Appeals court declines bid to speed voter ID ruling


Highlights

Those challenging the voter ID law hoped having all 14 appellate judges on the case would speed resolution.

Texas and Trump administration officials opposed the request, supporting the customary three-judge panel.

A federal appeals court Tuesday declined to have all 14 judges participate in the appeal over the Texas voter ID law — a decision that will keep the issue unresolved heading into the 2018 elections, one judge said.

Civil rights groups, Democrats and minority voters who challenged the voter ID law as discriminatory had asked for the entire court to hear the appeal as a way to speed the case toward resolution.

The 10-4 ruling by the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, however, means the appeal will be heard by the customary three-judge panel.

Writing in dissent, Justice Jerry Smith noted that the losing side will probably ask the entire court to review the panel’s decision in what is known as “en banc” consideration — a path the 5th Circuit Court took at an earlier stage of the case that, if taken again, would make it “impossible for a decision to be issued before some, if not all, of the 2018 elections are history,” he said.

READ: Austin judge blocks release of Texas voter data to Trump panel

“The lopsided vote to deny en banc hearing shows that the court has little appetite for disposing of this important case in advance of the beginning of the 2018 election cycle,” Smith wrote.

“The elephant in the room is Texas’s 2018 election schedule, which includes statewide primaries on March 6 (with early voting beginning February 20), municipal elections May 5 (early voting April 22), primary runoffs May 22 (early voting May 14), and the general election November 6 (early voting October 22),” Smith wrote.

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton and President Donald Trump’s Justice Department opposed en banc review of the appeal, filed after U.S. District Judge Nelva Gonzales Ramos of Corpus Christi tossed out the state’s voter ID law in August. Ramos ruled that changes adopted by the Legislature in May did not fix a law that was drafted by Republicans in the Legislature to discriminate against minority voters, who tend to favor Democrats and are less likely to have acceptable identification.

Under the recently passed Senate Bill 5, a registered voter who lacks a required photo ID can cast a ballot after showing documents that list a name and address, including a voter registration certificate, utility bill, bank statement or paycheck.

Such voters would have to sign a “declaration of reasonable impediment” stating that they couldn’t acquire a photo ID due to a lack of transportation, lack of a birth certificate, work schedule, disability, illness, family responsibility, or lost or stolen ID.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

Paxton argued that the looser standards protected voting rights and cured any problems with the voter ID law that was originally passed in 2011. The U.S. Justice Department agreed.

In her August ruling, Ramos acknowledged that SB 5 was an improvement because voters could present additional forms of ID, but the judge also wrote that the change “does not eliminate the discrimination” that continued to impose undue burdens on Latino and African-American voters.

Last month, however, a 5th Circuit Court panel ruled 2-1 that Texas can keep using its voter ID law while the Texas appeal proceeds.



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Texas family's Christmas light show pays tribute to Selena
Texas family's Christmas light show pays tribute to Selena

A Texas family is paying tribute to the late singer Selena with a light show set to one of her songs, WFAA reported. Beto Hinojosa of Boerne has been doing light shows in front of his home for four years. This year, he decided to add the Selena song, “Bidi Bidi Bom Bom.” Hinojosa, a principal in the Boerne school district, said he...
Sarah Palin's oldest son arrested on domestic violence charges
Sarah Palin's oldest son arrested on domestic violence charges

Track Palin, the oldest son of former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, was arraigned Sunday on domestic violence charges, according to online court records. Palin was arraigned on charges of felony burglary, assault in the fourth degree and criminal mischief for causing property damage in Wasilla, Alaska, according to court records. The criminal mischief charge...
California father continues Christmas tradition to honor late daughter
California father continues Christmas tradition to honor late daughter

For 19 years, a California man has decorated his home for Christmas and has invited community members to visit. The holiday display is a tribute to a daughter he lost in a plane crash. Bob Taylor oldest daughter died in the plane crash. “She loved Christmas,” Taylor told KRON. ” I mean, that was her favorite time of the year...
Sen. John McCain will miss tax bill vote
Sen. John McCain will miss tax bill vote

Sen. John McCain will not be in Washington when Congress votes on the Republican tax bill this week, CNN reported Sunday. The Arizona Republican returned to his home state Sunday to continue recovering from the side effects of chemotherapy for a brain tumor, two sources confirmed to CNN. The senator’s daughter, Meghan McCain, confirmed in...
Four-legged 'Santa' a savior during Battle of the Bulge
Four-legged 'Santa' a savior during Battle of the Bulge

Tucked between dollar bills, nestled next to a black-and-white photograph of his wife Gloria, Stan Saltz pulls out a second snapshot, the one of him as a 19-year-old Army private and survivor of the bloodiest battle in the second World War. But the photo isn’t about the Florida resident. It’s about the German shepherd, a four-legged...
More Stories