Why drop in water use could cost Austin customers more


Austin officials say residents have done such a good job conserving water that the city faces a conundrum: People aren’t buying enough water to keep the delivery system in the black.

The Austin Water Utility took a $10 million hit in water sales for the first few months of this fiscal year, on top of the $27 million loss it logged last year. Correcting that shortfall could require new, higher “drought rates” that raise more money even as people use less water, according to the city.

Utility executives told the American-Statesman they are discussing new rate structures that could be proposed this summer. One idea is rates that rise as the lakes that supply Austin’s water shrivel, a concept similar to one Dallas has adopted. Asked whether the rate increase would be double-digits, water utility director Greg Meszaros didn’t rule the possibility out. To balance its books, the water utility also may deepen internal cuts.

In a sense, Austin has been a victim of its own success: Austinites have been reducing their water consumption … which means the city has collected less money from them … which is leading city officials to conclude rates must rise to bring in the money necessary to fund the 80 percent of costs that utility executives say are “fixed,” such as debt payments and some equipment maintenance.

“For a customer it can be counterintuitive” that water conservation causes higher rates, Meszaros said. “But as we reduce water demand we reduce revenue, and a lot of the costs of our operation cannot be cut. We’re just not built to absorb $27 million in losses year after year.”

This situation may sound vaguely familiar — after all, Austin has been steadily raising rates for more than a decade to pay off major investments, such as a $400 million, federally mandated upgrade of the sewer system. It is not unique to Austin, either; cities across Texas have also raised rates substantially as the drought took hold.

Anyone who has looked at Lake Travis lately saw a powerful argument for conservation. Lakes Travis and Buchanan, which are the main water supplies for Central Texas, are only about 38 percent full. That is approaching the all-time low of 30 percent, with summer yet to come. Nearly every water official says the region is in a crisis.

Largely because of conservation efforts, Austin homes and businesses have used less water each year since 2006, despite population growth and hard droughts. Utility officials say the main reason is the once-a-week watering restriction, which Meszaros said will probably not be lifted for years. Utility officials also credit public education, giveaways of low-flow toilets, rebate programs and the current rate structure, which includes progressive “tiered” rates intended to discourage profligate water use.

In the 2006 fiscal year, per-person water use in Austin averaged 190 gallons a day; in the 2013 fiscal year, daily use had dropped to 136 gallons per capita. A more sophisticated analysis, which uses a five-year average to smooth out unusually wet and dry years, shows a similar trend. Likewise, the total amount of water pumped by the water utility peaked in 2007.

Even the summer scorchers of recent years haven’t changed the basic picture.

“It used to be that in dry years, water utility revenues would go up, and in wet years it would go down. It’s still down in wet years, but now it also is down in dry years,” said Daryl Slusher, an assistant director of the water utility who oversees its conservation efforts.

The revenue shortfall is happening despite rates that have more than doubled over the past 12 years. And it is happening despite one of Austin’s worst-kept secrets: Some houses are watering during days on which watering is not allowed — and producing revenue the city would not be collecting were it enforcing its conservation rules more vigorously.

Fiscal conservatives question whether the utility should cut rebates and other programs that kneecap revenues. Environmental activists say the city should not have added nearly a billion dollars worth of debt, to be paid back over 30 years, for a water-treatment plant now under construction, particularly at a time when citywide use is declining.

For years the city had also given developers steep discounts on water-and-wastewater hookup fees, a practice the City Council recently concluded should be curtailed because it pushed water-utility costs onto everyone else.

Even Mayor Lee Leffingwell recently alluded to nonvital expenses while trying to persuade his City Council colleagues to be more cognizant of the city’s bottom line. Leffingwell noted that a few years ago, the council decided to use Austin Water Utility revenue to maintain the Balcones Canyonlands Preserve, a high-profile nature conservation effort, “because that’s where the money was.”

To deal with the expected budget crunch, the water utility has begun cutting. Its plans include: reducing conservation advertising; hiring fewer consultants to help fashion conservation strategies; signing fewer contracts, such as those for leak detection and assessment of the utility’s water distribution system; creating less-generous rebate programs; and deferring maintenance of pumps and other equipment. But utility executives expect those cuts to yield only about $4.5 million in savings.

Last year, the utility dealt with the $27 million shortfall partly by refinancing some of its outstanding debt, which saved about $5 million, said David Anders, an assistant director who oversees the utility’s finances. The rest of the shortfall was covered by borrowing money to finance some construction projects, instead of paying for them with cash. Meszaros, the utility director, said it may do an even more pronounced shift from cash to borrowing in the coming years, which would save money in the short term but adds interest payments.

Meszaros added that the utility is looking to save more money by delaying more construction and maintenance projects.

“When we’re in a cash crunch, that’s one of the big knobs we can turn,” Meszaros said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Southbound I-35 lanes reopening in North Austin after wreck; delays extend to Round Rock
Southbound I-35 lanes reopening in North Austin after wreck; delays extend to Round Rock

7:30 a.m. update: The southbound lanes of Interstate 35 near Wells Branch Parkway in North Austin has been reopened for traffic after a wreck caused delays that have extended north to FM 1431 past Round Rock in Williamson County. 7:05 a.m. update: The southbound lanes of Interstate 35 just north of Wells Branch Parkway in North Austin is shut down...
FORECAST: 20% chance of rain Friday; weekend temps to reach low 70s
FORECAST: 20% chance of rain Friday; weekend temps to reach low 70s

Friday forecast for Austin: Austin has a 20 percent chance of seeing showers, according to the National Weather Service. The weather outlook calls for temperatures to reach near 49 degrees under mostly cloudy skies, and light south-southeast winds becoming south winds of 5 to 10 mph in the morning. At night, Austin’s expected to have the same...
New England, Jacksonville firms make whiskey wager for AFC title game
New England, Jacksonville firms make whiskey wager for AFC title game

The "whiskey wagers" are flying back and forth between distilleries in New England and Northeast Florida ahead of Sunday's AFC Championship game between the New England Patriots and the Jacksonville Jaguars. It began with Sons of Liberty Beer & Spirits Co. of South Kingstown, Rhode Island, challenging the St. Augustine Distillery Company ...
Iowa police charge 2 juveniles with destroying half-million bees
Iowa police charge 2 juveniles with destroying half-million bees

Iowa police arrested two juveniles Wednesday, charging them with alleged vandalism that destroyed more than a half-million bees at a Sioux City honey business last month, The Sioux City Journal reported. The minors, 12 and 13, were not identified by police. They were charged on three felony counts -- criminal mischief in the first degree...
Driver runs onto freeway to avoid car crashing into tow truck
Driver runs onto freeway to avoid car crashing into tow truck

A Michigan tow truck driver working to load a crashed vehicle was nearly hit by another car that lost control in slick conditions. On Wednesday morning at 10:30, the tow truck driver was working to load a vehicle that had been involved in a crash onto a truck.  A Michigan State Police officer was behind the tow truck, and on cruiser cam,...
More Stories