Texas governor won’t say whom he blocks from public Twitter account


Gov. Greg Abbott and Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick refuse public information requests on people they block on Twitter.

The officials cite cybersecurity concerns.

In June, the American-Statesman sent public records requests to Gov. Greg Abbott and Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, among other Austin- and Texas-based politicians, asking for lists of whom they block from following their public, taxpayer-funded Twitter accounts.

The governor, citing public safety concerns, said, no. His fear: Russian hackers.

Lawyers for each office said they are asking Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton to rule that the information is exempt from required public disclosure. Both argue that divulging the names of the blocked accounts constitute “a computer network vulnerability report.”

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

Abbott and Patrick cited a May Time magazine article that discusses Russian hackers who used tailored Twitter messages to take over a computer upon clicking a link in the tweet, a type of phishing attack. Releasing the lists of blocked accounts, they argue, would allow hackers to see which methods were flagged as security threats and which were not.

The Texas Public Information Act requires government bodies to request an attorney general opinion to withhold information and to notify the person who requested the information of their intent to do so. The law gives Paxton 45 business days to issue a decision; the clock started ticking on July 3. Paxton can also request a 10-day extension.

In a phone call, Abbott’s general counsel Jessica Vu said the governor would still seek to deny the records release even if the Statesman submitted a revised request for only Twitter handles and names.

Not all politicians fear hackers, though. City of Austin public information officials responded to the Statesman’s request the next business day, saying Austin Mayor Steve Adler doesn’t block anyone on Twitter.

In response to a separate request, Adler’s office also released its Twitter direct messages since January 2015.

The Statesman’s initial request was inspired by news that Kentucky Gov. Matt Bevin blocks more than 500 people on Twitter, despite often citing his social media as the only reliable news source on his office.

Kentucky news outlets, including Louisville’s The Courier-Journal and the national nonprofit ProPublica, obtained the names and Twitter handles of people Bevin blocked via open records requests.

TEXAS POLITICS DELIVERED EVERY DAY: Sign up for our Texas Politics email

According to the Kentucky Center for Investigative Reporting, Bevin’s office said users are blocked due to “posting obscene and abusive language or images, or repeated off-topic comments and spam,” while some of those blocked said it was because they sent tweets critiquing the governor.

The American Civil Liberties Union of Kentucky filed a lawsuit on behalf of two of the blocked Twitter users on July 31 for blocking their political speech.

“I may not have voted for Gov. Bevin, but I’m one of his constituents. He shouldn’t be permanently dismissing my views and concerns with a click,” Mary Hargis, one of the people blocked by Bevin and represented by the ACLU, told the Courier-Journal.

Nationally, Twitter users blocked by President Donald Trump are also lawyering up. The Knight First Amendment Institute sued Trump on July 11. The institute argues social media is the newest public forum and that it is unconstitutional to block people from public discourse due to conflicting opinions.

Politicians blocking people on Twitter is nothing new. In 2015, The Atlanta Journal-Constitution, which like the Statesman is owned by Cox Media Group, wrote about a list of people blocked by Atlanta Mayor Kasim Reed. The names came from journalists discussing it on Twitter, not from a public records request.

Most of those Reed blocked were members of the Atlanta press corps who had written unfavorably about the mayor or his policies, but several quoted said they weren’t sure why exactly they got blocked.

In their appeal to deny the Statesman’s request for a list blocked followers, Abbott and Patrick don’t indicate whether all of those they have blocked are barred because they posed cybersecurity threats.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Texas News & Politics

San Marcos considers supporting challenge to ‘sanctuary cities’ law
San Marcos considers supporting challenge to ‘sanctuary cities’ law

The San Marcos City Council will consider writing an amicus brief in opposition to Senate Bill 4, the ban on so-called sanctuary cities, during a special meeting called for Tuesday morning. The meeting, called for 8 a.m. Tuesday in council chambers at 630 E. Hopkins, comes after the council last week voted not to join the cities of Austin...
With rejection of special session core agenda, is GOP civil war next?
With rejection of special session core agenda, is GOP civil war next?

The day before the summer special legislative session began, Gov. Greg Abbott warned lawmakers that he would be keeping an eagle eye on how each of them voted on his 20-item agenda. “I’m going to be establishing a list,” Abbott said. “Who is for this, who is against this, who has not taken a position yet. No one gets to hide...
Two Florida police officers fatally shot, suspect in custody
Two Florida police officers fatally shot, suspect in custody

Two Florida police officers were fatally shot while checking out a report of a suspicious person Friday night, Kissimmee police Chief Jeff O’Dell said. Kissimmee police Officer Matthew Baxter and Sgt. Sam Howard were shot in a scuffle at about 9:30 p.m. at Palmway and East Cypress streets near East Irlo Bronson Memorial Highway and North Main...
After Charlottesville, Austin’s Confederate monuments get a second look
After Charlottesville, Austin’s Confederate monuments get a second look

After a rally by white supremacists fighting removal of a Confederate monument turned deadly in Charlottesville, Va., last weekend, the response in Austin came swiftly. Austin City Council members immediately began paperwork to rename Robert E. Lee Road, near Zilker Park, and Jeff Davis Avenue, near Allandale. At the Capitol, state Rep. Eric Johnson...
‘Free Speech’ rally in Boston draws large crowd of counter-protesters
‘Free Speech’ rally in Boston draws large crowd of counter-protesters

A “free speech” rally in Boston Saturday afternoon drew a large crowd of counter-protesters. An estimated 15,000 counter-protesters marched through the city to Boston Common, where rally attendees gathered to deliver a series of speeches.  The rally ended abruptly, and attendees were escorted by police from the rally area. Tense clashes...
More Stories