’s also nominated in the Album Notes category for his liner notes to the release.
Two Austin musicians share in the Contemporary Blues Album nomination for “Live From the Fox Oakland” by Tedeschi Trucks Band, which includes local drummer J.J. Johnson and trumpeter Ephraim Owens. Former Austinite Sam Beam, a.k.a. Iron & Wine, is nominated in the Americana Album category for his latest record “Beast Epic.”
— Peter Blackstock