Appeals court ruling delays abortion for immigrant teen in Texas


Highlights

Appeals court ruling means teen, 15 weeks pregnant, must cancel weekend appointment at abortion clinic.

Trump administration says it should not be forced to help teenager in federal custody have an abortion.

A federal appeals court Friday dissolved a lower court order that required the Trump administration to allow an abortion for a 17-year-old immigrant who is in federal custody in Texas after illegally crossing the border with Mexico.

The U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia gave administration officials until Oct. 31 to find a relative or other qualified adult willing to act as the teen’s sponsor in the United States — removing her from federal custody and allowing her access to an abortion she has been fighting more than three weeks to get.

If no sponsor is found by Oct. 31, the lower court could reissue its order directing federal officials to stop blocking the teenager from receiving an abortion. If so, however, the Justice Department could appeal again, Friday’s 2-1 ruling said.

The delay means the teen, 15 weeks pregnant and identified only as Jane Doe or JD, will have to cancel a weekend appointment at a Texas abortion clinic and could further complicate her attempts to have an abortion, lawyers said.

In oral arguments before the appeals court Friday morning, a Justice Department lawyer said the government’s interest in promoting childbirth over abortion allows federal officials to avoid any actions that would allow Doe to have an abortion.

“The government is refusing to facilitate an abortion, which it is permitted to do,” said the lawyer, Catherine Dorsey.

READ: Poll: 49% of Texans disapprove of Trump, but GOP support strong

But Doe’s lawyer argued that government officials are enforcing illegal “veto power” over the teen’s decision to exercise her constitutional right to an abortion.

“They are supplanting their decision about what JD should do with her pregnancy, and that is not acting in her best interest,” said Brigitte Amiri, a lawyer with the American Civil Liberties Union.

If allowed, the abortion would be paid for with private money, the ACLU has said.

Doe’s case has drawn national attention, serving as a proxy battle over two hot-button issues — the right to abortion and federal immigration policy.

Abortion rights advocates blasted Friday’s decision.

“The anti-choice GOP is using this young woman as a pawn for their extremist ideology,” NARAL President Ilyse Hogue said. “The Trump administration is holding Jane Doe hostage and forcing her to remain pregnant against her will.”

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, an outspoken opponent of abortion, said he was disappointed that the court left open an avenue for Doe to seek an abortion, adding that the ruling could provide an incentive for other pregnant immigrants to travel to Texas for the procedure.

“Texas must not become a sanctuary state for abortions,” he said.

On Wednesday, a federal district judge ordered officials with the Office of Refugee Resettlement to let Doe leave her government-financed shelter to get an abortion Friday or Saturday.

At the Trump administration’s request, the appeals court halted that order on Thursday to allow time for oral arguments, although Doe was allowed to attend her Thursday pre-abortion counseling session, which under Texas law must take place at least 24 hours before the procedure.

READ: Attorney General Sessions hails anti-sanctuary cities law in Texas

The Trump administration’s lawyer argued Friday that federal officials were not standing in Doe’s way by failing to “facilitate” her access to abortion because she has two options for leaving federal custody — she could voluntarily leave the country or she could be placed with a sponsor, typically a relative, who is already in the United States.

“The government is not preventing, blocking or imposing any (impermissible) obstacle on Miss Doe’s pursuit of an abortion here,” Dorsey said.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh latched onto the sponsor option, noting that it would allow the court to avoid a sticky constitutional question and get Doe out of federal custody, giving her access to an abortion while saving government officials from having to approve the procedure.

Lawyers on both sides, however, could not answer whether a sponsor could be found quickly enough, although the Justice Department lawyer said that Doe identified two relatives — one who declined to be a sponsor, while the other is a single man, raising concerns for her safety.

Justice Patricia Millett — the only member of the court panel appointed by a Democrat, President Barack Obama — dissented, saying Friday’s action will add weeks to Doe’s pregnancy.

“Forcing her to continue an unwanted pregnancy just in the hopes of finding a sponsor that has not been found in the past six weeks sacrifices JD’s constitutional liberty, autonomy and personal dignity for no justifiable governmental reason,” Millett wrote.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

George P. Bush outraises GOP primary opponent Patterson
George P. Bush outraises GOP primary opponent Patterson

Texas Land Commissioner George P. Bush, facing a Republican primary challenge from Jerry Patterson, the man who formerly held his post, significantly outraised his opponent in the last half of 2017, campaign finance reports filed this week show. Bush’s campaign raised $1 million, leaving him with almost $3.4 million in the bank at the end of...
We knew this already: Buc-ee’s is officially the best gas station 
We knew this already: Buc-ee’s is officially the best gas station 

Huge, super-clean bathrooms. Fresh sandwiches. Pajama pants covered in little beavers. Home decor. Awesome snacks. Really big car washes. Texans know where it’s at when it comes to gas stations, and Buc-ee’s is the best of the best. We knew this already. This is nothing new.  But now it’s official. GasBuddy listed Buc-ee&rsquo...
Are you the cutest couple in Austin? Enter the 2018 Cutest Couples Contest
Are you the cutest couple in Austin? Enter the 2018 Cutest Couples Contest

Are your friends constantly telling you how cute you and your significant other are? Do they say, “Oh, gross” when you smooch at brunch? Do they tell you to “get a room” when you gaze at each other lovingly over happy hour beers? Do you think you’re pretty cute, too?  Let’s put it to the test. We&rsquo...
Austin grows up: Statesman graphic from the 80s details ‘skyscraper boom’
Austin grows up: Statesman graphic from the 80s details ‘skyscraper boom’

People have been yelling “When did that get there?!” in Austin longer than you’d think. Reddit user Meetybeefy posted a graphic to the news aggregation site, which is stamped as having been printed in the Statesman on Oct. 21, 1984, that shows the planned downtown projects set to “stretch [the] skyline.” And even...
Slaughter Lane overpass in South Austin reopens early after deadly crash
Slaughter Lane overpass in South Austin reopens early after deadly crash

Austin police have reopened an elevated portion of Slaughter Lane in South Austin ahead of schedule after a fatal crash on Tuesday evening. Police shut down all traffic in the 1500 block of West Slaughter Lane after a pickup tumbled off a roughly 30-foot high bridge just east of Manchaca Road on Tuesday evening. Authorities at the time of the incident...
More Stories