‘Private school voucher’ bill approved by Senate panel


The Senate Education Committee approved Senate Bill 3 with a 7-3 vote.

State Sen. Kel Seliger, R-Amarillo, has concerns about state support of anti-American teachings with the bill.

Proponents say the bill would save the state money.

The Senate Education Committee on Thursday approved a bill that would redirect state money to help students pay for private school tuition among other non-public educational expenses.

Senate Bill 3, which has emerged as one of the most divisive education measures so far this session, won the approval of seven senators in the committee — Eddie Lucio, Jr. of Brownsville was the only Democrat to vote in favor — while three senators — Kel Seliger, R-Amarillo; Royce West, D-Dallas; and Carlos Uresti, D-San Antonio — voted against it.

Seliger told his colleagues that he was concerned that the bill would not hold private schools and other institutions that would benefit from the bill to the same accountability standards as public schools. He also said he was concerned that public money could go to support a Muslim private school that could teach anti-American principles.

“We must as Americans ardently defend their right do that. What we’re not obligated to do is spend public money on indoctrination and curriculum like that,” he said.

READ: Report: Bill could cut $86 million from Central Texas school districts

SB 3, which supporters have called the school choice bill and opponents have compared to private school vouchers, would create a system of so-called education savings accounts and tax credit scholarships.

Students leaving public school and kindergarten-aged children could use the savings accounts to pay for a variety of education services, including tuition for private schools, online courses and educational therapies. For those students who leave public school, SB 3 would redirect a portion of the per-student state money the school district receives to the savings accounts.

A family of four whose income is at least $90,000 would receive about $5,400 per year and a family who makes less than that would receive $6,800. Students with disabilities regardless of income would receive $8,200.

Low-income students could also qualify for tax credit scholarships to use toward private school tuition; businesses that donate to the scholarship fund would receive a tax credit — capped at $100 million per year — from the state.

State Sen. Van Taylor, R-Plano, who voted in favor, said that SB 3 would save the state money because public schools would be relieved of the student growth they’ve seen each year.

“Because we’re actually spending less money per child in this program, there would actually be more money per child in the public education system,” he said.

More than 100 people signed up to testify on the bill on Tuesday during a committee hearing that lasted more than nine hours.

Those who testified in favor included out-of-state policy experts who touted savings, parental oversight of private schools, and competition in public schools that other state school choice programs have created. Parents from Texas testified on how public schools failed their children and that they wanted more say in their children’s education. Private school officials touted their programs.

Those who testified against the bill included public school officials and their advocates and teacher union representatives who said SB 3 would strip money from cash-strapped schools and would not improve private school access or the academic performance of poor and minority children. At least one home schooling mom said she feared more state regulations.

“We are continuing to work on this bill … to make this a bill that we can pass,” committee chairman and author of SB 3 Larry Taylor, R-Friendswood, said on Thursday.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Georgia student discovers birth brother attended same college, had same major
Georgia student discovers birth brother attended same college, had same major

The slogan for purchasing a DNA test kit on the genealogy website Ancestry.com is "Open a world of possibilities." >> Read more trending newsFor a Georgia college junior, a DNA test earlier this week opened up his family history and helped him connect to a long-lost sibling and his birth parents.Kieron Christian Graham, 20, is majoring...
Precious photos show Santa visiting infants at Ohio hospital
Precious photos show Santa visiting infants at Ohio hospital

Santa Claus made a special trip to an Ohio hospital to spread Christmas love to babies in the newborn intensive care unit. At Akron Children’s Hospital, 66 families received a special visit from St. Nick, who held the infants and chatted with the babies’ older siblings, WJW reported. The hospital posted some of the photographs on its ...
Watch: Coyote attacks dog in suburban Chicago yard
Watch: Coyote attacks dog in suburban Chicago yard

An Illinois couple posted a scary video that showed their dog being attacked by a coyote. It happened very quickly in the Chicago suburb of Northfield, WGN reported. Boozer, a cairn terrier, was outside when a coyote rushed in and circled it. The coyote then attacked, biting the 14-pound dog’s head and dragging it around the back yard. The...
California swimmer hospitalized after sea lion bites him on the arm
California swimmer hospitalized after sea lion bites him on the arm

A California man was hospitalized after being bitten on the arm by a sea lion in the waters off San Francisco, The Los Angeles Times reported. The attack occurred Thursday near Aquatic Park, San Francisco police said. The man had been swimming when the sea lion approached him. The man said he felt threatened and began splashing water at the animal...
Female Democrat pulls out of House race amid sexual misconduct accusations
Female Democrat pulls out of House race amid sexual misconduct accusations

Andrea Ramsey, a Kansas Democrat running for a House seat in 2018, has dropped out of the race amid sexual misconduct accusations, according to the Kansas City Star. The retired businesswoman — who was considered one of the Democratic Party’s brightest political prospects — was hoping to challenge Republican Rep. Kevin Yoder...
More Stories