Texas can keep using voter ID law for now, appeals court says


Federal appeals court temporarily blocks ruling that voided the voter ID law as discriminatory.

Delay will let Texas appeal the ruling, avoid confusion for voters and election officials, court says.

A federal appeals court will let Texas continue using its new voter ID law for elections in November, temporarily blocking a lower-court ruling that said changes adopted by the Legislature in May couldn’t fix a 2011 law that was drafted to intentionally discriminate against minority voters.

In a 2-1 ruling issued late Tuesday, the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said Texas can continue requiring voters to show a photo ID at the polls while state officials appeal last month’s ruling by U.S. District Judge Nelva Gonzales Ramos of Corpus Christi.

Ramos issued an injunction Aug. 23 that permanently barred Texas from enforcing its voter ID requirements, saying the Republican-drafted law violated the Voting Rights Act and the U.S. Constitution because it was “enacted with discriminatory intent — knowingly placing additional burdens on a disproportionate number of Hispanic and African-American voters,” who tend to support Democrats.

READ: Eyes on U.S. Supreme Court in Texas redistricting fight

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton responded by asking the 5th Circuit to block Ramos’ ruling while his lawyers work to try to overturn it on appeal.

In granting Paxton’s request, the divided appeals court panel said changes to the voter ID law appeared to solve any problems for voters.

Under Senate Bill 5, which Gov. Greg Abbott signed into law on June 1, registered voters without the required ID could still cast a ballot by showing a paycheck, utility bill or other document that lists a name and address and by signing a “declaration of reasonable impediment” stating why they couldn’t obtain photo identification.

The panel emphasized, however, that its order was made after an initial review of the arguments and wouldn’t be binding when the appeals court decides whether to overturn or support Ramos’ decision.

“A temporary stay will allow this court to hear oral arguments and rule on the merits while preserving the status quo,” Justices Jennifer Walker Elrod and Jerry Smith said, adding that a delay now “will minimize confusion among both voters and trained election officials.”

The court also set oral arguments for the week of Dec. 4.

The ruling means the Texas voter ID law, with the impediment declaration and loosened ID standards, will be in place for the Nov. 7 election on seven proposed amendments to the Texas Constitution, as well as elections planned by several school districts.

Writing in dissent, Justice James Graves Jr. said he wouldn’t have allowed Texas to continue using its voter ID law at this stage of the appeal.

In a similar case in 2016, Graves said, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals tossed out North Carolina’s voter ID law — even after it had been amended by lawmakers — because the underlying law was enacted with the intent to discriminate against minority voters, and “laws passed with discriminatory intent inflict a broader injury and cannot stand.”

“In light of the 4th Circuit’s decision,” Graves wrote, “I am unconvinced that the state is likely to succeed on the merits.”

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

Paxton said he was pleased that the state’s voter ID law will remain in effect for the upcoming elections.

“Safeguarding the integrity of our election process is essential to preserving our democracy, and the voter ID law provides simple protections to ensure our elections accurately reflect the will of voters in Texas,” he said.

The civil rights groups, Democratic politicians and minority voters who challenged the voter ID law have several options. They could ask all 14 judges on the 5th Circuit to review Tuesday’s ruling, ask the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn it or choose to proceed to the oral arguments. They also could ask the full court to weigh the appeal instead of a typical three-judge panel.

Chad Dunn, a lawyer for some of those plaintiffs, said he and other lawyers are still considering their options and expect to decide in about a week.

“We’ve expected all along that the full 5th Circuit, and ultimately the Supreme Court, will have to weigh in on this case, and nothing has changed,” he said.

In the meantime, the 5th Circuit’s ruling stopped all proceedings before Ramos, who was beginning work on the final question in the case — whether she should require Texas to seek federal approval for changes to its election laws after finding that the voter ID law was intended to discriminate against minority voters.

That inquiry was still in its early stages, having been delayed in part by Hurricane Harvey.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Police: Man injured after shooting in East Austin
Police: Man injured after shooting in East Austin

Austin-Travis County EMS took a man in his 30s to the hospital after a shooting in East Austin, officials said Saturday. Austin Police responded at about 2 p.m. to the 8400 block of Garcreek Circle, Lt. Brian Moon said. Moon said the incident began as a disturbance and escalated. Medics took the man to Dell Seton Medical Center with a gunshot wound...
South Austin house fire kills pets, does $100,000 structural damage
South Austin house fire kills pets, does $100,000 structural damage

A fire that sparked after 3 a.m. Saturday did $100,000 in structural damage to a South Austin home and killed a dog and a cat, though the resident got out safely, Austin Fire reported. Flames were heavy in the front of the house in the 5800 block of South First Street, near Ben White Blvd., when firefighters arrived. Red Cross is assisting the resident...
New mural at 12th and Chicon unveiled
New mural at 12th and Chicon unveiled

Ten months after Chris Rogers’ mural at 12th and Chicon streets was painted over, sparking outrage from the community over what many saw as an act of gentrification, he will be back Saturday to present his new work at the same spot. In response to the controversy last summer, Austin’s black cultural district, Six Square, reached...
Australian priest reacts to Parkland shooting with swipe at US on church marquee 
Australian priest reacts to Parkland shooting with swipe at US on church marquee 

A rector at a church in Australia sent a pointed message to the United States this week in the wake of the shooting deaths at a high school in Parkland, Florida, on Feb. 14, The Washington Post reported. On the marquee outside the Gosford Anglican Church, the Rev. Rod Bower posted the message, “When will they love their kids more than their...
UPDATE: Two injured in auto-bicyclist crash in northwest Austin
UPDATE: Two injured in auto-bicyclist crash in northwest Austin

10 a.m. update: Two people have been taken to a local hospital, one with life-threatening injuries, after a vehicle and bike crash in northwest Austin, EMS officials said. Austin-Travis County EMS took a man in his 50s with life-threatening injuries and a woman in her 20s with non-life threatening injuries to Round Rock Medical Center. Officials advise...
More Stories