Study: Texas lags behind most states in school funding


Highlights

According to a new study, Texas saw the sixth-highest decline in state funding levels between 2008 and 2015.

Increased reliance on local taxes and tax cuts to businesses are among reasons for the state funding drop.

Cut in state funding has translated to cuts in school programs for low-income children.

Since 2008, when the Great Recession led to major funding cuts to education across the country, Texas has lagged behind most states in restoring those dollars, according to a new study.

Per-student state funding in Texas in 2015, the latest education spending data available from the U.S. Census Bureau, was 16 percent lower than in 2008, when adjusted for inflation, according to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a Washington-based liberal think tank.

That was the sixth-biggest decline in state education spending during that period — behind Arizona, Florida, Alabama, Idaho and Georgia. Nineteen states increased funding between 2008 and 2015 by as much as 96 percent.

READ: Texas Lawmakers offer urban schools little extra during legislative session

Increased reliance on local tax revenue and sluggish oil prices, among other factors, have contributed to stagnant state education funding, according to the study, which was released Tuesday night. At the same time, education has become more costly.

As a result, school districts have had to cut teachers, staff and student programs, particularly those that serve low-income students, said Michael Leachman, one of the study’s authors.

“These trends are very concerning to the country’s future prospects,” said Leachman, the center’s director of state fiscal research. “The health of the nation’s economy, our quality of life, will depend crucially on the creativity and intellectual capacity of our people. If we neglect our schools, we diminish our future.”

To soften the blow from the 2008 recession, Texas relied on federal money from the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. But when the money dried up, state lawmakers enacted major funding cuts in 2011, including $5.3 billion from public education, to fill the hole. Although the state has since added money back into education, it hasn’t been enough to bring the per-student funding level back to what it was in 2008 because of inflation and the rapidly growing student population in the state.

Between fiscal years 2017 and 2018, state per-student funding in Texas dropped 1.5 percent, when adjusted for inflation, according to Leachman’s study.

With diminished state money, Texas schools have had to rely more heavily on revenue generated from local property taxes. When local tax dollars are factored in, Texas’ per-student funding level is actually 4.8 percent below the 2008 level.

“Austin and most other Central Texas school districts are in danger of crumbling under the burden of serving as a piggy bank for the state of Texas when it comes to funding education. Property taxes are simply too high, and the state’s investment is too small,” said Drew Scheberle, senior vice president for policy and advocacy at the Greater Austin Chamber of Commerce.

Because the Austin school district is considered property wealthy, it will send an estimated $534 million — nearly 50 percent of the district’s operating budget — in recapture payments to the state to help support property-poor school districts.

POLL: Most voters blame state for school money woes, support bond

The study also says tax cuts are to blame for states’ struggles to return to 2008 education funding levels.

In 2015, Texas lawmakers passed a multibillion-dollar tax relief package that increased the property tax homestead exemption and cut the business franchise tax by 25 percent.

“While it might be popular to give tax cuts, we then have to pay for those tax cuts and fill that hole rather than (make) a greater investment in our schools,” said Christy Rome, executive director of the Texas School Coalition, which represents mostly property-wealthy school districts.

Rome said the study doesn’t take into account the greater challenges Texas faces compared with many other states. The state’s student population has grown about 2 percent each year to 5.3 million, with many of those new students non-native English speakers and from low-income families.

Special education services, bilingual programs and services for students at risk of dropping out were hit hardest by the funding cuts in 2011, according to another study released last month by the Center for Public Policy Priorities, an Austin-based liberal think tank.

“When we took a more in-depth look into Texas finances to look at how school districts absorbed the cuts, we saw that it was low-income elementary kids that faced the most cuts in programs that helped them get ahead,” said Chandra Villanueva, one of the study’s authors and a senior policy analyst with the Austin center.

In the Leander school district, officials have had to juggle providing adequate academic services for a growing student population with paying teachers and staff competitively.

In 2010, 43 percent of the district’s operating funds came from money from the state. In 2017, that dropped to 21 percent.

“Leander ISD supports more than 39,000 students in 42 schools despite significant financial challenges,” district spokesman Corey Ryan said. “Since 2010, LISD has seen a 25 percent surge in student enrollment and a significant rise in cost of living for employees, while its state revenues decreased by $15.3 million.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Deputies identify man found dead with child; his wounds were self-inflicted, officials say
Deputies identify man found dead with child; his wounds were self-inflicted, officials say

The Travis County sheriff’s office has identified the man who was found dead along with a young girl inside a southwestern Travis County home Monday, each apparently fatally shot. Yariv Kaplan, 42, was the man found dead, the sheriff’s office said. Officials said they are still working to confirm the child’s identity. Evidence...
Police: Man says he stole headstone from cemetery for Satanic worship
Police: Man says he stole headstone from cemetery for Satanic worship

An Austin man is accused of stealing a headstone from a Georgetown cemetery that he said was going to be used for an altar for Satanic worship, an affidavit said. Jeremiah Rhyne, 38, was charged with theft of grave property, a state jail felony punishable by up to two years in jail. Police found the headstone from 1884 leaning against a living room...
Abbott urges TEA to give Harvey-hit schools a reprieve from STAAR
Abbott urges TEA to give Harvey-hit schools a reprieve from STAAR

Gov. Greg Abbott is putting pressure on the Texas Education Agency to give students in school districts affected by Hurricane Harvey a reprieve from STAAR requirements. Students in the fifth and eighth grade must pass the math and reading STAAR to move on to the next grade. In a letter on Monday, Abbott asked TEA Commissioner Mike Morath to waive the...
TRAFFIC UPDATE: Southbound U.S. 183 near Payton Gin Rd. shut down after motorcycle crash, police say 
TRAFFIC UPDATE: Southbound U.S. 183 near Payton Gin Rd. shut down after motorcycle crash, police say 

4:10 p.m. update: Austin police have completely shut down the southbound lanes of U.S. 183 in North Austin after a motorcycle crash on Tuesday afternoon. Police said officers have closed the highway down at Payton Gin Road, and urged drivers to find alternate routes. Earlier: Medics say a man in his 50s was taken to Dell Seton Medical Center with critical...
Trump aide takes over as top federal prosecutor in Austin region
Trump aide takes over as top federal prosecutor in Austin region

A former member of President Donald Trump’s staff has been sworn in as the United States attorney for the Western District of Texas to prosecute federal crimes in the region that includes Austin. John F. Bash, who served as special assistant to Trump and associate White House counsel, took the oath Monday at the federal courthouse in San Antonio...
More Stories