You have reached your limit of free articles this month.

Enjoy unlimited access to

Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks.


  • ePAPER

You have read of premium articles.

Get unlimited access to all of our breaking news, in-depth coverage and bonus content- exclusively for subscribers. Starting at just 99¢ for 8 weeks


Welcome to

This subscriber-only site gives you exclusive access to breaking news, in-depth coverage, exclusive interactives and bonus content.

You can read free articles of your choice a month that are only available on

Senator vows to expand DNA testing in innocence claims

Arguing that the state’s highest criminal court watered down a law designed to free innocent people from prison, a state senator vowed Wednesday to introduce, and pass, legislation allowing for expanded DNA testing of crime-scene evidence.

Sen. Rodney Ellis, D-Houston, said a February ruling by the Court of Criminal Appeals interpreted the 2011 law too narrowly, “making it difficult for folks to secure DNA testing that can prove their innocence and identify actual perpetrators.”

“This decision, respectfully, is out of touch with tremendous advances in science that we’ve made in regard to DNA testing,” he said.

In its February ruling, the appeals court unanimously denied DNA testing for death row inmate Larry Swearingen, ruling that his lawyers had not established that there was biological material on several items Swearingen wanted to test, including pantyhose used to strangle the victim, Conroe college student Melissa Trotter.

The ruling leaves inmates in a catch-22 — unable to get DNA testing unless they can prove the existence of biological material that cannot be revealed without testing, said Michael Morton, who was exonerated by DNA evidence in 2011 after 25 years in prison.

It is “an impossible bar to meet,” said Morton, who joined Ellis at a Capitol news conference Wednesday.

Barry Scheck, co-director of the Innocence Project of New York and one of Morton’s lawyers, said modern tests can identify DNA from skin cells and sweat transferred onto items of clothing, including the pantyhose from the Swearingen case.

Knowing who touched a murder weapon “would be an important, critical clue in a criminal case, particularly post-conviction if you want to prove somebody innocent. But just by looking … I can’t tell whether there’s enough biological material here to get the result one would need from the DNA test — until I actually test it.”

Similar tests on a bandana led to Morton’s exoneration and identified Mark Alan Norwood, who has since been convicted in the 1986 murder of Morton’s wife, Christine, in their Williamson County home.

In 2011, the Legislature overwhelmingly approved an Ellis measure to allow inmates to seek DNA testing on evidence that could potentially establish their innocence, as long as the evidence had not yet been tested or was subjected to less-reliable, now-obsolete testing.

The bill, signed by Gov. Rick Perry, specified that the potential evidence could include saliva and skin cells.

A bill is still being drafted for the 2015 legislative session, which begins in January, but Ellis predicted that addressing the appeals court decision would require a “minor fix” specifying that the Legislature intends to have courts lean toward granting, not denying, DNA tests.

“I want to make this legislative fix so it is abundantly clear that this Texas Legislature meant want we said … with regard to testing material that might exonerate someone,” Ellis said.

Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Local

Rick Perry chimes in on A&M student election; social media reacts
Rick Perry chimes in on A&M student election; social media reacts

Rick Perry, the former governor of Texas and current U.S. energy secretary, questioned the legitimacy of Texas A&M’s student elections in an opinion piece published Wednesday in the Houston Chronicle. Perry wrote that his alma mater’s disqualification of former student body president candidate Robert McIntosh, who garnered the most votes...
Conservation nonprofit breaking new ground in education
Conservation nonprofit breaking new ground in education

R. Brent Lyles has been in environmental education his whole career, from the time he taught seventh-grade science in a poor, rural county in North Carolina to today as executive director of the Colorado River Alliance. The nonprofit is tasked with advocating for the Colorado River, the source of Austin’s water and an economic engine of Central...
Community news: First ‘CodeTalk’ on Wednesday about environment

TRAVIS COUNTY DOWNTOWN AUSTIN First ‘CodeTalk’ on environment The city of Austin will hold its first of five “CodeTalk” sessions from 5 to 7 p.m. Wednesday at Austin City Hall, 301 W. Second St. CodeTalks are topic-based information sessions open to the general public but tailored to those who have profound interests in specific...
Austin board to vote on land parcels, preview revised facilities plan
Austin board to vote on land parcels, preview revised facilities plan

The Austin school board on Monday night is expected to approve the purchase of three land parcels for the expansion of Bowie High School and a future high school in Southeast Austin. Trustees will consider two smaller tracts next to the overcapacity Bowie High School that would go toward a multimillion-dollar expansion and modernization of the school...
Mulling Trump, trains and Lone Star while waiting on MoPac to open

I’ve got questions … What, for instance, does the president really think about trains? Some transit supporters, perhaps creatively looking for silver linings, speculated shortly after Nov. 8 that Donald Trump, having spent his life surrounded by New York subways and commuter trains, might be into locomotion. Can you really picture the...
More Stories