Texas Senate panel OKs $1.5 billion cut from House school finance bill


The Texas Senate Education Committee on Friday pared down a priority House bill that would have injected $1.8 billion into the public education system.

House Bill 21 would now spend $311 million over the next two years.

“We’ve got to get more productivity out of every dollar we spend in education. We’ve got to seek out efficiencies … things that we can do better with the same amount of money, not just a matter of throwing more money into the system,” Senate Education Chairman Larry Taylor, R-Friendswood said during the hearing.

HB 21 passed the Senate Education Committee Friday 9-1. Sen. Van Taylor, R-Plano, voted against it.

Taylor said that the Senate is expected to vote on HB 21 on Saturday and that he and House lawmakers will work on a compromise.

The trimmed down version of the bill further highlights the discord between both chambers of the Legislature over how to address the state’s beleaguered school finance system.

The House has been pushing the original version of HB 21 filed by House Public Education Chairman Dan Huberty, R-Houston, as the first step in helping cash-strapped school districts.

RELATED: In his special session, Abbott will fall short of 20, but how short?

A majority of the Senate supports studying the school finance system through a commission which would then make recommendations to the Legislature. Gov. Greg Abbott has included such a commission in his special legislative session agenda.

In a news conference earlier this week, Senate Republicans criticized the House for trying to throw money at the school finance problem without a long term plan in place and characterized the HB 21 as a Band-aid fix and political gimmick.

“I talk about doing a basic analysis with a clean sheet … and ask the question what does it cost to educate the child,” said Sen. Bob Hall, R-Edgewood, on Friday.

About 1,500 superintendents and school board trustees, including from the major Central Texas school districts, signed a letter to the Senate committee supporting the original version of HB 21. Some of them comprised the 15 people who signed up to testify during Friday’s hearing.

“It provides immediate help to schools across Texas that have been coping with the state’s diminishing role in funding education,” the letter read. “It also serves as a down payment on the larger process of overhauling the troubled school finance system. The school finance reforms in House Bill 21 are significant, and if made now, they can be built upon in the next legislative session.”

The Senate’s version of HB 21 keeps a provision to create a financial hardship grant for school districts that will lose Additional State Aid for Tax Reduction in September, but trims the appropriations from $200 million to $150 million.

It also boosts spending for small school districts by $41 million and directs $120 million to help school districts and public charter schools pay for construction. Charter schools, which are privately run public schools, have been pushing for such funding for years.

A similar provision was taken out of the original version of HB 21 after traditional school districts and their supporters opposed the idea; they have said that charter schools should not receive such funding because they are held to different standards than traditional public schools.

Officials from Austin charter schools Austin Achieve and NYOS told lawmakers that they need the facilities funding to alleviate waiting lists and improve services for students.

“There’s no space for science labs, athletic fields, no theater or music space. Our guitar class practices outside,” said Kathleen Zimmermann, executive director of NYOS.

IN REVIEW: School finance reform in the 85th Texas Legislature

The Senate’s version of HB 21 eliminates a major provision that would have given almost all public schools a boost by increasing the base amount of money schools get per student from $5,140 to $5,350. The increase would have dropped recapture payments by $389 million over the next two years. Property-wealthy school districts must make recapture payments back to the state to be redistributed to property-poor school districts.

The Austin school district pays more in recapture than any other district in the state — an estimated $534 million next school year.

“We’re dipping into our fund balance,” said Austin school district trustee Julie Cowan. “In three years we’ll be down 3 percent of our fund balance and the year after that, I don’t know what will happen.”

HB 21 would have increased funding to Austin by $25 million over the next two years. The Pflugerville school district would have received $6 million over the next two years, Round Rock $22 million, Leander $9 million and Hays $2 million.

The Senate also removed from HB 21 extra funding to help schools educate students with dyslexia and who are learning English as a second language. It also removed funding for career and technology programs in the eighth grade.

“Parents move to different districts, a few pay for private school but many helplessly watch their children struggle for years. Cash strapped districts have to decide where to take their money from if they’re going to do a dyslexia program,” said Alice Marsel, an Austin dyslexia specialist, opposing the Senate’s changes.

Taylor said that some funding for dyslexia and students learning English as a second language could be put back in the bill.

Both chambers also differ on how to pay for the school finance bill. The House had proposed delaying certain payments to school districts in the upcoming budget cycle to the following 2020-21 biennium.

The Senate instead wants to pay for HB 21 by delaying certain payments to Medicaid managed care organizations in the upcoming budget cycle to the following biennium.

“Plus you have to pay back the $1.8 billion that you deferred so it’s actually a $3.6 billion hit to the next budget,” Taylor said. “We don’t know what the economy is going to look like two years from now. We hope it’s good, but what if it’s not?”

Chandra Villanueva, policy analyst with the Austin-based think tank Center for Public Policy Priorities, told the committee on Friday the state shouldn’t be siphoning money off the Medicaid program, which is already underfunded by $1.2 billion.

The Texas Health and Human Services Commission, however, has already told Senate lawmakers that delaying payments to Medicaid shouldn’t hurt services.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

JUST IN: Man in his 20s found dead near airport after apparent hit-and-run, Austin police say
JUST IN: Man in his 20s found dead near airport after apparent hit-and-run, Austin police say

A man was found dead after an apparent hit-and-run crash in South Austin near Austin-Bergstrom International Airport on Wednesday morning, authorities said.  A passerby called Austin police shortly after 7 a.m. to report a dead person on the side of the road in the 3200 block of U.S. 183 South, on the west side of the airport, authorities said...
FORECAST: Afternoon rain possible as heat nears 100; Gulf storm system heading for Texas
FORECAST: Afternoon rain possible as heat nears 100; Gulf storm system heading for Texas

Wednesday forecast for Austin: The Austin area could see some scattered showers in the afternoon as temperatures could hit 100 for the 42nd time this year. The outlook for Wednesday calls mostly sunny skies with a 30 percent chance of rain, mainly after 2 p.m. High humidity will continue to intensify summer temperatures, sending heat index readings...
NORTHEAST AUSTIN: 2 injured in school bus crash on U.S. 290 service road
NORTHEAST AUSTIN: 2 injured in school bus crash on U.S. 290 service road

A pickup truck apparently ran a red light before hitting a school bus carrying two students in Northeast Austin on Wednesday morning, an Austin school district spokesperson said. Austin-Travis County EMS medics took the drivers of the bus and the pickup truck to St. David’s Medical Center in Central Austin with injuries that were...
How Powerball manipulated the odds to make another massive jackpot
How Powerball manipulated the odds to make another massive jackpot

At $700 million, Wednesday night's Powerball prize is the second-largest lottery jackpot in its history, and the math is working out in favor of lotto commissions. Two years ago, your chances of becoming an instant millionaire were 1 in roughly 175 million. Now, the odds are 1 in roughly 292 million. Tweaks to the game in October 2015 increased the...
DOWNTOWN GARAGE SUED: Woman files lawsuit after car’s 7-story fall last month 
DOWNTOWN GARAGE SUED: Woman files lawsuit after car’s 7-story fall last month 

The woman whose car plummeted from the seventh floor of a downtown parking garage last month has sued the garage’s owner and its management, alleging they were negligent by not upgrading a cable barrier system that failed to keep the car from going over the edge of the building. Cedar Park resident Christi Bowmer, 49, is asking for more than...
More Stories