Republican state Senate plan would limit local tax increases


Under a new proposal from a key Republican state senator, city and county property tax increases of 4 percent or greater would automatically trigger elections in which voters could nix the planned tax hikes.

State Sen. Paul Bettencourt, R-Houston, who chaired a special committee that studied ways to limit local property taxes in advance of the next legislative session, on Tuesday unveiled Senate Bill 2, which would make changes to Texas’ “roll back” process for tax increases.

Currently, if cities and counties raise taxes by 8 percent or more, residents can petition to hold an election on the tax rate. Under the proposal, the “roll back rate” is lowered to 4 percent, and the referendum is automatic.

“Property tax bills go up much faster than people’s paychecks,” Bettencourt said. “The taxpayers’ ability to pay has to be looked at.”

Critics of the proposal, however, said that it usurps local control and that Bettencourt uses fuzzy math in claiming that property taxes have outpaced income growth. They also questioned whether the bill would make an impact given that it doesn’t address the largest source of property tax collections in Texas: school districts.

GET THE DAY’S LATEST NEWS: Click here to sign up for our Afternoon Updates email

The mayors of Austin, San Antonio, San Marcos and New Braunfels issued a joint statement attacking the plan, saying it would save their taxpayers little but would result in significant cuts to city services.

“We should not risk police, fire fighting, EMS, parks, safety nets and transportation projects – all to save Austin homeowners only $2.69 a month. It’s risky and not real tax relief,” Austin Mayor Steve Adler said in the statement. “If the Legislature really wants to help local taxpayers, it should better fund education because that’s most of the Austin property tax bill.”

Bettencourt’s bill includes a dig aimed directly at the city of Austin, which last year sued the Travis Central Appraisal District to argue that commercial properties are systematically undervalued in Texas, indirectly costing homeowners who end up paying more on their property taxes. Earlier this month, a judge tossed out the lawsuit, saying it was a question for the Legislature, not the courts.

The Bettencourt bill would codify that finding by prohibiting local governments from filing similar suits. In a news conference, he criticized Austin’s handling of the lawsuit, in which the city encouraged local tax authorities to reject its appeal of the valuations to set up a showdown in court.

“I can’t imagine anything more un-American,” Bettencourt said.

Adler fired back in a statement: “I hear the senator’s passion, but there are few things more American than the right to seek redress in our courts — especially as regards a broken tax system.”

Senate priority

The property tax measure is one of Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick’s top priorities for the legislative session that begins in January. He appointed Bettencourt’s Select Committee on Property Tax Reform and Relief, which held eight hearings across the state since the last session.

“Texans pay the sixth-highest property tax in the nation and Texans have told us loud and clear that common-sense property tax reform legislation is long overdue,” Patrick said in a statement. “Property taxes are driving people out of their homes and hampering business expansion and growth. It’s time for this to stop.”

With lackluster sales tax collections caused by persistently low oil and gas prices and growing demands for increased funding for scandal-plagued social programs, there will be little wiggle room in the state budget adopted by lawmakers next year. Republicans might find the Bettencourt proposal to be politically useful because it allows them to take credit for tax relief without having to find cuts in their own budget.

Bennett Sandlin, executive director of the Texas Municipal League, said that the Bettencourt plan is politically motivated and that real property tax relief must involve changes to the funding system for public schools.

“It’s just diverting attention away from the real issue,” he said. “It’s coming after a very small piece of the pie. It’s not going to provide meaningful relief.”

Travis County Commissioner Brigid Shea said she thinks Bettencourt’s bill is unfair to counties because the state often gives them “unfunded mandates” that require counties to carry out costly functions without providing state money to pay for them.

“The Legislature takes actions which force additional costs on local government and a lot of that is in the court arena,” Shea said.

Apples and incomes

Bettencourt’s pitch for Senate Bill 2 comes with a packet of line graphs comparing city and county tax collections with median household income over the last decade. The graphs appear to show that property tax collections have far outpaced Texans’ incomes, but critics say that comparison is too simplistic

Bettencourt’s approach fails to take into account population growth because it compares the growth of one typical Texas household’s income to the growth in tax collections across the entire state. A more direct comparison would do one of two things: compare a typical Texans’ income to what a typical Texan pays in taxes; or compare all Texans’ combined incomes to what all Texans’ pay in taxes combined.

Dick Lavine, a senior fiscal analyst for the left-leaning Center for Public Policy Priorities, chose the latter option and found that the growth in total personal income for all Texans has tracked closely with the growth in total city and county tax collections since 1993.

“It’s really the foundation for his whole argument,” Lavine said. “That’s his fundamental complaint about the system, and it’s a misinterpretation of what’s going on.”

Bettencourt said the committee chose to use median household income because it was “the best reflection of what a median household in Texas has with extra disposable income.”

“No matter what graph you use, you’ve got property tax payments rising faster than people’s ability to pay for it,” he said. “We’ll leave it to the folks to decide: Are their paychecks rising faster than their taxes? And the universal answer is no.”


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Iran tests new ballistic missile
Iran tests new ballistic missile

Iran tested a new ballistic missile that reportedly is capable of carrying multiple warheads, CNN reported Saturday, citing the nation's state-run broadcaster announced. >> Read more trending news “Iran has released footage of the successful test-launch of its new ballistic missile, Khorramshahr, a few hours after it was unveiled during...
Memo: Seattle officer bragged that 'mini Mafia' controlled off-duty contracts
Memo: Seattle officer bragged that 'mini Mafia' controlled off-duty contracts

As an FBI investigation into Seattle’s off-duty police work unfolds, additional claims of questionable tactics by officers have emerged, including a report that one policeman proudly called his fellow officers a “mini Mafia” in the way they secured, enforced, and collected on private security and traffic contracts in the booming city...
Trump touts transparency on Twitter
Trump touts transparency on Twitter

President Donald Trump has no intention of scaling back his Twitter presence.  >> Read more trending news The president, campaigning for fellow Republican Luther Strange in Alabama on Friday night, touted his provocative and sometimes controversial tweets, CNN reported. "That is the great thing about Twitter," Trump said during...
Texas students told ‘It’s the law’ to stand for Pledge of Allegiance
Texas students told ‘It’s the law’ to stand for Pledge of Allegiance

A presentation telling students that they have to stand for the Pledge of Allegiance because it's the law has caused controversy at a Texas high school, the Houston Chronicle reported. >> Read more trending news  Juniors and seniors at Midland High School were given a presentation on the Pledge of Allegiance earlier this month...
Police: New Orleans mayoral candidate facing lewd conduct charge
Police: New Orleans mayoral candidate facing lewd conduct charge

A New Orleans mayoral candidate was arrested on a charge of lewd conduct after police said he was found with his pants pulled down in the back of an Uber in Santa Monica, Calif., Nola.com reported. >> Read more trending news Frank Scurlock was picked up on a charge of public masturbation in February, police said. Terry White, a deputy...
More Stories