Texans testify against transgender bathroom bill through the night


Highlights

Transgender Texans ask House committee to oppose bill they see as discriminatory.

Testimony began at 11:30 p.m. and ended more than five hours later, with the vast majority opposed.

Transgender Texans, and parents of transgender children, packed a Capitol hearing that ran through the night, ending near daybreak Thursday, to oppose a bill that would block cities and school districts from enacting or enforcing transgender-friendly restroom policies.

Several choked back tears as they decried House Bill 2899 as discriminatory, recalling years of rejection, harassment and fear about something most people take for granted — going to a public restroom at school, work and elsewhere.

“Trans people, we can choose not to transition and hate ourselves, or we can step out and be authentic and often invite hatred upon ourselves merely by existing,” said Emmett Schelling of San Antonio. “This basically green lights citizens who might have a bias already to openly be worse than they already are.”

Of 72 people who testified over five hours before the Senate State Affairs Committee, 66 opposed HB 2899, unveiled as an alternative to a Senate measure that also received overwhelming opposition during another hearing that had ended shortly before dawn in March.

With 2 a.m. approaching, Frank Gonzales of Dallas, holding his sleepy transgender daughter, Libby, 7, said he feared the message HB 2899 would send if approved. “My family would become a target for hate groups and lawful discrimination,” he said.

His wife, Rachel Gonzales, said, “Many, many families in Texas, including my own, are counting on you to keep our families safe.”

“It’s terrifying to know the ugly in this world is targeting your child,” she said.

Delayed by long debates on the Texas House floor, the committee took up HB 2899 at 11:30 p.m. with its author, Rep. Ron Simmons, R-Carrollton, saying Texans deserve a uniform policy to protect their safety and privacy statewide.

“This bill is about making sure no child is forced to be in a locker room, shower or changing facility against their will with a member of the opposite sex,” Simmons said. “This issue needs to be the same in Austin as it is in Abilene, the same in Houston as it is in Hutto.”

HB 2899 seeks to nullify local anti-discrimination protections, such as Austin’s protections based on gender identity, as they regulate access to multiple-occupancy bathrooms, showers and changing rooms.

‘A thoughtful proposal’

Simmons’ bill takes a different approach than Senate Bill 6, approved by the Senate last month, which would require government buildings and public schools and universities to limit bathroom use to the sex listed on a person’s birth certificate.

The House version was given an extra boost Tuesday when Gov. Greg Abbott called Simmons bill “a thoughtful proposal to make sure our children maintain privacy in our school bathrooms and locker rooms.” Abbott also said he would work with the House and Senate to get a transgender bathroom bill to his desk before the legislative session ends May 29.

Pastors and social conservatives were among the half-dozen witnesses who spoke in favor of the bill at the hearing.

Tom Giovanetti, president of the Institute for Policy Innovation, which he described as a free-market conservative think tank in Dallas, said the House bill was an improvement from a Senate version because it was a small-government solution that limits the creation of additional protected classes of people.

“It will limit the ability of cities to get involved in this type of social justice activity,” he told the committee.

Dave Welch, president of Texas Pastor Council, said Christian pastors from across the state are pressing for a uniform, statewide standard to counter local laws that have created “a definition of gender identity that differs from city to city.”

Welch took exception to witnesses who opposed HB 2899 because they feared an economic backlash from boycotts.

“We need our women and children protected,” he said. “They are not for sale.”

‘It’s discrimination’

Chairman Byron Cook, R-Corsicana, questioned the need for HB 2899 several times during the hearing, saying he knew of no problems caused by transgender people in public restrooms. Cook balked, however, at allowing students to use locker rooms and changing rooms that conform with their gender identity, saying limitations on those areas may be justified.

Opponents of HB 2899 included elected officials from Austin, San Antonio, Dallas and El Paso. Business organizations, including several that cater to travel and tourism, also registered their opposition, with representatives arguing that passage of the bill would hurt the state’s economy and damage its reputation as an open and welcoming state.

Jimmy Flannigan, who introduced himself as the first openly gay man to serve on the Austin City Council, said HB 2899 represented an improper state intrusion into people’s lives.

“Yes, there are economic issues. There will be jobs lost; there will be money lost. But this is also about people’s lives,” Flannigan said. “This is no role for government. It is not small government, it is not big government, it’s discrimination.”

Cathryn Oakley with the Human Rights Campaign said the bill targets transgender people under the guise of improved safety and privacy.

“It singles out one group of people for no reason other than sheer dislike of them,” Oakley said. “This is not about bathrooms. It’s never been about bathrooms.”

The State Affairs Committee closed the hearing at 4:39 a.m. without voting on HB 2899, a common practice.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

HAPPENING TODAY: UT stabbing suspect to appear in court
HAPPENING TODAY: UT stabbing suspect to appear in court

University of Texas stabbing suspect Kendrex White will appear in court Wednesday for the first time since he was indicted last month for murder in a deadly campus attack that left one student dead. It’s possible White will be arraigned and make a formal plea of guilt or innocence. He also is charged with three counts of aggravated assault with...
When the eclipse appears over Austin, DO NOT STARE AT IT
When the eclipse appears over Austin, DO NOT STARE AT IT

Staring at the sun is always a bad idea. It’s a bad idea even when the moon slides in front of the sun and blocks out most of the sun’s rays, as will happen on Monday for a little over two-and-a-half minutes. Basically, looking at the sun can give your eyeball a sunburn. Robert Rosa, an ophthalmologist at the Texas A&M University Health...
A fiery Dan Patrick lashes out at Speaker Straus
A fiery Dan Patrick lashes out at Speaker Straus

In a fiery news conference minutes after the special legislative session ended Tuesday night, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick lashed out at House Speaker Joe Straus, anticipated difficult primary elections for Republicans in Straus’ mold and predicted that bills to limit transgender bathroom use will be back. Patrick blamed Straus for causing the demise...
Special session ends abruptly, with key issue unresolved
Special session ends abruptly, with key issue unresolved

The special session of the Legislature came to an abrupt end Tuesday night, a day earlier than expected, when the Texas Senate adjourned without acting on a House-passed version of a property tax bill. The House began the late-session drama when it unexpectedly closed the special session with one item pending — a conference committee on...
Lake Travis school board meeting highlights: Changes to the tax rate
Lake Travis school board meeting highlights: Changes to the tax rate

Here are some highlights from the Aug. 15 Lake Travis Board of Trustees meeting: District staff are proposing a balanced budget for the 2017-2018 school year for the first time in a decade. The Texas Education Agency announced earlier this year that school districts offering a Local Optional Homestead Exemption would...
More Stories