breaking news

Texas high court says Xerox can’t blame dentists in Medicaid fraud case

Hopdoddy suit says Oklahoma restaurant is an ‘unauthorized clone’


It’s a battle over Bunz.

HopBunz, a Tulsa, Okla., burger joint, to be exact.

The owners of Austin-based Hopdoddy Burger Bar have filed suit against the Oklahoma restaurant, accusing it of trademark infringement, copyright infringement, unfair competition and unjust enrichment.

The saga began in March 2014 when Oklahoma restaurateur James Blacketer allegedly approached Hopdoddy, asking to buy a franchise, according to documents filed this week in U.S. District Court in Austin. However, Hopdoddy, which has a pair of locations in Austin, as well as ones in the Dallas area, Denver and Scottsdale, Ariz., doesn’t sell franchise rights.

Undeterred, Blacketer allegedly sent an email to Hopdoddy executives that said, in part, “I know you said that you were not interested in franchising Hopdoddy’s (nevertheless) … I hope to open discussion on (acquiring) a franchise of Hopdoddy’s,” according to the suit.

Again, Hopdoddy executives said they declined Blacketer’s request.

By August, Blacketer had opened his own restaurant, HopBunz Crafted Burgers and Beers, in Tulsa, court records indicate. Hopdoddy calls HopBunz “an unauthorized clone.”

A second HopBunz, also in the Tulsa area, has since opened.

HopBunz didn’t respond to a message from the American-Statesman seeking comment.

Hopdoddy president and CEO Dan Mesches said the suit was a last resort.

“We respect everyone’s right to bring quality burgers to food lovers across the country and understand that imitation can be the sincerest form of flattery, but HopBunz has unfortunately created confusion in the marketplace,” Mesches said. “After months of failed attempts to resolve this issue amicably, we have been advised to take action to protect the Hopdoddy name that our loyal fans have loved since 2010.”

The consumer confusion comes, in part, because “defendants or their agents meticulously and extensively gathered on-site information at Hopdoddy in Austin, and took photographs and notes for purposes of re-creating Hopdoddy in Tulsa,” the suit claims.

The photos and notes were then allegedly used to “fabricate, print or otherwise re-create signature Hopdoddy trade dress, design elements or copyrighted materials, for purposes of utilizing same in its HopBunz restaurant,” according to the lawsuit. “Upon information and belief, defendants’ primary goal in forming HopBunz was to create a self-franchised facsimile of Hopdoddy.”

One example: The suit alleges parts of the Hopdoddy menu were “lifted wholesale,” pointing to a customer’s post on the HopBunz Facebook page that says, in part, “Do you also own Hopdoddys? I love that place. Thank you for bringing it here and not changing the menu!!”

In its filing, Hopdoddy asks the court to block HopBunz from using “confusingly similar” marketing materials. The restaurant is also seeking statutory damages and reimbursement for attorneys’ fees, among other things.

A trial date hasn’t been set.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

Austin alcohol sales soar 12 percent in April
Austin alcohol sales soar 12 percent in April

Alcohol sales at Austin bars, restaurants and hotels soared 12 percent in April, according to an American-Statesman analysis of state data. Bartenders citywide poured $74 million worth of beer, wine and mixed drinks, up from $66.2 million in 2017. Across Texas, April bar tabs totaled $623.6 million, also a 12 percent year-over-year increase. The top-selling...
Business Digest: Downtown Austin apartment tower on market

REAL ESTATE Downtown Austin apartment tower on market Northshore, a 38-story apartment tower at 110 San Antonio St. in downtown Austin, is up for sale. CBRE, a commercial real estate services firm, confirmed it is marketing the property. High Street Residential, a subsidiary of Dallas-based Trammell Crow, and Houston-based Hanover Co., completed the...
AMC Theatres announces $20-a-month rival to MoviePass
AMC Theatres announces $20-a-month rival to MoviePass

AMC Theatres, the world's largest movie theater chain, has unveiled a $20-a-month subscription service to rival the fledgling MoviePass. The theater chain on Wednesday announced a new service to its loyalty program, AMC Stubs, allowing subscribers to see up to three movies a week for a monthly fee of $19.95. That's more expensive than the $9.95 monthly...
Wanted: Buyer for downtown Austin apartment tower
Wanted: Buyer for downtown Austin apartment tower

Northshore, a 38-story apartment tower in downtown Austin overlooking Lady Bird Lake, is up for sale. CBRE, a commercial real estate services firm, confirmed it is marketing the property. High Street Residential, a subsidiary of Dallas-based Trammell Crow, and Houston-based Hanover Co., completed the tiered tower in 2016. According to the publication...
Discount carrier adding flights from Austin to Amarillo
Discount carrier adding flights from Austin to Amarillo

Another week brings another new nonstop flight to Austin’s airport. Discount carrier ViaAir said Tuesday it will fly from Austin-Bergstrom International Airport to Amarillo beginning Sept. 19. The service will run six days a week, Sunday through Friday, operating out of the South Terminal. “Both Austin and Amarillo are amazing cities and...
More Stories