Abbott call for Convention of States clears first hurdle in the Senate


Highlights

Gov. Greg Abbott’s emergency call for a resolution seeking a Convention of States was approved in committee.

The vote was party-line but Republicans also voiced concern for the perils of a new constitutional convention.

The resolution likely will find less enthusiasm in the House.

Gov. Greg Abbott’s emergency item, calling for a national Convention of States to amend the U.S. Constitution, cleared its first hurdle Thursday, with the Senate State Affairs Committee sending the resolution to the floor on a 6-2 party-line vote.

“We are on the precipice of history we have not seen before,” said Sen. Brian Birdwell, R-Granbury, the lead Senate sponsor, arguing that the convention was needed because the “federal government has been usurping state power,” leaving the states little more than “subcontractors.” A new Convention of States to amend the U.S. Constitution under a process envisaged by Article V of the Constitution is critical to restore the states to their rightful place in the federal system, Birdwell said.

In order to avoid a runaway convention, Birdwell said that under Senate Joint Resolution 2, the only amendments that could be considered would be ones “to impose fiscal restraints on the federal government, to limit the power and jurisdiction of the federal government and to limit the terms of office of federal officials and members of Congress.”

TEXAS POLITICS DELIVERED EVERY DAY: Sign up for our Texas Politics email

Sen. Bryan Hughes, R-Mineola, said it was imperative that the call for the convention be drawn as narrowly as possible, but “that shouldn’t stop us from moving forward carefully.”

One Republican, Sen. Jane Nelson, of Flower Mound, said that while she wanted the full Senate to consider the legislation, “I still have concerns.”

“Both sides include patriots who love our country,” Nelson said. “We need to be very, very cautious and move slowly.”

The House Select Committee on State and Federal Power and Responsibility, which will consider the legislation and includes Republicans who have previously opposed the Convention of States, may do just that.

Anthony Gutierrez, executive director of Common Cause Texas, who testified against SJR 2, described a Convention of States as “one of the most dangerous ideas in American politics today,” without precedent, certain rules or predictable outcomes.

The legislatures in 34 states would have to call for a convention for it to occur.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

Birdwell said that as of now, eight states have called for the convention, and in 16 other states, one legislative house has called for it. Most states are considering resolutions.

State Sen. Craig Estes, R-Wichita Falls, the most adamant foe of the call for a convention in the last session, was ill and not present for Thursday’s vote, but sent no signal that he intends to block one of the four emergency items Abbott announced in his State of the State Address. A former attorney general and state Supreme Court justice, Abbott devoted much of his 2016 book, “Broken but Unbowed,” to making the case for calling the convention to cut the federal government down to size.

The committee also voted 8-0 to send to the floor SJR 38, authored by Estes, rescinding all previous applications for an Article V convention made by the Texas Legislature to the U.S. Congress over more than a century.

Tamara Colbert, spokesman for the formal organization calling for the Convention of States, told the lawmakers they were submitting into the record petitions with 24,000 signatures calling for the convention, which has mostly generated enthusiasm on the right, though that is by no means a unanimous view.

“I beg this committee and this Legislature not to open this Pandora’s box on this nation, just for the dream of some minor tweaking our Constitution may need,” said Michael Openshaw of Plano, the founder of the North Texas Tea Party, who warned that a convention could be taken over by well-heeled, well-organized liberals, and conservatives might “end up with the destruction of the rights we currently do have.”



Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Texas News & Politics

CANCHOLA TRIAL: Murder charge tossed after medical examiner’s flip-flop
CANCHOLA TRIAL: Murder charge tossed after medical examiner’s flip-flop

A man who is suspected of beating his boyfriend to death no longer faces several felony charges, including a murder charge, after a Travis County judge tossed out the bulk of a medical examiner’s controversial testimony on Monday. State district Judge David Wahlberg reversed his ruling from last week, announcing statements given from the witness...
Man offered $25k to kill ex-girlfriend, sheriff’s office says

TRAVIS COUNTY Officials: Man offered $25k to kill ex-girlfriend Travis County sheriff’s deputies on Monday arrested a man accused of trying to hire an acquaintance to kill his ex-girlfriend. Keith James Cote has been charged with criminal solicitation (to commit capital murder), according to the sheriff’s office. Cote offered someone $10...
Despite dropped charges, four Democrats to challenge Rep. Dawnna Dukes
Despite dropped charges, four Democrats to challenge Rep. Dawnna Dukes

Following Travis County prosecutors’ decision on Monday to drop all charges in the corruption case against her, state Rep. Dawnna Dukes is now out of legal trouble — but she’s not yet out of political trouble. Four Democrats who had previously said they plan to run for Dukes’ heavily Democratic House District 46 confirmed Monday...
Poll finds most Texans think DACA program should be extended
Poll finds most Texans think DACA program should be extended

Nearly 60 percent of Texans want to extend the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals program, which protects from deportation some 124,000 Texans who arrived as children and remained in the country illegally, according to results of the University of Texas/Texas Tribune poll released Monday. Answering a separate question, slightly more than half oppose...
Murder trial begins in Sixth Street shootings that killed 1, injured 4
Murder trial begins in Sixth Street shootings that killed 1, injured 4

A trial begins this week for a man accused of firing shots into a Sixth Street crowd around closing time, killing a woman and wounding four other people. Endicott McCray, 26, was aiming for his brother-in-law but missed and instead shot five others, including Teqnika Marie Moultrie, who was in town visiting her wife’s family and died of a head...
More Stories