With final Senate OK, transgender bathroom bill heads to Texas House


Highlights

After final Senate approval, transgender bathroom bill heads to uncertain reception in the Texas House.

Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick says his House counterpart is out of touch with voters on the issue.

After a second day of sharp disagreement and impassioned debate, the Texas Senate gave final approval to the transgender bathroom bill Wednesday, drawing condemnation and praise from across the nation as Senate Bill 6 next heads to the House.

Attention now focuses on House Speaker Joe Straus, who has said he is no fan of SB 6 — a detail that was on Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick’s mind hours before Wednesday’s vote.

In a morning radio interview, Patrick — the bill’s leading advocate — suggested that fellow Republican Straus was playing with political fire.

“I think the speaker is out of touch with the voters,” Patrick said on KLIF in Dallas. “This is an issue that people, supporters, constituents and voters want.”

Wednesday’s 21-10 final vote, identical to Tuesday’s initial vote, included support from all 20 Senate Republicans and one Democrat, state Sen. Eddie Lucio Jr. of Brownsville, who said: “I cast my vote from a place of faith and devotion.”

TEXAS POLITICS DELIVERED EVERY DAY: Sign up for our Texas Politics email

Like Patrick, opponents of SB 6 also turned their focus to the House, where Republicans hold a 95-55 advantage over Democrats but where conservative members of the GOP hold less sway.

Sarah Kate Ellis, president of GLAAD, a national LGBT advocacy group, said the Senate showed “complete disregard” for the state’s economy and the “well-being of the people they represent.”

“It is vital that SB 6 not become law and that the Texas House heed the call of fair-minded Texans, businesses, organizations, conferences and celebrities who have decried this hateful bill,” Ellis said.

RELATED: Mayors fear impact of transgender bathroom bill

Passions ran equally high during Wednesday’s Senate debate over legislation that would prohibit transgender people from using the bathroom that conforms with their gender identity in public schools and universities and in government buildings. SB 6 also would overturn city and county regulations requiring transgender-friendly bathrooms.

Her voice cracking at times, state Sen. Lois Kolkhorst, the bill’s author, said her family “has been through a lot from the so-called tolerant and anti-bullying” opponents of SB 6, which she defended as an attempt to strike a balance between privacy and compassion.

“I believe in my heart it’s an attempt to be as inclusive as we possibly can when we — men and women, but I speak from the women’s perspective — find ourselves in the most intimate situations,” said Kolkhorst, R-Brenham.

“And it’s not a transgender person that would violate that, but open policies allow people, sexual predators and other people, to abuse that moment,” she said.

RELATED: Artists, stars urge Texas leaders to reject transgender bathroom bill

State Sen. Kirk Watson, D-Austin, disputed GOP arguments that SB 6 was needed to protect the privacy and safety of women and children.

“The people who will be most affected by SB 6 are transgender Texans who are just trying to live their lives and be true to themselves. And this bill does discriminate against them. It harms one group of people under the false pretense of protecting the majority from some amorphous threat,” Watson said.

“We’re allowing fear to guide public policy and justifying discrimination … in the name of public safety,” he said.

State Sen. Sylvia Garcia, D-Houston, said nobody has been harmed “by this mythical, mysterious predator” in bathrooms.

“This is, in my view, legislative bullying,” she said.

But state Sen. Donna Campbell, R-New Braunfels, insisted that SB 6 was narrowly crafted to “protect the privacy of all Texans.”

“I think for anyone to suggest this is at all political is disingenuous,” Campbell said. “This bill gives protection, dignity, safety. It provides liberty. It provides reasonable access to those who need it.”

RELATED: Religious leaders enter both sides of fight over transgender bathrooms

Also Wednesday, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton — joined by seven states, a religious hospital network and Christian medical associations — asked a federal judge to issue a final judgment overturning an Obama administration regulation designed to protect the health care decisions of transgender people by prohibiting discrimination based on “gender identity.”

U.S. District Judge Reed O’Connor of Fort Worth had issued a preliminary injunction in December that blocked enforcement of the rule nationally.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Williamson residents speak for, against removing Confederate statue
Williamson residents speak for, against removing Confederate statue

GEORGETOWN — Several Williamson County residents asked the county commissioners Tuesday morning to move a statue of a Confederate soldier off the courthouse lawn, saying it was intimidating and represented slavery. A few asked the commissioners to keep the statue in place. The commissioners took no action Tuesday after hearing the comments. The...
Austin nonprofit Care Communities to close its doors
Austin nonprofit Care Communities to close its doors

In a move that surprised some volunteers and stakeholders, Austin’s Care Communities announced that, because of financial challenges, it will stop providing free support for those living with HIV or cancer in Central Texas. The midsize nonprofit, which operated with an annual budget of almost $600,000, according to GuideStar.org, sent out a message...
5 Austin drinks you’ll want to snap before you sip
5 Austin drinks you’ll want to snap before you sip

Do you know where your next Instagram post is? If you’re thirsty, and your social media presence is looking dry, you can kill two birds with one beautifully crafted beverage.  These are five summer drinks that look as good as they probably taste, but I can’t say for sure because I have never tried any of them. Swirly. The Love...
Community news: Turn parking spots into small parks for a day

TRAVIS COUNTY AUSTIN Turn parking spots into parks Austin residents are encouraged to apply to organize an event for Park(ing) Day to generate public engagement and critical dialogue on the need for public, open spaces in urban areas. The event is held worldwide Sept. 15 and is intended to reclaim, reimagine and reinvent parking spaces as temporary...
DOCUMENT: Greg Kelley stopped lawyers from investigating other suspect
DOCUMENT: Greg Kelley stopped lawyers from investigating other suspect

A defense attorney who helped represent Greg Kelley wrote in an email that Kelley refused to participate in any investigation of a friend who is now considered a suspect in a child sexual assault — newly disclosed information that could mark the latest rapid turn in the case. A new court filing, obtained by the American-Statesman and KVUE-TV...
More Stories