Buc-ee’s tells Bucky’s: Texas isn’t big enough for both of us, and our giant stores were here first 


Highlights

Within the next year, Bucky’s reportedly plans to open six Texas locations, Buc-ee’s says.

Central Texas Buc-ee’s locations include Bastrop, Giddings, New Braunfels and Temple.

Welcome to Texas. Now, get the heck out.

That’s not quite what Lake Jackson-based Buc-ee’s is saying to a similarly named competitor, but it’s pretty darn close.

In a lawsuit filed this week in U.S. District Court, Buc-ee’s accuses Omaha, Neb.-based Bucky’s of trademark infringement, unfair competition and unjust enrichment, claiming the Bucky’s name is “confusingly similar” to the Buc-ee’s name that’s been around these parts for more than three decades.

Both businesses operate gas stations and convenience stores. There are more than 30 Buc-ee’s stores – known for their squeaky clean restrooms and cheeky billboards featuring a grinning beaver – in Texas, including Central Texas locations in Bastrop, Giddings, New Braunfels and Temple.

Bucky’s hasn’t set up shop in Texas just yet, the suit says, but it’s about to – and that has Buc-ee’s worried. The court filing indicates Bucky’s has acquired land in Houston and Nassau Bay and has worked to obtain liquor licenses from the state and necessary zoning changes.

Within the next year, Bucky’s plans to open six Texas locations, Buc-ee’s says in its court filings.

Bucky’s, which currently has about 80 locations in the Midwest, didn’t respond to a message from the American-Statesman seeking comment.

“Bucky’s actions have and will continue to result in direct, substantial overlap with Buc-ee’s current customer base… as well as overlap between the parties’ channels of trade,” the suit says. “Bucky’s activities and use of the term ‘Bucky’s’ is causing actual confusion in at least Texas … and is creating a strong likelihood of confusion between Bucky’s and Buc-ee’s.”

Due to its similar name, Buc-ee’s contends that Bucky’s would “receive the benefit of the goodwill built up at the great labor and expense by Buc-ee’s.” Use of the Bucky’s name is also “likely to dilute the famous, distinctive quality of the Buc-ee’s trademark,” according to the suit.

“Bucky’s unauthorized activities are likely to weaken or otherwise jeopardize Buc-ee’s highly valuable rights,” the suit says. “Bucky’s use of a mark similar to the Buc-ee’s trademark has caused and, unless enjoined, will continue to cause substantial and irreparable injury to Buc-ee’s for which Buc-ee’s has no adequate remedy at law.”

Claiming there is a “substantial likelihood that Buc-ee’s will prevail on its claims against Bucky’s,” Buc-ee’s is asking a judge to issue an injunction that would prevent Bucky’s from operating in Texas under that name.

“Bucky’s unjust enrichment at Buc-ee’s expense has been intentional,” the suit claims.

Buc-ee’s is also requesting a jury trial where it is seeking “an award of Bucky’s profits, Buc-ee’s actual damages, enhanced damages, exemplary damages, costs, pre-judgment and post-judgment interest and reasonable attorney fees.”

A trial date has not been set.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Business

Wanted: Buyer for downtown Austin apartment tower
Wanted: Buyer for downtown Austin apartment tower

Northshore, a 38-story apartment tower in downtown Austin overlooking Lady Bird Lake, is is up for sale. CBRE, a commercial real estate services firm, confirmed it is marketing the property. High Street Residential, a subsidiary of Dallas-based Trammell Crow, and Houston-based Hanover Co., completed the tiered tower in 2016. According to the publication...
Discount carrier adding flights from Austin to Amarillo
Discount carrier adding flights from Austin to Amarillo

Another week brings another new nonstop flight to Austin’s airport. Discount carrier ViaAir said Tuesday it will fly from Austin-Bergstrom International Airport to Amarillo beginning Sept. 19. The service will run six days a week, Sunday through Friday, operating out of the South Terminal. “Both Austin and Amarillo are amazing cities and...
Menswear startup Taylrd opens Domain pop-up shop
Menswear startup Taylrd opens Domain pop-up shop

Looking stylish doesn’t have to cost you a fortune. That’s one of the guiding philosophies behind Taylrd, a startup that sells menswear online at taylrdclothing.com and at a pop-up shop at the Domain in North Austin. Tom Dwyer founded the company about a year ago, offering an assortment of dress shirts, chinos, underwear and, now, swimsuits...
Founder of Austin-based Bumble says she received threats after banning gun photos from app
Founder of Austin-based Bumble says she received threats after banning gun photos from app

Three months after announcing the decision to ban images of guns on the dating and networking app she created, Bumble founder Whitney Wolfe Herd said she and her employees have received multiple threats relating to the decision. According to Page Six, Herd told a crowd at Cannes Lions that the “polarizing” decision led the Austin-based...
Downtown Austin office building makes debut after $11 million remodel
Downtown Austin office building makes debut after $11 million remodel

An 18-month-long project to modernize a nearly 70-year-old downtown Austin office building has wrapped up. The former Texas State Teachers Association headquarters, at 316 W. 12th St., is now known as Westview following the $11 million makeover and expansion by its owner, the Prescott Group, a Dallas-based firm. Texas State Teachers Association sold...
More Stories