State panel limits teaching phenomena that challenge evolution


Highlights

The board on Friday adopted streamlined science curriculum standards that will go into effect 2018-19.

The board has struggled with whether to change how evolution is taught.

Critics say that the current way evolution is taught is watered down.

By swapping out a few words in high school biology curriculum standards, the State Board of Education has limited the teaching of scientific phenomena that challenge the theory of evolution, a move that liberals hailed as a victory.

The panel on Friday approved a pared down version of the high school biology curriculum standards after committees of teachers and scholars worked for months to streamline the state’s voluminous science curriculum for all grades. The standards that covered evolution became the most hotly debated issue during the process.

“It was clear from testifiers that many who had varied concerns found the compromise language chosen by the board to be acceptable, addressing both the need to streamline content while still encouraging critical thinking by students,” said board chairwoman Donna Bahorich, R-Houston.

TEXAS POLITICS DELIVERED EVERY DAY: Sign up for our Texas Politics email

Currently, high school students must learn about scientific phenomena that can’t readily be explained by evolution, like cell complexity, origin of DNA and life, and abrupt appearances in fossil records, which left-leaning critics have said invites teachings of creationism and intelligent design.

On Friday, the board approved new wording on two standards that have come under particular scrutiny:

• Compare and contrast prokaryotic and eukaryotic cells, including their complexity, and compare and contrast scientific explanations for cellular complexity.

• Identify components of DNA, describe how information for specifying the traits of an organism is carried in the DNA, and examine scientific explanations for the origin of DNA.

The streamlined standards will go into effect in the 2018-19 school year.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

In January, the board-appointed streamlining committee recommended elimination of anti-evolution curriculum standards, but the board in February proposed to restore much of the language. The committee then asked the board to soften the language the board wanted to restore — instead of “evaluating” cell complexity and origin of DNA, students should “identify” or “compare and contrast, ” the committee suggested — which received pushback from evolution skeptics.

On Wednesday, with the blessing of some of the committee members, the board voted unanimously to allow students to compare and contrast cell complexity and examine the origin of DNA instead of “evaluate” or “identify.”

Ron Wetherington, a Southern Methodist University professor and member of the streamlining committee who doesn’t think creationism and intelligent design should be taught in the classroom, said the new standards were a success.

“For the first time in decades, the science standards contain no controversial student expectations and represent mainstream science. Also for the first time, the board reached out to teachers for ongoing comment on their amendments and paid attention to the experts in the classroom,” he said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

FORECAST: Moisture from front, cold front could make for soggy weekend
FORECAST: Moisture from front, cold front could make for soggy weekend

Friday forecast for Austin: It will be muggy in Austin on Friday and Saturday, thanks to moisture flowing off of the Gulf of Mexico, potentially bringing daytime storms that could throw a new wrinkle at the Texas Longhorns struggling offense and the Formula One races set to begin this morning.  A cold front arriving late Saturday or early...
Jeff Sessions to speak immigration priorities in Austin
Jeff Sessions to speak immigration priorities in Austin

Attorney General Jeff Sessions will be in Austin Friday to discuss President Donald Trump’s immigration priorities, according to the Justice Department. Sessions will have a round table discussion with state and local law enforcement officials, receive a federal crime briefing and meet with U.S. Attorney’s Office staff, a DOJ official told...
Cub Scout who questioned Colorado lawmaker kicked out of his den
Cub Scout who questioned Colorado lawmaker kicked out of his den

A Cub Scout in Colorado was kicked out of his den, allegedly for asking pointed questions to a state senator during a meeting organized by the Boy Scouts, The Denver Post reported. On Oct., 9, Ames Mayfield, 11, a fifth-grader and a Scout for five years, asked Colorado Sen. Vicki Marble questions about gun control and about comments she made about...
Transgender woman convicted of sexually assaulting 10-year-old in bathroom
Transgender woman convicted of sexually assaulting 10-year-old in bathroom

A Wyoming transgender woman was found guilty of sexually assaulting a 10-year-old girl in a bathroom, the Billings Gazette reported Wednesday.  A 12-person jury found Michelle Martinez, who was known as Miguel Martinez before identifying as a female, guilty of first-degree and second-degree sexual abuse of a minor. Martinez could face...
Trial in boyfriend’s death jeopardized over medical examiner’s testimony
Trial in boyfriend’s death jeopardized over medical examiner’s testimony

A Travis County judge is threatening to dismiss murder charges against man who is on trial for beating his boyfriend to death because a medical examiner revealed unexpectedly that he amended his official finding on the victim’s cause of death. State district Judge David Wahlberg on Thursday told lawyers in Bryan Canchola’s trial that he...
More Stories