Abbott advises Hispanic Texans not to fall for `fearmongering’ on SB 4


Gov. Greg Abbott said the ‘sanctuary cities’ ban won’t hurt those who stay out of trouble.

But opponents of the new law say it is an invitation for police to engage in racial profiling.

The memorial service for Texas Rangers and state troopers who have been killed in the line of duty had ended Tuesday when a reporter for Univision 62, the Austin station for the Spanish-language network, asked Gov. Greg Abbott if he could say anything that might allay the fears of Hispanic Texans worried about the “sanctuary cities” ban he recently signed into law.

“My message to the Hispanic community is don’t fall for all of the fearmongering that’s going on,” Abbott replied. “If you look at the details of Senate Bill 4, it does not pose any concern for anybody who’s not a criminal. If you’re a criminal and you’ve done something wrong, yes, whether you’re here legally or illegally, you’ve got something to be concerned about. If not, you’ve got nothing to be concerned about.”

But Democratic lawmakers, lawyers and activists who passionately opposed the legislation found cold comfort in the governor’s assurance.

“Either he hasn’t read the bill or he misunderstands it,” said state Rep. Rafael Anchia, D-Dallas, a leading opponent who had beseeched Abbott to contemplate his Catholic faith and his wife’s Hispanic ancestry before affixing his signature to the legislation.

LIKE US ON FACEBOOK: Our Lone Star Politics page brings Capitol news to your Facebook feed

But Rep. Jason Villalba, Anchia’s Dallas colleague and one of only three Hispanic Republicans in a Legislature in which every Republican voted in favor of SB 4, said he thought Abbott’s soothing words were reasonable and appropriate.

“I tend to think he’s right,” Villalba said. “This bill is a law-and-order, commonsense measure that say that cities and other jurisdictions cannot refuse to enforce existing federal law.”

“That’s all it says,” said Villalba, adding it was something that the overwhelming majority of Texans of all backgrounds support.

Defending SB 4

In the aftermath of Abbott signing the law on May 7, the American Civil Liberties Union issued a “travel alert” for Texas.

“The law gives a green light to police officers in the state to investigate a person’s immigration status during a routine traffic stop, leading to widespread racial profiling, baseless scrutiny, and illegal arrests of citizens and non-citizens alike presumed to be ‘foreign’ based on how they look or sound,” the ACLU said in a statement.

Villalba called that “the height of disingenuousness.”

“Everything that is said about ‘show me your papers’ is flat-out false,” Abbott said Tuesday. “The only way that anybody can ever be detained is if there is probable cause to detain someone.”

TEXAS POLITICS DELIVERED EVERY DAY: Sign up for our Texas Politics email

But Jose Garza, a San Antonio attorney who advises the Mexican American Legislative Caucus, said the only way one wouldn’t think that this law would lead to racial profiling is if one were willfully blind to Texas history.

“In Texas, we have a history of the Latino community having been at odds with law enforcement,” Garza said. “I’m not saying that all law enforcement is out to target Latinos, but I think this gives police the license to target Latinos. I don’t think it’s hyperbole. I think it’s a real threat.”

Under the law, police can inquire about a person’s immigration status if that person has been detained for crimes as minor as jaywalking and speeding, even if the suspect hasn’t been arrested. Democrats, and a few Republicans, including Villalba, wanted a higher standard, in which a person had to be arrested to have to answer questions about immigration status.

‘A racist law’

In the end, what started out as a law intended to bring to heel “sanctuary city policies” in which certain jurisdictions choose not to cooperate fully with federal immigration law, now, with that provision, applies broadly across the state and might place individuals who aren’t authorized to be in the country — and their families, including children who are often American-born citizens — on high alert for any interaction with police that could end with their detection and deportation.

“It’s a racist law,” said Sheridan Aguirre, a University of Texas graduate and spokesman for United We Dream, an organization of young people who lack legal immigration status. Aguirre was part of a Capitol press conference Tuesday at which county commissioners, state legislators and grassroots organizations from the five largest metropolitan areas in Texas launched a coordinated effort to support litigation challenging SB 4.

The Austin City Council is expected to formally join that effort later this week.

But, Abbott said in his remarks, “The people who have gotten this right are the Hidalgo County sheriff and the McAllen police chief. These are people on the border. They are men, both of whom are Hispanic, and they’ve got communities with a high-percentage Hispanic population, and they both said the exact right thing. This law is not going to change a thing about the way they do their business.

“If there hasn’t been a problem in the past, there won’t be a problem in the future, except for those who are here illegally and have committed a crime,” Abbott said.

But state Rep. Poncho Nevárez, D-Eagle Pass, said Abbott’s comments about the law suggest that he wants to reap the political benefit of SB 4 without incurring any of the backlash from those who might be hurt by it.

“He wants the cheese, but he doesn’t want to be stuck in the trap,” Nevárez said. “He needs to own it.”

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Texas News & Politics

Police: Maine man punches himself in face to avoid sobriety test 
Police: Maine man punches himself in face to avoid sobriety test 

Police have accused a Maine man of punching himself several times in the face to avoid a Breathalyzer test, The Bangor Daily News reported. Police suspected Brian Fogg, 27, of Belfast, to be intoxicated when they were called to a residence on Jan. 13 and found Fogg’s vehicle stuck in a ditch, police said. Belfast police said Fogg and...
FORECAST: Patchy fog in morning followed by sunshine
FORECAST: Patchy fog in morning followed by sunshine

A winter reprieve is finally here. Saturday will bring patchy fog before noon, then sunshine, according to the National Weather Service. The service warns that there may be dense fog, which could decrease visibility. Visibility is still less than a mile for most places along Interstate 35 and areas east and south of there. The day, which will begin...
THE LATEST: Activist Alexei Wood arrested at Austin anti-Trump rally
THE LATEST: Activist Alexei Wood arrested at Austin anti-Trump rally

1 p.m. update: The activist who was arrested during this morning’s rally at Austin City Hall is Alexei Wood, one of the six defendants who were acquitted last month of causing rioting and destroying property during President Donald Trump’s 2017 inauguration. Wood was charged Saturday with theft from a person after a dustup at the Austin...
College student dies after on-campus shooting at Wake Forest
College student dies after on-campus shooting at Wake Forest

A 21-year-old student from Winston-Salem State University was shot and killed early Saturday after a fight broke out during a party at Wake Forest University, police said. The shooting occurred around 1 a.m., WXII reported. It took place on campus during a Delta Sigma Theta sorority party at The Barn, police said. Najee Ali Baker, 21, was...
Pizza shop owner sues when store confused for one where assault occurred
Pizza shop owner sues when store confused for one where assault occurred

A Pennsylvania pizza shop is being targeted, but its owner says it is a case of mistaken identity. Customers upset about a viral video in which a former manager allegedly assaulted a woman have been calling Original Milano's in Oakland -- but the video was taken at Pizza Milano. Ben Sciulli is the owner of the Original Milano's Pizza. He wants to make...
More Stories