State panel gives early OK for curriculum that challenges evolution


Highlights

The proposed biology curriculum standards will be posted to the Texas Register for public comment.

The public comment period should start within the month.

The curriculum would invite creationism and intelligent design into the classroom, liberals say

The State Board of Education gave preliminary approval Friday to biology curriculum for public high school students that challenges the theory of evolution.

The vote gives the Texas Education Agency the OK to post the curriculum changes, which are similar to standards already in place, to the Texas Register so that the public can offer input.

Over the summer, the board tasked a committee to whittle down the high school biology curriculum standards to help teachers lessen the material they must teach. The committee voted to pare down or remove language that challenges the theory of evolution, which had been originally implemented in 2009.

Board member Barbara Cargill, R-The Woodlands, offered to restore most of the language on Wednesday and fellow Republican members, which make up a majority of the board, agreed. The five Democrats on the panel opposed the move.

The biology curriculum would require students to evaluate the complexity of cells, the origin of DNA and life, and examine explanations of abrupt appearance and stasis in the fossil records. Supporters of the standards have said that the theory of evolution can’t readily explain these scientific events.

Cargill defended the move, saying that the curriculum standards spur critical thinking in students and that geophysicists and those who work in the oil and gas industry have told her that they want students to learn about fossils.

Democratic board members said earlier this week that the standards would invite creationism and intelligent design into the classroom.

In April, the board could adopt the curriculum standards, which would then go into effect in the 2017-18 school year.

The curriculum standards dictate what teachers teach in the classroom, what students are tested on in standardized tests and what appears in textbooks.

The Legislature has also taken an interest in science education in public schools.

State Rep. Valoree Swanson, R-Spring, proposed a bill this week that would give “academic freedom for teachers” and require a public school environment that encourages students to “respond appropriately and respectfully to differences of opinion about scientific subjects.”

Glenn Branch with the National Center for Science Education, a California-based organization that supports the teaching of evolution, said House Bill 1485 is unnecessary and would embolden “maverick teachers” to teach junk science.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Bullet grazed child’s neck outside South Austin Torchy’s, officials say
Bullet grazed child’s neck outside South Austin Torchy’s, officials say

Austin police are investigating an incident in which a bullet grazed a 9-year-old’s neck Saturday afternoon outside a South Austin Torchy’s restaurant. Austin police and Austin-Travis County EMS officials said they received a call about the incident at about 12 p.m. outside of a Torchy’s at 4301 W. William Cannon Drive. EMS officials...
East Austin plaque unveiled to remember lynching victims
East Austin plaque unveiled to remember lynching victims

The details of the Travis County lynching in 1894, based on news accounts from the time, are discouragingly sparse. Even the victims’ names are lost to history. An African-American woman working as a nurse for a white family was jailed after one of the children in her care died. Two African-American men, for reasons no longer known, were arrested...
Texas GOP files suit to remove Blake Farenthold from ballot
Texas GOP files suit to remove Blake Farenthold from ballot

The Republican Party of Texas is suing the Texas secretary of state over an election filing deadline that prevents it from removing embattled U.S. Rep. Blake Farenthold from the ballot. The move is in response to Farenthold’s announcement that he won’t seek re-election in the spring. Farenthold, whose district includes parts of Bastrop...
Trail of Lights, Winter Wonderland canceled tonight due to weather
Trail of Lights, Winter Wonderland canceled tonight due to weather

Organizers have canceled tonight’s events at Austin’s Trail of Lights, Circuit of the Americas’ Winter Wonderland and Buda’s Trail of Lights due to the rainy weather expected. “The forecasted weather conditions would limit the operation of many attractions and would dampen a festive atmosphere,” Circuit of the Americas...
How the federal government seized Texas property for the border fence
How the federal government seized Texas property for the border fence

The land agents started working the border between Texas and Mexico in the spring of 2007. Sometimes they were from the Army Corps of Engineers. Other times the U.S. Border Patrol. They visited tumbledown mobile homes and suburban houses with golf course views. They delivered blunt news to ranchers and farmers, sheet metal workers and university professors...
More Stories