House approves Senate’s mail-in ballot fraud bill


Under the bill, an offender could face up to 10 years in prison in some fraud cases.

The House is scheduled to take a final vote on the measure Thursday.

After more than three hours of debate Wednesday, the Texas House voted 90-37 to tentatively approve a Senate bill that would increase penalties for mail-in ballot fraud. The House is scheduled to take a final vote on the measure Thursday.

Senate Bill 5, by Sen. Kelly Hancock, R-North Richland Hills, would require a signature verification process for early ballots, notification of rejected ones within a month after an election and a process for correcting errors. Punishment for committing mail-in voter fraud in some cases could carry a penalty of up to 10 years in prison. Hancock and bill supporters have said the bill would protect the most vulnerable voters: seniors and people with disabilities.

But some House Democrats said SB 5 focuses more on penalties than solutions to fraud, and that a special session isn’t enough time to draft sound legislation. Rep. Eric Johnson, D-Dallas, called SB 5 “sloppy” and argued for a more robust conversation before moving forward on voter fraud legislation.

READ: Gov. Abbott predicts special session will create a ‘far better’ Texas

“The system needs to be reformed to make the commission of the crime impossible or more difficult to commit in the first place, not enhancing the penalty,” Johnson said.

Johnson offered an amendment that would have essentially killed SB 5. The chamber voted it down, a fate shared by all but one amendment offered by Democrats.

The House approved changes to the bill that would prohibit electronic signatures on mail-in ballot applications and repeal House Bill 658 — passed during the regular session earlier this year — which gives voting priority to people with mobility issues and makes it easier for people in residential care facilities to vote by bringing ballots and an election official to their location — if at least five voters living there request a ballot. Gov. Greg Abbott signed the bill into law in June, setting it to take effect on Sept. 1.

Rep. Craig Goldman, R-Fort Worth, who is carrying SB 5 in the House, said HB 658 is an unfunded mandate to nursing homes and similar facilities and that it would be difficult for some counties to make the accommodations for seniors and people with disabilities.

FIRST READING: This is the way the special session ends. Not with a bang but a whimper.

Under SB 5, a person could face jail time if they try to influence a vote “in the presence of the ballot or during the voting process,” a part of the bill that has drawn the most criticism from Democrats and other opponents of the bill. They argue that specific language could land people in legal jeopardy if they discuss a candidate’s qualifications to a loved one while the ballot is present. Goldman said the premise is “unrealistic,” and that the bill targets people harvesting mail-in ballots and who “knowingly and willingly” committing fraud.

“I don’t think any other family member is going to turn in their aunt or their uncle, their dad, their mother or their brother for committing fraud, if they’re sitting around the kitchen table and a ballot happens to be there, and they talk about how their going to vote,” Goldman said.

Reducing mail-in ballot fraud is one of Abbott’s 20 special session items. As lawmakers look for a solution, Dallas County is prosecuting a mail-ballot fraud case in which 700 ballots were marked as suspicious.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Smoking pot while owning guns kept Austin man in jail for eight months
Smoking pot while owning guns kept Austin man in jail for eight months

When prosecutors could not prove allegations that an Austin man planned to use his stockpile of guns for an attack on the city’s police in April, they pivoted to an obscure federal charge that kept the defendant behind bars because of two habits he has. Steven Boehle shoots guns. He also smokes pot. The combination of the two is prohibited, according...
PolitiFact: Promise to change immigrant tuition law goes broken
PolitiFact: Promise to change immigrant tuition law goes broken

Greg Abbott ran for Texas governor signaling he’d go along with disconnecting a political tripwire for Republicans that benefits college students from Texas living in the United States without legal permission. We decided to put Abbott’s statements about in-state tuition for such Texans to the PolitiFact Texas Abbott-O-Meter, which tracks...
Community news: Dougherty Arts Center closing for maintenance

TRAVIS COUNTY SOUTH AUSTIN Dougherty closing for maintenance The Dougherty Arts Center, at 1110 Barton Springs Road, will close for required routine maintenance from Monday to Friday. During this time, the business office will be closed, as well as the front of the building including the gallery, rehearsal rooms, artist resource center and theater...
Traffic report for Dec. 18, 2017

Interstate 35 (Travis County): The inside lane on the northbound access road will be closed between the Oltorf Street exit and Royal Hill Drive from 8 p.m. to 5 a.m. Monday through Thursday nights; the Oltorf Street exit (#232) will also be closed. The outside lane on the southbound access road will be closed between Reinli Street and 53½ Street...
Past Season for Caring-nominated family donates to this year’s family
Past Season for Caring-nominated family donates to this year’s family

In 2014, Wendi and Todd Noble and their daughter Avery were one of three families nominated to the Statesman Season for Caring program by nonprofit organization Wonders & Worries. At the time Todd Noble had been diagnosed with stage four non-Hodgkins lymphoma and life was emotionally and financially uncertain. The committee at the American-Statesman...
More Stories