Pregnant immigrant in Texas will test abortion access under Trump


Highlights

Federal judge in California will decide if pregnant teen in U.S. custody should be able to have an abortion.

Attorney General Ken Paxton asks judge to reject the request for immigrant who crossed border illegally.

A pregnant 17-year-old, in federal custody in Texas after being apprehended while crossing the Mexican border illegally, is seeking an emergency court order to allow her to have an abortion that has been thwarted by Trump administration officials.

Lawyers with the American Civil Liberties Union, representing the teenager identified only as Jane Doe, will appear Wednesday before a federal judge in California to request an order allowing the teen to obtain an abortion as soon as possible.

The lawyers also will request a wider order barring Trump administration officials from “obstructing or interfering with abortion access” for other pregnant minors who were arrested after crossing the border without their parents.

“Ms. Doe is not the only unaccompanied minor who has recently experienced obstruction to abortion access at the hands of defendants and, absent this court’s intervention, she will not be the last,” the ACLU lawyers argued.

FIRST READING: Why the Texas GOP won’t be able to replace Ken Paxton on the ballot even if he is convicted of a felony

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton entered the fray Tuesday, filing a brief urging U.S. Magistrate Judge Laurel Beeler to deny Jane Doe’s “radical request,” arguing that crossing the border illegally does not provide immigrants with broad rights protected by the U.S. Constitution.

“No federal court has ever declared that unlawfully present aliens with no substantial ties to this country have a constitutional right to abortion on demand,” Paxton said.

Paxton, who said Doe was being held in a government-funded shelter in Brownsville, also argued that a court victory by Doe would create “a right to abortion for anyone on Earth who entered the United States illegally, no matter how briefly,” drawing additional migrants and placing Texas at risk of becoming “a sanctuary state for abortions.”

Joined by six states — Louisiana, Missouri, Nebraska, Ohio, Oklahoma and South Carolina — Paxton added that there was a larger principle at stake.

“The states have a legitimate and substantial interest in preserving and promoting fetal life, as well as an interest in promoting respect for human life at all stages in the pregnancy,” he told the judge.

Officials with the ACLU and Janes Due Process, a nonprofit that helps teenagers gain access to abortion, argue that Jane Doe’s experience is part of a larger pattern by the Office of Refugee Resettlement, which under President Donald Trump has refused to allow unaccompanied minors to receive abortions, referring them instead to crisis pregnancy centers, which counsel women against abortions, often from a religious perspective.

Despite receiving a judicial bypass from a Texas judge, which allows minors to receive an abortion if their parents are not willing or able to provide consent, Jane Doe has had to cancel two abortion appointments because federal officials refused to let her leave a government-funded shelter, said Susan Hays, legal director for Janes Due Process.

“Trump administration officials are literally holding her hostage,” ACLU lawyer Brigitte Amiri said. “The interference by government officials about the most intimate and personal decision a woman can make is horrific. It’s also blatantly unconstitutional.”

READ: 3-time Texas GOP court candidate sues Trump over foreign aid

Lawyers for the teenager argue that without court intervention, “Doe will be pushed further into her pregnancy, which increases the risks associated with the procedure, and at some point will be forced to carry to term against her will.”

Wednesday’s hearing will be in San Francisco because the ACLU is seeking to add Jane Doe’s case to an existing lawsuit challenging Trump administration contracts with U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops-affiliated agencies to provide care to unaccompanied immigrant minors.

The original lawsuit argues that the agencies are violating a federal law requiring them to provide minors with access to contraception and abortion.

Paxton, however, argued that siding with Jane Doe would have far-reaching consequences.

If the teenager is found to have a constitutional right to an abortion, Paxton argued, “it is hard to imagine why she could be denied any other constitutional rights — such as the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms,” a notion the federal courts have already rejected, he added.

“To hold that Doe enjoys a constitutional right to an abortion in this case would undermine these and others cases holding that individuals in Doe’s circumstances possess only narrow constitutional protections. The court should decline to take that dramatic step,” Paxton told the judge.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Cedar Park holding public meetings about stormwater drainage proposal
Cedar Park holding public meetings about stormwater drainage proposal

Cedar Park is holding town hall meetings about a proposal to create a stormwater drainage and street repairs program. The proposal would reallocate one-fourth of the revenue from the Economic Development Sales tax to the program, a press release from the city said. If the money was reallocated, the program would receive about $1.57 million annually...
Austin police officer fired 4 months after federal indictment
Austin police officer fired 4 months after federal indictment

An Austin police officer was fired today, four months after a federal grand jury indicted him on a charge of making a false statement to a U.S. agency in the midst of his wife’s Social Security fraud case. Officer Roosevelt Granderson II was fired, not because of the charges, but because he did not attend two separate Internal Affairs...
Police: Georgetown woman lied about income to get free healthcare
Police: Georgetown woman lied about income to get free healthcare

A Georgetown woman was accused of falsely claiming she had no income when she applied for health benefits, an arrest affidavit said. Zona Nelson, 65, was charged with theft by deception, a third-degree felony punishable by up to 10 years in prison. Officials with the Williamson County and Cities Health District told the sheriff’s office they...
Defendant called 911 after injuring boyfriend, jury hears
Defendant called 911 after injuring boyfriend, jury hears

Attorneys representing both sides in a Travis County murder trial agree Stephen Sylvester died in July 2015 at the hands of his boyfriend after they fought, following a night of drinking in downtown Austin, in the apartment they shared. But prosecutors are calling Sylvester’s boyfriend, Bryan Canchola, a jealous murderer who flipped out...
Travis DA clears officers in 3 shootings, without grand jury review
Travis DA clears officers in 3 shootings, without grand jury review

Travis County District Attorney Margaret Moore said Tuesday that she will not pursue possible charges against officers in three police shootings as part of an overhaul in how she handles such cases. Her decision to use “prosecutorial discretion” and end such investigations marks the first time in years that an Austin police officer&rsquo...
More Stories