Even court officials find fees hard to untangle


Because of the Legislature's tinkering, the matrix of fees, fines and costs criminal defendants face has grown into an administrative thicket that even people who see it every day can find baffling.

"Sometimes I can't even tell my client what the bill is for," said David Gonzales, an Austin defense attorney.

The Office of Court Administration fields "hundreds of calls a year from trial court officials about how to assess and prioritize fines, fees, and surcharges in criminal cases," the agency wrote in a 2009 report.

The report concluded, "The sprawling number of state and local fees and court costs that state law prescribes as a result of a criminal conviction amounts to a nearly incomprehensible package."

The system can also be unfair. Courts across the state can assess the myriad costs and fees in different ways, so "the court costs a defendant must pay can vary for the exact same offense," the report said.

Everyone convicted of a crime starts with a "consolidated court cost." The more severe the crime, the higher the fee. Felons owe $133, lesser criminals $40.

After that, there are six other fees levied against every convict, including assessments for "records management," a "clerks fee," a "county and district court technology fund" and a "courthouse security fee."

Defendants then can be dinged for dozens of other costs, depending on the crime and jurisdiction. Dense charts compiled by the Office of Court Administration show three dozen possible costs and fees.

Those arrested on a warrant must pay a $50 fee; those arrested without one pay $5. Those who go to jail pay $5 when they enter jail and $5 when they leave. DWI defendants can be assessed a "visual recording fee" to cover the cost of videotaping their arrests. Sex criminals pay a $250 DNA fee.

There are even fees on fees, which critics say disproportionately punish the poor. Defendants pay a $25 fee if they need to set up a schedule to pay all their other fees. They can be charged a $12 "restitution installment fee" if they need to pay their court-ordered victims restitution over time and then a $2 "transaction fee" every time they make an individual payment.

In 2009 and again in 2011, the Texas Judicial Council, which makes policy for the state's courts, passed resolutions urging the Legislature to simplify the costs and fees, without success.

The current system of criminal court costs, said Sharon Keller, presiding judge of the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals, is "a messy closet that needs to be tidied up."

Contact: 445-1774


Reader Comments ...


Next Up in Featured

A handful of hep Hammer horror movies for Halloween
A handful of hep Hammer horror movies for Halloween

From the 1950s to the 1970s, the British film studio Hammer Films made some of the best horror pictures in the Western world. With over the top scripts, lush gothic colors and beautiful women, Hammer horror influenced everygenre from sci-fi (George Lucas would not have cast Peter Cushing as the Grand Moff Tarkin without the latter’s run in dozens...
On the Texas coast, a hurricane recovery haunted by the past
On the Texas coast, a hurricane recovery haunted by the past

Between the beaches of Port Aransas and the vacation rentals of Port O’Connor, the Texas coast is filled with small towns that suffered massive damage in Hurricane Harvey. For some, the hurricane will forever alter the course of their future: Already in Bayside (pop. 333, and falling), at least eight families, close to 10 percent of the population...
It’s the first day of fall in Austin! This means nothing!
It’s the first day of fall in Austin! This means nothing!

Today is Sept. 22 in the year of our Lord 2017. According to the calendar, it is the first day of autumn. Which means, according to popular imagination, golden-brown leaves falling from trees; crisp, cool air; everyone in sweaters or jackets; and the anticipation of Halloween and Thanksgiving. Except in Austin.  Austin does not have autumn. At...
How to watch last night’s Emmy-winning shows
How to watch last night’s Emmy-winning shows

The big question after watching the Emmys every year is, “How can I, the humble viewer, watch all of this incredible TV, even when the season for said TV is over?” Here is your answer, in no particular order. “Atlanta” The stunning FX comedy picked up two of three awards for which it was nominated. Not only did Donald Glover...
Wedding album lost during Harvey recovered
Wedding album lost during Harvey recovered

Much of the time, we, the people, look at the Internet and think, “Why, Lord, why?” Even when (with a little Google-fu) we are able to listen to pretty much every piece of recorded music in human history, it doesn’t change the fact that the Internet has made the basest, most destructive impulses of humanity as public as humanly possible...
More Stories