Texas returns to court to defend abortion regulations


Highlights

Texas will defend law prohibiting “dismemberment abortions,” known medically as dilation and evacuation.

Abortion providers argue the law bans the safest and most common procedure for second-trimester procedures.

For the fifth time since 2013, lawyers for Texas will defend an abortion-related law or regulation Tuesday in the Austin federal courthouse, where they hope to reverse a string of legal defeats that included a precedent-setting decision by the U.S. Supreme Court.

The latest lawsuit seeks to block a law, passed by the Legislature in May and signed by Gov. Greg Abbott, that bans “dismemberment abortions,” a term not used in medical literature or by doctors but which targets a procedure known as dilation and evacuation, commonly called D&E abortions.

Abortion providers argue that the law bans the safest and most commonly used procedure for second-trimester procedures, placing an unconstitutional limit on access to abortion that would force women into unnecessary medical procedures at a higher risk and with additional pain and expense.

Lawyers for Attorney General Ken Paxton will ask U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel to let the law take effect, as scheduled, on Friday, arguing that the state has a legitimate interest in outlawing a “brutal, gruesome and inhumane practice.”

They also say the abortion providers that sued, including Whole Woman’s Health and Planned Parenthood, are not entitled to emergency relief because they waited six weeks before filing the suit on July 20, leading to a rushed appearance before the judge days before the law takes effect.

Each side will have 90 minutes to present its arguments during Tuesday’s hearing, with no witnesses. All expert testimony was submitted to the court in writing.

Yeakel can rule from the bench afterward or take the matter under advisement for a decision that would be expected before Friday.

Seven other states have adopted similar measures, with courts halting enforcement in five of them: Alabama, Arkansas, Kansas, Louisiana and Oklahoma. Laws in Mississippi and West Virginia were not challenged because providers there do not offer the restricted type of abortions, according to the Center for Reproductive Rights, a legal advocacy group whose lawyers will argue against the Texas law in Austin.

Under the Texas law, physicians can perform D&E abortions if they first take steps to ensure “fetal demise” — a provision added because the procedure “involves the limb-by-limb destruction of a living unborn child, and our society has long recognized dismemberment of living beings as particularly cruel,” Paxton told the judge in a legal brief.

A substantial body of medical literature, Paxton said, suggests that doctors have three safe and effective methods of ensuring fetal demise.

“Prohibiting this inhumane procedure does not impose any significant health risks or burdens on women,” he said.

Abortion providers disputed Paxton, telling Yeakel that most D&E abortions are performed after 15 weeks of pregnancy, but the three methods have not been tested on fetuses younger than 18 weeks, carry increased health risks for women and are not guaranteed to be effective.

“There is no safe, studied or medically appropriate way for (abortion doctors) to attempt to cause fetal demise. Attempting to do so would impose risks with no medical benefit to the patient, and is untested, has unknown risks and is of uncertain efficacy,” lawyers for the abortion providers wrote.

“There is no fail-safe way to ensure fetal demise before every D&E procedure, and therefore no clear way for physicians to begin any D&E procedure without fear of criminal prosecution,” they added.

The limit on D&E abortions was included in Senate Bill 8, a sweeping measure passed during the Legislature’s regular session that also requires fetal tissue to be buried or cremated, prohibits the use of fetal tissue from abortions in medical research and creates state crimes for two practices already prohibited by federal law: selling fetal body parts and performing “partial-birth” abortions.

Those regulations also take effect Sept. 1, although a federal judge in January blocked Texas from enforcing a similar fetal-burial rule that state health officials had adopted last year. Paxton has appealed that ruling.

In addition, during the special session that ended two weeks ago, the Legislature banned general insurance plans from covering abortions and required stricter reporting for abortion-related medical complications.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Donning red shoes to help nonprofit
Donning red shoes to help nonprofit

Guests of the Ronald McDonald House Charities Central Texas’ Red Shoe Luncheon raised $85,000 on Tuesday to support its programs. About 275 women, and a few men, donned red shoes from sandals to cowboy boots at the third annual event at Brazos Hall to support the nonprofit group, which provides compassionate care and resources to children and...
Austin ISD is banking on bond to boost enrollment, turn around schools
Austin ISD is banking on bond to boost enrollment, turn around schools

Natural lighting, movable furniture, state-of-the art technology, and open and collaborative learning spaces. That kind of learning environment is what Austin district leaders envision for their campuses of the future. The average Austin school building is 40 years old. Many of the classroom spaces still resemble industrial-era classrooms with their...
Answers to your questions about graffiti abatement in Austin

Austin’s Graffiti Park at Castle Hill is officially the city’s only open canvas for spray painters to express themselves. But when graffiti pops up in neighborhoods and on private property, it’s considered vandalism. Questions often arise about how to handle graffiti, so here are some of the answers we’ve found: What counts...
AISD LAND FOR SALE: Alamo Drafthouse eyes former school site for HQ
AISD LAND FOR SALE: Alamo Drafthouse eyes former school site for HQ

Alamo Drafthouse Cinema is seeking to move its headquarters to the Baker Center, one of 40 bids and proposals for 10 of the Austin school district’s surplus properties that remain in negotiations. Baker, a former school built in 1911, had a minimum bid of $10.6 million. Alamo was among the six bidders, and one of three (including the city) that...
HAPPENING TODAY: UT stabbing suspect to appear in court
HAPPENING TODAY: UT stabbing suspect to appear in court

University of Texas stabbing suspect Kendrex White is scheduled to appear in court on Thursday afternoon to address matters in his murder case. Court documents do not give reason for the 1:30 p.m. hearing. A prosecutor who is working on the case declined comment Thursday. White, a 21-year-old biology student, is accused of killing 19-year-old Harrison...
More Stories