Wear: Trump infrastructure dollars won’t stretch very far


What we do know of the now $1.7 trillion plan indicates it’s not all it’s hyped up to be.

The federal spending would be $200 billion over a decade, less than a quarter of the Obama stimulus plan.

And it depends on 80 percent of spending coming from local or state governments or the private sector.

The Donald J. Trump Infrastructure Plan — he would like the capital letters, I suspect — somehow experienced a $700 billion growth spurt this past week.

Which would be impressive if the Plan were even a thing. After a year and a half of sporadic hype and promises of its impending birth, what the president now pegs at $1.7 trillion for many unspecific (but wonderful and badly needed) projects remains publicly only a six-page collection of “funding principles.”

And that part is public only because political website Axios recently published a leaked version of it.

The White House later declined to vouch for that dense (if mercifully brief) document, but allowed as how the president “looks forward to presenting our plan in the near future.” Stop me if you’ve heard that before.

Trump later told reporters that he would be discussing the infrastructure plan in his State of the Union speech Tuesday — not at length, I would guess — and that a fleshed-out plan would be released shortly thereafter. We’ll see.

But what we do know about it indicates the plan will be far less than it has been cracked up to be.

Start with the number, either the $1 trillion that TrumpWorld had been floating since before his 2016 election, or the $1.7 trillion now suddenly out there. All along, the administration has said that the plan would involve $200 billion at most in actual federal spending, and even that would be spread over 10 years.

READ: The Trump infrastructure plan, 2016 version

The rest, we have been told, would come from local and state governments and the private sector. The federal money, in other words, would be leveraged — a favorite word of those looking to create a multiplier of what they’re actually pledging to spend. The “funding principles” document said any federal grant under the plan “can’t exceed 20 percent of total project cost.”

So, what it really boils down to is $20 billion a year in added federal spending. Or at least we think it is added federal spending. Perhaps it will only be money reallocated from some other corner of the federal budget, especially given that the tax bill Trump signed into law just before Christmas will add an estimated $1 trillion to the national debt over the next decade. And those principles (again, from a leaked document of uncertain provenance and legitimacy) also include “disposition of federal real property” to raise some of the money.

Which property? Old warehouses? Military bases? Big Bend National Park? Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s parking spot at the Supreme Court building? The document doesn’t say.

So how much is $20 billion, in the scheme of things? The 2017-18 federal budget is $4.1 trillion, putting this added money for infrastructure at about half of 1 percent.

The federal highway trust fund, which distributes money for road, bridge and transit projects to the states (raised originally in states through gas and diesel taxes, mainly), will hand out $54 billion this year. So $20 billion on top of that would be pretty salty, right?

RELATED: The Texas Legislature, tolls and the Trump plan

Except that the Trump plan money (again, based on the principles document) would go not only to roads and transit, but also to airports, ports, inland waterways, flood control, water supply, drinking water facilities, hydropower, stormwater facilities and the cleanup of polluted lands. We have no idea at this point (or likely for quite some time) how much of that would go to each of those categories. Suffice it to say, transportation would almost certainly get only a small fraction of that $20 billion a year.

So, how does the Trump Plan compare in size with former President Barack Obama’s 2009 stimulus plan, a juxtaposition Trump almost surely would relish?

The final tab on that legislation, introduced and passed within a month of Obama taking office, was about $830 billion over a several-year period. I notice that Trump’s flashy new number is almost exactly twice that Obama figure. Probably just a coincidence.

Anyway, transportation got about $50 billion of the Obama stimulus. More than half of the $830 billion total went to instant tax breaks of various kinds, health care, education and added unemployment benefits. Remember, we were in a deep recession at the time, and the point was to inject cash into the system as well as create jobs.

So the Obama economic stimulus, most of which was spent (or forgiven in the form of those tax breaks) within the first five years, was four times larger than the Trump plan in terms of actual federal outlay. Remember, Trump, in saying $1 trillion or $1.7 trillion, to a great degree is rhetorically spending other people’s money.

COMMENTARY: Why Trump’s infrastructure plan is a hard sell for Texas

So, summing up, what we have here is a long-delayed and still-unreleased plan, of uncertain size, paid for mostly by entities other than Uncle Sam, going to an array of projects of totally unknown size and character. And, oh yeah, this would all have to be passed by a Congress riven by partisan discord, consumed by such long-unresolved issues as immigration and health care, and eager to knock off work by Aug. 1 so the members can go plead with voters to return them to office.

Oh, and that Robert Mueller investigation. That too.

And even if it were to become some sort of reality, the plan depends to a great degree on mixing government money with private sector funding on profit-making ventures. Sort of like, I dunno, tolls? That might be a problem here in Texas, it appears.

As a transportation reporter, I would like to think that this long-anticipated infrastructure plan is going to be a big deal in my policy neck of the woods.

Right now, though, it’s not any sort of deal.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

NC woman wins $1 million scratch-off jackpot
NC woman wins $1 million scratch-off jackpot

Winner, winner, before that chicken dinner. A North Carolina woman is $1 million richer after buying a scratch-off ticket while purchasing her meal, WRAL reported. Sayanna Bragg bought a dozen chicken wings and a soft drink at a Durham convenience store and decided to purchase a Million Dollar Fever scratch-off ticket.  When she got to her...
Georgia dad, daughter sing their way to more Girl Scout cookie sales
Georgia dad, daughter sing their way to more Girl Scout cookie sales

Who knew Childish Gambino’s “Redbone” would make good Girl Scout cookie-selling music? A father and daughter team from Georgia created a viral video in which they ride in the car while subbing out the song’s original lyrics to push Girl Scout cookies. The song is performed by Grammy-winning Georgia artist Childish Gambino...
Lawsuit accuses Taylor facility of forcing immigrant detainees to work for little or no pay
Lawsuit accuses Taylor facility of forcing immigrant detainees to work for little or no pay

A class action lawsuit filed in federal court Thursday argues that a company that manages immigrant detention centers — including the T. Don Hutto Center in Taylor — is violating the federal Trafficking Victims and Protection Act by forcing labor on those in the center. Martha Gonzalez — a Harris County resident who was formerly detained...
Abbott spares death row inmate’s life, heeding father’s plea
Abbott spares death row inmate’s life, heeding father’s plea

Gov. Greg Abbott agreed Thursday evening to spare the life of death row inmate Thomas Whitaker, announcing his decision less than an hour before the Houston-area man’s scheduled execution. Abbott said a number of factors distinguished Whitaker’s case from 30 other executions that had taken place under his watch as governor, including the...
Teen charged with making threats, prompts Akins High lockdown
Teen charged with making threats, prompts Akins High lockdown

A 17-year-old former student was arrested after he “threatened to shoot and blow up” Akins High School on Thursday, the Austin school district police chief said. The teen, who up until two weeks ago had been a student, made threats in person at the school and on a school bus, interim Chief Chris Evoy said. Police seized a magazine and ammunition...
More Stories