Testimony begins in challenge to Texas abortion law


A Texas law banning second-trimester abortions on living fetuses requires doctors to use untested, complicated and riskier procedures that have no medical benefit to the woman, an Oregon doctor who teaches and performs abortion testified Thursday.

Kicking off a five-day federal court trial on a bid by abortion providers to overturn the law, Dr. Mark Nichols said the regulation would force physicians to choose from several methods of inducing “fetal demise” that carry increased risks of infection and injury before beginning the safest and most common type of procedure – dilation and evacuation, or D&E, beginning in the 15th week of pregnancy.

Two methods of injecting toxins into the fetus require special skills and equipment and are not guaranteed to work, forcing doctors to consider a second injection – which adds to the health risks for women – and placing physicians in danger of prosecution for violating the law, he said.

In addition, Nichols testified, the injection procedures are not commonly performed earlier than the 18th week of pregnancy, requiring doctors to essentially experiment on patients to meet the fetal demise requirement.

A third method, cutting the umbilical cord, is difficult to complete, particularly at younger gestational ages, Nichols said.

“I would be very nervous about being able to provide this service and not violate the law,” he said.

Darren McCarty with the Texas attorney general’s office challenged Nichols, noting that some Texas doctors prefer to induce fetal demise before a D&E abortion because they believe there are medical benefits.

McCarty also scoffed at claims that the differences between the 17th and 18th week of pregnancy would be great enough to increase risks.

But Nichols said the smaller size of the fetus, coupled with the larger amount of amniotic fluid, makes fetal demise procedures more difficult “the earlier you are in the pregnancy.”

The Texas law, approved by the Legislature in May and signed into law by Gov. Greg Abbott, was blocked from taking effect on Sept. 1, leading to a trial scheduled to end Wednesday before U.S. District Judge Lee Yeakel.

The trial broke for lunch with Nichols still on the stand.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Lakeway City Council discusses citizen engagement measures
Lakeway City Council discusses citizen engagement measures

A couple city council members want the city of Lakeway to up its efforts at engaging the community, and are proposing several measures to accomplish this. During the Nov. 20 council meeting, Councilwoman Jean Hennagin made a presentation for a Lakeway “engagement committee,” and put forward ideas brainstormed along with Councilman Keith...
Transgender Day of Remembrance held outside Austin City Hall
Transgender Day of Remembrance held outside Austin City Hall

The tone of the Transgender Day of Remembrance event held outside Austin City Hall on Monday evening was, as always, a bittersweet mix of hope and sadness as organizers and attendees proclaimed their pride to be transgender and mourned the loss of transgender individuals who were killed this year. For years, Austin has participated in the international...
EAST AUSTIN FIRE: Mobile home blaze in Bastrop Highway under control, officials say
EAST AUSTIN FIRE: Mobile home blaze in Bastrop Highway under control, officials say

A fire at a mobile home located in East Austin near U.S. 183 is now under control, Austin fire officials said Monday night.  The structure at the 500 block of Bastrop Highway was heavily involved when the fire was reported about 10 p.m., officials said. The mobile home was abandoned and no one was injured, officials said. 
U.S. 183, I-35 projects waver after Abbott, Patrick trash tolls
U.S. 183, I-35 projects waver after Abbott, Patrick trash tolls

Several key Central Texas highway projects — including expansions of U.S. 183 in North Austin, U.S. 290 in Southwest Austin and Interstate 35 through the heart of the area — are once again in limbo after Gov. Greg Abbott and Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick last week staked out firm anti-toll positions. “Right now there’s a billion dollars...
UPDATE: Fire at downtown Hilton hotel now out, fire officials say 
UPDATE: Fire at downtown Hilton hotel now out, fire officials say 

11:30 p.m. update: The Hilton Hotel in downtown Austin was partially evacuated Monday night after a dryer malfunction on the third floor, Austin fire officials said. Firefighters responded around 7:15 p.m., and all guests were allowed back in around 10 p.m. The fire was confined to a laundry room, but the fire is estimated to have caused $200...
More Stories