Austin follows through on lawsuit to block ‘sanctuary cities’ ban


Highlights

The city of Austin filed suit Friday to join onto a suit filed Thursday against Senate Bill 4.

Multiple lawsuits now challenge the state’s ability to create so-called immigration law.

The suits also allege SB 4 violates numerous other provisions in the Constitution.

The city of Austin followed through on a promise to challenge the state’s controversial “sanctuary cities” ban on Friday with a court filing that now unites it with the city of San Antonio and numerous advocacy groups in their fight to block Senate Bill 4 before it takes effect.

Calling Austin’s public safety a political football state lawmakers kicked around the Capitol that ultimately resulted in a dangerous law, Austin Mayor Steve Adler said it was time to move the fight to a different venue.

“We want our day in court,” Adler said.

SB 4 creates civil and criminal penalties for police and elected officials — including arrest or removal from office — if they block cooperation with federal requests to detain jail inmates suspected of being in the country illegally. It also allows police to inquire about a person’s immigration status during routine police encounters, such as traffic stops.

Gov. Greg Abbott signed the bill last month and Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton sued Austin hours later in what many saw as a pre-emptive strike to have a judge declare the law constitutional. Though Austin was destined to defend itself in federal court over SB 4, joining San Antonio’s suit against the law allows the cities to argue it should be blocked.

Austin’s legal challenge, which the City Council voted to pursue last month, takes the form of a “complaint in intervention” that allows the city to join a suit that San Antonio filed in federal court on Thursday. The city and county of El Paso have sued along with the town of El Cenizo, Maverick County and numerous advocacy groups.

As the legal challenges to SB 4 have rolled in, a consensus of arguments against the law is beginning to emerge.

The central challenge in both Austin and San Antonio’s filings has been against the state’s ability to create immigration laws, a power the U.S. Constitution reserves for the federal government in part so foreign governments don’t end up dealing with a patchwork of immigration laws.

That part of the Constitution was cited in a 2012 Supreme Court ruling that blocked several parts of Arizona’s Senate Bill 1070, a law with a section similar to SB 4’s “show me your papers” provision that empowers local law enforcement to inquire about a person’s immigration status during routine interactions.

The lawsuits also say SB 4 violates the Fourth Amendment because it could lead to jail detentions for immigration violations, which are civil infractions, not criminal offenses. The cities also argue that SB 4 might violate elected officials’ First Amendment rights because it bars them from endorsing sanctuary policies, a provision critics believe is overly vague.

Several 14th Amendment violations are alleged along with claims that the law would encourage racial profiling and discrimination.

“The result of the threatened implementation of SB 4 has been a breakdown in public trust, as affected individuals feel they cannot contact municipal and nongovernmental agencies for fear of immigration enforcement,” Austin’s suit said.

The city’s filing on Friday states that Austin would suffer economic harm if the bill is allowed to take effect. The city could see a drop in international tourism for the South by Southwest Festival and Circuit of the Americas events because visitors might fear enhanced immigration enforcement measures, the filing says. The state could also face boycotts like Arizona did after that state passed its controversial law in 2010.

The Austin filing also states that local policing could suffer. It posits that a police officer might be forced under the law to assist federal immigration authorities performing operations in Austin while a more urgent public safety matter might be unfolding because the law prohibits local police from refusing to assist federal authorities in any instance.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

UPDATE: San Antonio murder suspect has been shot, toddler unharmed
UPDATE: San Antonio murder suspect has been shot, toddler unharmed

11:57 a.m. update: San Antonio police say homicide suspect Richard Concepcion is being treated for a self-inflicted gunshot wound and he is in grave condition. The 18-month-old child was found in backseat of truck unharmed in Guadalupe County. Earlier: A man suspected of murdering a woman and then taking their 18-month-old child is being pursued by...
McConnell rejects Trump's suggestion to use 'nuclear option' to break budget impasse
McConnell rejects Trump's suggestion to use 'nuclear option' to break budget impasse

On day two of the U.S. government shutdown, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said Republicans would not adopt President Donald Trump’s call for a “nuclear option” to pass a budget with a simple majority, The New York Daily News reported Sunday. “The Republican Conference opposes changing the rules on legislation,&rdquo...
Several congressmen will donate pay during shutdown
Several congressmen will donate pay during shutdown

Led by Rep. John Delaney of Maryland, several members of Congress asked for their pay to be withheld during the government shutdown, CNN reported. “I don't think it's right for me to get paid during a government shutdown while my constituents are being furloughed and important and necessary services are being limited or halted all together...
Firemen: Child igniting paper on space heater starts fire at Orlando apartment complex
Firemen: Child igniting paper on space heater starts fire at Orlando apartment complex

At least 48 people were displaced after a fire at a Florida apartment complex Saturday morning, the Orlando Fire Department said.  Firefighters said no one was injured in the fire that broke out at the Windsor Cove apartments in Orlando around 10 a.m. Fire investigators said a child igniting paper on a space heater caused the blaze....
UT POLICE: Man pulled down woman’s underwear near campus Sunday morning
UT POLICE: Man pulled down woman’s underwear near campus Sunday morning

University of Texas police are searching for a man who pulled down a female student’s pants and underwear Sunday morning. According to the UTPD Twitter account, a woman was walking near Tyler’s in the 2300 block of Guadalupe Street when a man approached her from behind and pulled down her pants and underwear. The man then fled the scene...
More Stories