Marvel or DC? Texas wants it both ways on comic book favorites


The most boring question in all of geekdom: Are you a DC or a Marvel fan?

Hold on a second, I need to push my glasses up on my nose.

DC and Marvel are the world’s two dominant comic book companies, the ones that have published the adventures of Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman (on the DC side) and Spider-Man, Iron Man and the X-Men (on the Marvel side) for decades. Asking which company is your favorite rankles me, because if you love comics, why choose? It's the sort of thing you'd be asked by the kid in your high school algebra class who just found an issue of "Wolverine" in the lost-and-found and decided that Batman is lame because he doesn't have superpowers.

(He would be wrong, of course, because Batman's superpower is generational wealth.)

With the sublime "Black Panther" dominating both the box office and the cultural conversation this month, though, it's worth casting an eye toward each house's output during the great superhero movie boom of the past couple decades. It's hard to deny that Marvel has soared where DC's silver screen seems cursed by green kryptonite, "Wonder Woman" notwithstanding. That's not because of the characters, mind you. Even Beyoncé would flop if she was directed by Zack Snyder.

RELATED: ‘Black Panther’ is the king of them all

Here's where I, whose first comic book purchases as a child were issues of Green Lantern and Superboy (both DC characters) from the Comics Cave on Westgate Lane, start to have doom-filled thoughts. Are DC's muddy-colored and poorly scripted movies dragging down their almost century-old icons in the public mind?

According to a study by satellite TV retailer USDish, they could be getting crowded out, at least. Citing Google Trends data, USDish found that most U.S. states — including Texas —prefer Marvel comic books over their DC counterparts. A few states like Kentucky, Oregon and Indiana are clear-cut Marvel fans, the study found. Only eight states (and fittingly, Washington, D.C.) swing for Wonder Woman's parent company. Five eastern states couldn't pick a super-fast horse in the race, going 50-50 for Marvel and DC.

There's still some hope for the people who brought you the Flash and Aquaman, though. (DC, just in case that's not clear.)

"Most states, though, barely reach consensus," according to the study. "In Mississippi, Iowa, and Pennsylvania, DC or Marvel comics win by a single point."

The study also found each state's favorite superhero. In Texas, the Man of Steel is our hero, even if we do prefer the house of the Hulk overall. Mixed message, y’all. We've looked a previous super-studies along these lines that seem to fly in the face of that finding, which named Batman as the Lone Star State's protector of choice.

A battle between Superman and Batman to see who comes out on top? Been there, done that, saw the movie, wished I hadn't seen the movie.

Correction: An earlier version of this post incorrectly attributed the original study to Dish Network. USDish is an online authorized sales agent of Dish.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Movies & TV

ACL Fest: Weekend one, both Saturdays of the fest are sold out
ACL Fest: Weekend one, both Saturdays of the fest are sold out

All three-day passes and single-day tickets for weekend one (Oct. 5-7) of Austin City Limits Festival are now sold out. An adoring crowd cheers Willie Nelson’s performance at The Austin City Limits Music Festival 2016. (Tamir Kalifa for American-Statesman) Friday and Sunday have been sold out for a while, but we’re guessing the ...
Not into ACL Fest? Outside the City Limits, at a scenic Hill Country brewery, is your alternative
Not into ACL Fest? Outside the City Limits, at a scenic Hill Country brewery, is your alternative

There’s no doubt Austin City Limits Festival has become an indelible piece of our music-loving city’s identity, but for people who would prefer a more low-key day of tunes away from the hubbub coming to Zilker Park, one Driftwood brewery is offering an alternative. Vista Brewing has teamed up with Sun Radio for Outside the City...
Willie Nelson doesn’t care if you’re mad about his Beto O’Rourke support
Willie Nelson doesn’t care if you’re mad about his Beto O’Rourke support

Mad that Willie Nelson is playing at a rally for U.S. Rep. Beto O'Rourke? You’re entitled to your opinion, the Austin icon and country music legend says. Nelson will headline a concert for the El Paso Democrat, who is running to unseat Republican U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz, on Sept. 29 at Auditorium Shores. That hasn't settled well with some conservative...
Leon Bridges to join Willie Nelson at Beto rally at Auditorium Shores
Leon Bridges to join Willie Nelson at Beto rally at Auditorium Shores

The rally for U.S. Senate candidate Beto O’Rourke, set for Sept. 29 at Auditorium Shores, was already destined to be a Texas-sized spectacle with local legend, Willie Nelson headlining. On Wednesday afternoon, the show got even bigger as Leon Bridges, who recently sold out two nights at ACL Live, announced plans to join...
Big names, local favorites: Your Austin live music calendar for fall
Big names, local favorites: Your Austin live music calendar for fall

Remember those late-summer days when everyone seemed to be on vacation and not a lot of touring shows were coming through town? Welcome to fall, when everything’s completely different and music is falling off the trees everywhere. The proof is in our list of more than 300 events from now through December, including arena and theater concerts...
More Stories