Why Scherzer's ring finger fracture could help in the long run


When Max Scherzer decided not to play in the World Baseball Classic because of what he and the team called a "stress fracture in his right ring finger," something seemed odd. Scherzer is not one to be derailed by minor impediments such as a sore knuckle. Plus, he did not pitch like an injured man down the stretch of what became a Cy Young Award-winning season.

But official word from Scherzer and unofficial word from those familiar with the situation is that Scherzer did, indeed, feel the trouble midway through last season. As he said in the statement he released on Twitter, the trouble did not affect his pitching, so Scherzer continued to pitch. It did not go away, so he decided not to pitch for Team USA in the World Baseball Classic, which might turn out well for the Nationals.

The WBC felt like a dangerous endeavor for Scherzer, who treasures big moments. Determination such as his is exactly what a team should want in an ace, but it is also the result of an unrelenting competitive spirit. If Scherzer found himself in a win-or-go-home game in an international competition, he would be unlikely to dial himself down with an eye toward the major league season.

"I've seen different games and videos where the fans are going crazy, especially for the Latin American countries," Scherzer said in December. "It seems like those fans are crazy out there. Seems like an environment that I want to pitch in."

But while Nationals General Manager Mike Rizzo has reiterated his support of Team USA and his willingness to let his players participate, he must feel some relief that Scherzer will not. No one has thrown more innings in the past five seasons than Scherzer. No Nationals starter is guaranteed more money over the next five seasons than Scherzer. No starter is more crucial to the health of his rotation -- and perhaps his entire roster -- than Scherzer. His decisions to commit to the WBC, then pull out, casts a spotlight on an unheralded part of Scherzer's value to the Nationals: health risk management.

Often, a player's ability to stay healthy depends on toughness, luck or circumstances beyond a player's control. But Scherzer, though tough and certainly lucky of late, also has a profound awareness of the difference between being hurt and being injured. Scherzer dealt with a jammed finger early in the 2015 season, and had to push a start back because of it. Otherwise, he has avoided schedule-altering trouble beside fatigue.

But Scherzer has not been perfectly healthy throughout those two seasons, because no baseball player stays perfectly healthy through eight months of work. Like many players, Scherzer generally does not admit he pitched with a nick here or a bruise there. But he is meticulous and dogged in self-assessment. At one point last season, for example, Scherzer noticed the process of throwing his change-up was taking a little more out of him than usual, and that he was feeling strain in places he did not usually feel it. He checked the video, identified the problem, and worked to tweak his delivery with a near imperceptible shift in his arm path.

Scherzer has said he can often pitch through a nick here and there without concern of greater injury because he is aware of ways in which he might compensate and able to adjust around them. That does not mean his mechanics are garrisoned against occasional devolution. But he does know how to tinker. He will not have to tinker through the WBC now, or wrestle with his own competitiveness and self-preservation instincts at the same time.

Instead, he will rehab his ring finger (whatever that entails) and expects to be fully ready for spring training. Instead of being tempted to call on his full arsenal in February, Scherzer can ramp up slowly, his preferred approach to spring training. Instead of having to be cautious in navigating those high-energy environments that drew him to the WBC, Scherzer will begin his year with a similarly exciting bout of live batting practice or two.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

Denver Broncos coach Vance Joseph denies potential QB controversy
Denver Broncos coach Vance Joseph denies potential QB controversy

After opening the season with two excellent performances, Denver Broncos quarterback Trevor Siemian has had three-straight subpar outings. In fact, his play his been so poor that some media outlets are suggesting the Broncos should give their backup, Brock Osweiler, a chance with to work with the first-team offense. On Wednesday...
Tennessee QB Jarrett Guarantano breaks down first collegiate start
Tennessee QB Jarrett Guarantano breaks down first collegiate start

After three days to digest his first collegiate start, which ended in a troubling 15-9 loss to South Carolina, Jarrett Guarantano saw a lot to be gained from the performance. “I think it was a very good learning experience,” Guarantano said Wednesday evening on Vol Calls. “I think there’s a lot of things...
Johnathan Gray, Tommy Jeter both going into Texas High School Football Hall of Fame
Johnathan Gray, Tommy Jeter both going into Texas High School Football Hall of Fame

Two Longhorns, one of the most prolific high school running backs ever along with one of the toughest, are both going into the Texas High School Football Hall of Fame. Running back Johnathan Gray and defensive end Tommy Jeter were both selected as part of the Class of 2018 by a statewide committee made up of sportswriters, high...
Jim Mora on UCLA’s sieve-like defense: ‘It rips my guts out’
Jim Mora on UCLA’s sieve-like defense: ‘It rips my guts out’

We’re not trying to harp on it, but Jim Mora keeps talking about it, and for good reason. After a frustrating loss to Arizona, UCLA has perhaps as little momentum as any 3-3 team in college football history. Most of that blame belongs to the Bruins’ defense. The Bruins are 129th in the nation against the run. Even their high-powered...
Jay Cutler voted as QB most NFL players would not want as a teammate
Jay Cutler voted as QB most NFL players would not want as a teammate

The players of the NFL have spoken: Miami Dolphins signal caller Jay Cutler is the one quarterback they would not want as a teammate. ESPN’s NFL Nation conducted a poll this season where reporters asked 155 current NFL players questions about today’s NFL quarterbacks that ranged from who their favorite rookie is...
More Stories