Why texting-while-driving ban may need super-majority in Senate


Highlights

A Senate committee Monday delayed voting on HB 62, a proposed statewide ban on texting while driving.

The bill’s Senate sponsor already has enough votes on Senate rules, but Patrick wants majority GOP support.

The legislation, which its sponsor has been trying to pass since 2009, easily passed the House in March.

The texting-while-driving ban, with its sponsor attempting to reach ever-moving legislative goalposts, has hit another hitch.

Sen. Judith Zaffirini, D-Laredo, the Senate sponsor of House Bill 62, asked Senate State Affairs Committee chairwoman Joan Huffman on Monday to put off a vote for at least another day. The reason: further demands for amendments from the Republican senators she needs to reach a goal of 25 votes.

That’s 25 votes in a 31-member Senate, or six more than is normally needed under Senate rules to bring a bill up for consideration.

“We’re still working on amendments,” Zaffirini said after the committee failed to act on her bill early Monday afternoon. “One vote at a time.”

Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, who as presiding officer of the Senate has the power to squelch consideration of any piece of legislation, reportedly has demanded more supportive senators before Zaffirini can bring up the bill on the Senate floor.

Patrick, who did not respond to a request for comment, is uncomfortable with the much-publicized bill passing the 31-member Senate with 11 Democratic votes (the entire roster of Senate Democrats) and just 10 Republican votes, lawmakers have said. Zaffirini has thus been put in the unusual position of rounding up even more GOP votes despite already having more than two-thirds of the Senate on board with HB 62.

Under normal circumstances, HB 62 would appear to have enough votes to pass the State Affairs Committee already. A similar bill passed the same committee 6-3 in mid-March at roughly the same time the House approved HB 62 on 114-32 vote.

The current delay in the measure turns on the words “or” and “and.” Zaffirini said some hold-out senators want a texting-while-driving citation to depend on a police officer spotting the offense and for it to occur simultaneously with another violation, such as reckless driving or running a traffic light.

Zaffirini said law enforcement officials have said that requiring both would make the potential law unenforceable and “gut the bill.” Zaffirini said she could live with the conjunction “or.”

Zaffirini has been trying to pass a texting-while-driving ban since the 2009 session, joined since 2011 by Rep. Tom Craddick, R-Midland, the sponsor of HB 62. Forty-six other states and 101 Texas cities having outlawed the practice in various forms. In Austin, the city ban prohibits talking on a hand-held phone as well, unlike the proposed state law.

The case for the bill was further bolstered in late March when 13 New Braunfels church members died in a head-on car accident near Uvalde, one caused at least in part by one of the drivers texting in the moments before the crash. And Zaffirini several weeks ago secured the 19 votes necessary under Senate rules to bring a bill up for debate and a vote in the 31-member Senate. Passage requires only a simple majority, and Zaffirini said Monday she now has 21 votes.

Huffman, in the hearing Monday morning, read a list of more than two dozen Texas companies and organizations that are in favor of HB 62, including several oil companies, police departments, medical groups representing doctors and hospitals, automobile manufacturers and Realtors.

“That is a substantial and impressive list,” said Huffman, who strongly supports the bill.

The bill on a statewide basis would ban typing or reading electronic messages (which includes texting, emails and apps like Twitter and Facebook) on a hand-held device by drivers in a moving vehicle, other than for emergencies and for global positioning systems. Zaffirini, in a substitute version of HB 62 introduced Monday, has now included accessing music apps as an allowed activity while driving, an attempt to lure more votes.

The bill has also been amended as it moved through the Legislature this session to make it clear that a violator, in a city where texting and driving is already banned by local ordinance, would not be hit with both a local and a state citation.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

Fifth UT-area Subway robbery reported in two months
Fifth UT-area Subway robbery reported in two months

An armed robbery occurred Tuesday night at a Subway fast food restaurant on San Antonio Street near West 24th Street, University of Texas police said. At 10 p.m., police said they were looking for the robber, who witnesses described as a man wearing baggy clothing, who might be in his mid-30s.  This is the the fifth Subway to be robbed in...
Manchaca vs. Menchaca: Step closer to renaming South Austin road
Manchaca vs. Menchaca: Step closer to renaming South Austin road

It’s always been a head-scratcher for outsiders — Austinites pronouncing Manchaca Road as “MAN-shack.” But after decades of confusion, will Austin finally get it right? After six years and more than $24,000 raised, retired Judge Bob Perkins certainly hopes so. Since 2011, he’s been a champion for Texas Revolutionary captain...
Mayor Adler’s State of City address covers taxes, CodeNext and Russia
Mayor Adler’s State of City address covers taxes, CodeNext and Russia

Austin Mayor Steve Adler delivered Tuesday a State of the City address that blamed the state for continual rises in property tax bills, touted the numerous amount of road projects ahead that will — hopefully — improve traffic and vowed to make Austin a global leader. In an address that checked in at about 42 minutes, Adler hit on many of...
Abbott picks former San Angelo mayor for transportation board
Abbott picks former San Angelo mayor for transportation board

The suddenly short-handed Texas Transportation Commission Tuesday gained a new member, business investor, rancher and former San Angelo Mayor Alvin New. New, a life-long West Texan who was born in Brownfield and has lived in or near San Angelo since 1981, will replace Tryon Lewis of Odessa. Lewis, who until September had been chairman of the five-member...
Abbott looks to address shootings, doesn’t mention changing gun laws
Abbott looks to address shootings, doesn’t mention changing gun laws

In the wake of the Florida school shooting that killed 14 students and three staff members, Gov. Greg Abbott called for ensuring Texas schools are safe, fixing the federal background check database and addressing mental health as a cause of some shootings. Asked whether changing gun laws should be considered, Abbott did not mention it as a solution...
More Stories