State panel limits teaching phenomena that challenge evolution


Highlights

The board on Friday adopted streamlined science curriculum standards that will go into effect 2018-19.

The board has struggled with whether to change how evolution is taught.

Critics say that the current way evolution is taught is watered down.

By swapping out a few words in high school biology curriculum standards, the State Board of Education has limited the teaching of scientific phenomena that challenge the theory of evolution, a move that liberals hailed as a victory.

The panel on Friday approved a pared down version of the high school biology curriculum standards after committees of teachers and scholars worked for months to streamline the state’s voluminous science curriculum for all grades. The standards that covered evolution became the most hotly debated issue during the process.

“It was clear from testifiers that many who had varied concerns found the compromise language chosen by the board to be acceptable, addressing both the need to streamline content while still encouraging critical thinking by students,” said board chairwoman Donna Bahorich, R-Houston.

TEXAS POLITICS DELIVERED EVERY DAY: Sign up for our Texas Politics email

Currently, high school students must learn about scientific phenomena that can’t readily be explained by evolution, like cell complexity, origin of DNA and life, and abrupt appearances in fossil records, which left-leaning critics have said invites teachings of creationism and intelligent design.

On Friday, the board approved new wording on two standards that have come under particular scrutiny:

• Compare and contrast prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells, including their complexity, and compare and contrast scientific explanations for cellular complexity.

• Identify components of DNA, describe how information for specifying the traits of an organism is carried in the DNA, and examine scientific explanations for the origin of DNA.

The streamlined standards will go into effect in the 2018-19 school year.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

In January, the board-appointed streamlining committee recommended elimination of anti-evolution curriculum standards, but the board in February proposed to restore much of the language. The committee then asked the board to soften the language the board wanted to restore — instead of “evaluating” cell complexity and origin of DNA, students should “identify” or “compare and contrast, ” the committee suggested — which received pushback from evolution skeptics.

On Wednesday, with the blessing of some of the committee members, the board voted unanimously to allow students to compare and contrast cell complexity and examine the origin of DNA instead of “evaluate” or “identify.”

Ron Wetherington, a Southern Methodist University professor and member of the streamlining committee who doesn’t think creationism and intelligent design should be taught in the classroom, said the new standards were a success.

“For the first time in decades, the science standards contain no controversial student expectations and represent mainstream science. Also for the first time, the board reached out to teachers for ongoing comment on their amendments and paid attention to the experts in the classroom,” he said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Police union: Officers still suffering from carbon monoxide effects

Three Austin police officers are suffering long-term effects from carbon monoxide poisoning that they believe came from their police vehicles, according to the Austin Police Department’s union president. “This whole thing has been a disaster from the beginning,” said Ken Casaday, president of the Austin Police Association. &ldquo...
Police union: Officers still suffering from carbon monoxide effects
Police union: Officers still suffering from carbon monoxide effects

Three Austin police officers are suffering long-term effects from carbon monoxide poisoning that they believe came from their police vehicles, according to the Austin Police Department’s union president. “This whole thing has been a disaster from the beginning,” said Ken Casaday, president of the Austin Police Association. &ldquo...
Central Health budget hearing sparks debate over medical school funds
Central Health budget hearing sparks debate over medical school funds

About an hour into a discussion on Central Health’s budget that became a debate over the health district’s relationship with University of Texas’ Dell Medical School, Travis County Commissioner Gerald Daugherty announced he was fed up. “I have sat through two, three years of this stuff, and I’m, quite frankly, I&rsquo...
Bee Cave City Council parses budget
Bee Cave City Council parses budget

The Bee Cave City Council met briefly on Aug. 22 to nail down a budget for the 2017-2018 fiscal year with few drastic changes. Council focused on road maintenance and police department expenses. City Manager Travis Askey showed the council a chart demonstrating costs for each of the city’s departments over the past five years. The police department...
Dan, Fran Keller to get $3.4 million in ‘satanic day care’ case
Dan, Fran Keller to get $3.4 million in ‘satanic day care’ case

Dan and Fran Keller, who spent more than 21 years in prison after they were accused of sexually abusing children during supposed satanic rituals at their South Austin day care facility, will receive $3.4 million from a state fund for those wrongly convicted of crimes. Shortly after receiving the news Tuesday, an ecstatic Fran Keller said they will...
More Stories