Does a new Texas textbook whitewash Mexican-American history?


A Mexican-American studies textbook proposed for Texas high schools is a racist whitewashing of history, according to some scholars and activists, who are urging the state to find an alternative.

Concerns about the book include:

  • Simplistic treatment of Native Americans
  • Describing the Chicano movement as an effort to reconquer the United States
  • Using the term “illegal” to describe immigrants who are not authorized to be in the U.S.
  • Describing immigrant neighborhoods as riddled with crime

The book, “Mexican American Heritage,” posted for public review on the Texas Education Agency’s website, is unfit for Texas students, more than half of whom are Hispanic, said State Board of Education member Ruben Cortez Jr., D-Brownsville.

“Based on the initial conversation with these experts, I don’t believe that this book should see the inside of any classroom in any shape, form or fashion,” Cortez said. “If it’s as bad as they’re all telling me, there’s not a chance in hell I’m going to support this book.”

Other board members say they’re reserving judgment.

State Board of Education Chairwoman Donna Bahorich, R-Houston, said that she and fellow members are checking with Mexican-American studies scholars on the book, adding that it’s too early to tell if the board should write off the book.

Board member David Bradley, R-Beaumont, who opposed asking for a Mexican-American studies course and textbook, said the proposed book seems fine.

“It’s really kind of amusing. The left-leaning, radical Hispanic activists, having pounded the table for special treatment, get approval for a special course that nobody else wanted,” Bradley said. “Now they don’t like their special textbook? I bet they want everyone to also get an A for just attending? The one thing we can’t fix in this world is unhappy people.”

The textbook is the result of a divisive measure in 2014. Instead of creating a statewide Mexican-American studies course as a high school elective, the education board opted to offer districts recommended textbooks for such a course and other ethnic studies areas.

The Mexican-American textbook was the only ethnic study area book submitted for consideration.

Although textbooks in any subject that the board approves are optional for school districts, many end up adopting them instead of finding other material.

Chicanos and other issues

Trinidad Gonzales, Mexican-American studies professor at South Texas College, said that incomplete treatment of Native Americans occurs in the first chapter of the book.

Gonzales said authors neglected to mention one of the largest urban communities in the pre-Columbian U.S. was a Native American city called Cahokia, located on the Mississippi River near present-day St. Louis. Instead, the book’s description of the Plains Indians is limited to their use of tepees and their reliance on buffalo — “the Hollywood definition,” Gonzales said.

“It’s a simplistic presentation of Native American history that is very problematic, that is not based on current scholarship,” Gonzales said.

Gonzales also said the book’s statement that colonial Protestants believed in the separation of church and state is incorrect.

Among the largest problems with the book, though, according to scholars and activists, is its portrayal of Chicanos. The book’s authors said Chicanos “adopted a revolutionary narrative that opposed Western civilization and wanted to destroy this society.”

“It is appalling this textbook would claim Chicanos want to destroy society. If a student turned in this textbook as a research paper, it would be graded an F,” state Sen. José Menéndez, D-San Antonio, said in a recent statement.

Gonzales said that the Chicano movement of the 1960s and 1970s, which has spawned generations of Mexican-Americans who identify as Chicanos, was fighting for equal access to social programs created under the Great Society, “not to destroy the U.S.”

Christopher Carmona, who is a committee chairman of the Texas chapter of the National Association for Chicana and Chicano Studies, said that the discussion questions at the end of the Chicano chapter aim to penalize students if they do not interpret the historical events in a certain way.

For example, one reads, “Are Chicano Studies beneficial to Mexican-American culture? Explain. How did César Chávez challenge this vision?”

Chávez “couldn’t really get involved in the Chicano movement because he was involved in the farmworker movement,” Carmona said. “They are conflating two things that have nothing to do with each other, and they are bringing them together to form an answer: The Chicano movement is bad. That’s what they want you to say.”

The authors also repeatedly use the term “illegal immigrants” in reference to those who immigrate to the country illegally. The book also says that “crime and exploitation can circulate unabated in their neighborhoods.”

“We’re talking about human beings,” said Gonzales. “Calling individuals illegal is very problematic and very un-American.”

A call and email to the publisher of the textbook, Momentum Instruction, were not returned.

According to the left-leaning Texas Freedom Network, which typically analyzes social studies textbooks submitted to the state, the authors of the book — Jaime Riddle and Valarie Angle — have backgrounds in education but not specifically in Mexican-American studies.

Riddle’s online professional profile on LinkedIn says that she is a “professional developer of conservative instructional content.”

Rise of ethnic studies

Almost all Mexican-American studies courses offered in seven Texas school districts are college-level classes that were established in the last few years, Carmona said. He said the growing interest in the course is in response to the xenophobic treatment of Mexican-Americans as well as a link between student performance and ethnic studies.

A 2014 study in Tucson, Ariz., found that Latino students who took such a course were more likely to graduate and do better on state standardized tests. University of Arizona researchers conducted the study after the Arizona government —arguing that the curriculum was too political — eliminated the Tucson school district’s Mexican-American studies program in 2010.

Carmona said that the recent textbook controversy, along with presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump’s comments about Hispanics, will only serve to stoke interest in Mexican-American studies.

Three hundred people have signed up for this year’s summit on June 18 to implement Mexican-American studies in Texas public schools — a far cry from the 50 people who have attended the summit in the past.

The Austin school district, which educates about 50,000 Hispanic students, is considering offering ethnic studies, including Mexican-American studies, said Paul Saldaña, vice president of the school board.

Mexican-American students “are able to see themselves reflected in the curriculum, and it gives them more confidence and drive to educate themselves, whereas before they were lost in the system,” Carmona said.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Giving City: Need cited for providing foster parent info in Spanish
Giving City: Need cited for providing foster parent info in Spanish

For Spanish-speakers in the Austin area seeking to foster or adopt a child in the care of the state, there are very limited opportunities to do so. That’s because the required information and training sessions here are not offered in Spanish. In fact, Austin is the only region in Texas that does not offer the required information in Spanish....
NOW: More than 100 students walk out of Austin middle school, demanding stricter gun laws
NOW: More than 100 students walk out of Austin middle school, demanding stricter gun laws

10:15 a.m. update: More than 100 students walked out of Bailey Middle School on Friday morning calling for stricter gun laws. The students filtered out of the school chanting, “we can make a change” and “save our schools.” Some carried signs, including one that says “17 killed, 40 hurt,” in reference...
SOUTHEAST AUSTIN: SWAT responding to possibly armed person in Montopolis
SOUTHEAST AUSTIN: SWAT responding to possibly armed person in Montopolis

9:50 a.m. update: Austin police say a man has barricaded himself in the 6900 block of Villita Avenida in Southeast Austin and may be armed. SWAT units were at the scene in the Montopolis neighborhood, and other officers have secured the area, police said. Earlier: Austin police are searching for a person who could be armed after a reported disturbance...
Heavy rain prompts New Braunfels to close Comal River for recreation
Heavy rain prompts New Braunfels to close Comal River for recreation

New Braunfels officials have banned recreational use on the Comal River there after heavy rains pummeled Central Texas early Friday. “This closure will remain in effect until further notice,” the city of New Braunfels said in a statement. Authorities cited high water flow rates and said water was flowing over the Tube Chute Dam. &ldquo...
Middletown school on lockdown after student acts suspicious
Middletown school on lockdown after student acts suspicious

A Middletown high school is on lockdown this morning. A notice from Bishop Fenwick High School this morning states: “Bishop Fenwick High School is currently on a ‘soft lockdown.’ This means that teaching continues in the building, but no one will be permitted in or out of the building until the lockdown is lifted. Everyone is safe...
More Stories