College football teams are risky and expensive-and schools keep adding them


At many schools, the costs of football are starting to challenge the benefits. It's expensive, it doesn't always make money, many academic faculty resent it, and the ongoing debate over health risks and players' labor rights put universities in an awkward position.

Taken together, football could look like the kind of hassle a university president might try to avoid. Yet few do.

In the past eight years, 57 colleges and universities have started an NCAA football program. Alabama-Birmingham restored its team to the Football Bowl Subdivision. Another 11 joined the Football Championship Subdivision (formerly known as Division I-AA), and the rest are competing at lower levels-Divisions II or III.

For all but UAB, there's little money to be made from TV or ticket sales. In the past decade, annual football expenses at a typical FCS school have increased from less than $2 million to $3.5 million. In the same period, revenue has expanded from $430,000 to $1 million.

Middle-of-the-road FCS programs-a division that includes University of Maine, Colgate, Portland State-are losing millions on football altogether.

In spite of all this, East Tennessee State University still decided to add football in 2015. The team costs about $4 million to field, one-quarter of the overall department budget.

Encouraged by the school's president, students approved a $125 fee that would cover $2.8 million of the football team's costs.

"That was the only way we could do it," said Richard Sander, originally a consultant on the football revival and later hired as the school's athletic director. "It's much more than trying to create revenue, because it's not going to do it. There's no doubt about that."

ETSU, like most schools, sees advantages to football that may not show up on the balance sheet.

Football is thought to drive alumni donations and raise a school's profile beyond its immediate regional footprint, creating a better pool of prospective students. University officials also say it's a point of community pride and juices local businesses through such events as pep rallies and homecoming.

Of course, a focus on football isn't the only way to achieve those goals. According to the Council for Aid to Education, only three of the 10 schools that raised at least $500 million from alumni in 2015 have FBS football teams. The rest of the list is largely composed of academically excellent universities such as Harvard, Princeton, and Johns Hopkins.

The same is true of the schools with the highest rates of alumni giving. Only two -- Princeton University and Davidson College -- compete in NCAA Division I. The rest are smaller, top-flight liberal arts colleges such as Williams, Wellesley, and Carleton.

Other schools hitch their athletic wagon to another sport: men's basketball.

With smaller rosters and less equipment, it's cheaper to field and more competitive. The attention is also significant. Schools such as Gonzaga, Marquette, and Xavier owe their national reputations at least in part to the success of their basketball teams.

And insofar as anyone outside of Appalachia has heard of ETSU, it may be because of basketball. The Buccaneers regularly contend for a conference title and have gone to the NCAA tournament four times in the past 15 years.

ETSU has relied heavily on basketball. When Sander arrived in Johnson City, the Bucs were playing five or six "guarantee games" every year, getting paid for road games at basketball giants. That earned about $600,000 a year, but it also hobbled the team with a losing record early, turning off fans and demoralizing the athletes.

ETSU was damaging its most important sport just to support the others.

In the past eight years, 57 colleges and universities have started an NCAA football program. Football won't fully solve that problem. What it could do is take some of the pressure off basketball and raise overall morale around Buccaneers athletics.

"The university decided it was better for quality of life, better for branding, better for enrollment, and the expectation here in town is to have football," Sander said. "It's much more than trying to create revenue, because it's not going to do it. There's no doubt about that."

He's also clear that ETSU is entering into a precarious financial bargain with its new football program. The school had a football team for decades until, in 2003, it disbanded because the team was financially unsustainable.

An effort to bring it back in 2007 failed when students voted down a $50 fee increase to fund the program. All signs suggest that football is back to stay, but at what cost?

"Enrollment nationwide is trending down, so tuition gets raised, and that hits us by reducing student support and raising the cost of scholarships," Sander said.

"Throw in the rising cost of coaching salaries, health care, other things. Eventually you get to a point of, how can I survive? It makes me real nervous."


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Sports

How did 'average' skier Elizabeth Swaney make it to the 2018 Winter Olympics?
How did 'average' skier Elizabeth Swaney make it to the 2018 Winter Olympics?

One skier who competed in the women's halfpipe at the 2018 Winter Olympics really stood out – but not for her skills. American Elizabeth Swaney, a member of Hungary's team who finished in last place Monday after a qualifying run that Deadspin described as "thoroughly average," apparently was able to game the Olympics' quota system...
How a skier managed to compete at Olympics despite not being very good
How a skier managed to compete at Olympics despite not being very good

Elizabeth Swaney is not bad at skiing, not at all. But she is not very good, either, and certainly not Olympic-caliber in the halfpipe. So how, at age 33 no less, did she manage to make her way into the field at that event in the Winter Games? The answer, or at least how to frame it, lies in the eye of the beholder. Either Swaney is an embarrassment...
I didn't understand that Olympians were so small - and so vulnerable
I didn't understand that Olympians were so small - and so vulnerable

The first thing I noticed about ice dancer Madison Chock was that she was so much smaller in person. Most on-ice athletes are. The skates normally provide a boost. But standing next to a railing that separated her from a horde of reporters, she looked downright tiny. Most of the Olympians are smaller than you think. Absent the gear and the distance...
10 simple steps to help Dolphins this offseason
10 simple steps to help Dolphins this offseason

Well, it’s that time of year when, once again, I fearlessly state what the Dolphins do to win the offseason.   There’s just one problem: I don’t feel so fearless with answers this February.   I don’t even know the question this time. Is this regime trying to save jobs, and make the playoffs, which is possible...
Bubba Wallace delivers raw star power for NASCAR’s future
Bubba Wallace delivers raw star power for NASCAR’s future

Sports entities like NASCAR can market anyone to be the next “Rising Phenom.” It’s all in the packaging, the come-hither emails and advertising blitz.  Darrell “Bubba” Wallace doesn’t need any of that stuff. It slows him down, and he has places to go. Bubba Wallace is going to be a star.   Wallace...
More Stories