UT report: Wind, natural gas cheapest electricity if full cost tallied


Highlights

Researchers took environmental and public health impacts into account when calculating costs.

The UT Energy Institute’s online tools let policymakers, others fiddle with their calculations and assumptions.

Wind and natural gas are the lowest-cost options for new electrical generation across much of the nation when environmental and public health impacts are considered along with direct expenses such as fuel and transmission lines, according to a report being released Thursday by the University of Texas.

The white paper, coordinated by UT’s Energy Institute, examined electrical generation involving coal, solar and nuclear power in addition to wind and natural gas on a county-by-county basis in the 48 contiguous states.

“One of the surprising things is that with our full suite of restrictions and assumptions, the cheapest power plant in many counties is nuclear,” Carey King, a research scientist and assistant director of the institute, said in an interview. “That doesn’t tell you that nuclear is low cost,” just that it’s lower than the other technology options in those particular counties.

Wind was the cheapest option for new generation in 1,347 of 3,110 counties, including part of the nation’s midsection, from the Dakotas south into West Texas. Combined-cycle natural gas technology, which uses a gas-fired turbine as well as a steam-powered one, proved cheapest in 1,127 counties, encompassing much of East and Central Texas, including Travis County. Nuclear was cheapest in 398 counties.

Among the factors to which cost was assigned for environmental and public health impacts are air emissions of sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and carbon dioxide, King said. Researchers used existing studies to enhance an industry formula known as the levelized cost of electricity to come up with the county-by-county prices for the various types of generation.

“We think our methodology is sound and hope it enhances constructive dialogue,” Joshua Rhodes, a postdoctoral fellow and lead author of the paper, said in a written statement. “But we also know that cost factors change over time, and people disagree about whether to include some of them. We wanted to provide an opportunity for people to change these inputs, and the (online) tools we’ve created allow for that.”

The tools can be used by policymakers and others to fiddle with cost estimates and other factors to inform discussion about new electrical generation.

The report, “New U.S. Power Costs: by County, with Environmental Externalities,” is part of a series of UT white papers examining many aspects of the nation’s power system, including broad topics such as its history and narrower ones such as household energy costs for Texans. Funding for the research came from industrial, nonprofit and governmental organizations, including Austin Energy, the Environmental Defense Fund and ConocoPhillips.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Local

FedEx airlifts barbecue meals to Irma victims in Florida Keys
FedEx airlifts barbecue meals to Irma victims in Florida Keys

Hurricane victims in the Florida Keys are receiving fresh barbecue meals from Operation BBQ Relief thanks to an airlift program by FedEx, USA Today reported. >> Read more trending news FedEx began airlifting more than 10,000 meals a day from Fort Myers to the Keys, following through on a request from one of its aircraft mechanics, Scott...
Deputies: Teacher accused of sex crime exchanged messages via Facebook
Deputies: Teacher accused of sex crime exchanged messages via Facebook

A North Carolina middle school teacher was arrested and charged with a sex crime involving a child, officials with the Rowan County Sheriff's Office said. >> Read more trending news Parents of a student complained that Mark Dexter, 42, sent inappropriate messages to their child through Facebook, deputies said. Investigators determined that it...
British police release 2 men in London train attack probe
British police release 2 men in London train attack probe

British police said they have released two men arrested as part of the investigation into last week’s London Underground train station attack in Parsons Green, which injured 30 people, Reuters reported. >> Read more trending news A 21-year-old man arrested in Hounslow on Sept. 16 and a 48-year-old man arrested in Newport on Sept...
Cop-watcher files lawsuit against Austin police officer
Cop-watcher files lawsuit against Austin police officer

A prolific cop-watcher has filed suit against an Austin police officer, arguing that the officer violated his civil rights when he arrested him on charges that were later dropped. Julian Reyes is representing himself in a case against Austin police Officer Justin Berry based on an arrest that happened on Sept. 19, 2015. Reyes was at the Rally Against...
Cómo puedes ayudar a Puerto Rico tras la devastación del Huracán María
Cómo puedes ayudar a Puerto Rico tras la devastación del Huracán María

María ha sido el huracán más fuerte en golpear a Puerto Rico en más de 80 años, y los daños han sido extensos. El huracán tocó tierra en Puerto Rico el miércoles 20 de septiembre, desatando vientos de 155 millas por hora. Hasta el momento no se han reportado muertes en la isla de 3.4 millones...
More Stories