Proposed Mexican-American studies textbook decried as ‘racist’ scrapped


A Mexican-American studies textbook proposed for Texas public high schools has been dumped.

The State Board of Education voted unanimously on Friday to exclude “Mexican American Heritage” — a textbook that critics have for months said contained racist passages and factual errors — from a list of recommended textbooks.

“I am gratified that the board members were able to put aside differences about their views of the book and speak in favor of sound structural materials and the well-being of children in public schools,” said Emilio Zamora, a University of Texas history professor who served on a committee appointed by board member Ruben Cortez, D-Brownsville, that reviewed the book.

READ: Does a new Texas textbook whitewash Mexican-American history?

The board gave a preliminary vote on Wednesday to scrap the book with the board’s Vice Chairman Thomas Ratliff, R-Mount Pleasant, declaring that the move wasn’t meant to censor the authors.

Cynthia Dunbar — a former Republican board member who is now head of Momentum Instruction, which published the textbook — said earlier this week that the board would invite a lawsuit if it rejects the book.

She has denied any racist intent with the book and promised that she would address all errors if it were adopted.

She didn’t respond to a request for comment Friday.

The textbook has generated significant controversy since the Texas Education Agency released it online for public review in May.

Among the problems with the book, according to critics, were depictions of early Mexican-American activists as threats to American democracy. The textbook also came under fire for omitting contributions of Mexican-American women through history and suggesting that Mexican-Americans are lazy.

The book’s authors submitted 20 pages of corrections to the Texas Education Agency, including eliminating the reference to the “stereotype of Mexicans working idly,” but Zamora said the authors didn’t significantly address other major concerns that critics had.

One section of the book initially said that communism caused natural disasters. After this error was identified, authors changed the sentence to say communism “left in its wake famine, natural disaster and civil war.”

“Mexican American Heritage” was the only textbook proposed for any ethnic studies subject for the 2017-18 school year.

The board on Friday approved opening bids next year for additional textbooks in Mexican-American studies as well as in other ethnic area studies. The books would go into classrooms in the 2018-19 school year.


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Kentucky teacher arrested after allegedly snorting crushed pill in class
Kentucky teacher arrested after allegedly snorting crushed pill in class

A Kentucky teacher was arrested Thursday on suspicion of snorting drugs in class, WLEX reported. Students at Menifee County Elementary/Middle School in Frenchburg told officials they saw Cherish Rednour, 41, crush a pill with a credit card and make a line with the powder. They alleged that after snorting the pill, Rednour slumped over her desk...
A decade later, Russian couple discover their dead infant son is actually alive
A decade later, Russian couple discover their dead infant son is actually alive

For nearly a decade, a Russian couple believed their infant son was dead. Instead, they discovered the child is alive; an “administrative mix-up” led to miscommunication. In 2011, the couple, who live in Volgograd, were told by their doctor that their newborn boy would die within the week, The Independent reported. Believing that their...
Veteran claims homeless woman she invited into home stole her car
Veteran claims homeless woman she invited into home stole her car

A military veteran thought she was being a good Samaritan when she invited a homeless woman into her California home to avoid cold weather. Instead, she is lamenting the loss of her car, which she alleges the homeless woman took, KRON reported. Sharon Larson, 69, said she saw a homeless woman outside a McDonald’s restaurant in Fairfield...
FORECAST: Rain, slick roads during morning commute; temps to reach 67
FORECAST: Rain, slick roads during morning commute; temps to reach 67

Friday forecast for Austin: Morning commuters should be wary of slick roads and heavy rainfall as the National Weather Service calls for a 90 percent chance of rain throughout the day and evening. Forecasters say Austin could get at least a quarter-inch of rain. Despite the patchy fog and rain, Austin temperatures – which were 45 degrees as...
Pennsylvania school district officials cancel classes over potential threat
Pennsylvania school district officials cancel classes over potential threat

Officials in a school district in Pennsylvania decided to cancel classes for Friday after an alleged threat was found at a high school. The Greater Latrobe School District announced that a note was found in a bathroom at Greater Latrobe Senior High School, school officials said. The note was scribbled on a bathroom wall and mentioned Friday's date...
More Stories